Hay Gone

[jourgo]

WC need him more than Freo. Glass is effectively scrap metal.

I'll take Glass over Hay any day of the week. In fact I'll take Glass over any fullback in the league, bar one (and the way things are going, soon I wouldn't swap Glass even for him!)

 

[jess-jess]

I can't believe some of the garbage some people are saying at how low Hay is worth, i have heard people more then willing to give up 1st rd pick to players that are almost finished, and older (e.g. Primus), Hay is anything but finished, he is a AA, about to come into his prime, yet he is only worth a 2nd rounder or less? considering this coming draft is weak (by all talks) with potientially 3 PP, a 1st rounder is more then justified, or a player of note.

He may very well be worth more, but if he's told them he's going no matter what at the end of the year, they might have to settle for below his actual value in order to get anything for him at all....

 

[feher]

He may very well be worth more, but if he's told them he's going no matter what at the end of the year, they might have to settle for below his actual value in order to get anything for him at all....

we can always do another backdoor rawlings type deal with the tiges/dogs especially if they are offering something better the eagles/dockers

 

[Goldenblue]

Hay >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Glass/Haddrill

Morons.

Hay was AA at the same age as Glass and Haddrill. Even in an injury interrupted year Stacks has beaten the likes of Tredrea and Rocca -> Glass has done sfa.

Tool.

Try watching a game of footy. Hay has been a hack since he had 1 decent season when he made the AA. Glass is better than Hay now.

 

[F-U]

Your all idiots. Reports say that if he doesnt go to the West he will quit so there is no chance of him going to Tigerland..

Although that could be a idle threat.....if he is actually leaving.....

 

[Robin Hood]

Your all idiots. Reports say that if he doesnt go to the West he will quit so there is no chance of him going to Tigerland..

Although that could be a idle threat.....if he is actually leaving.....

Altohugh tiger land would look far more attractive than hawthorn atm

 

[Goldenblue]

Your all idiots. Reports say that if he doesnt go to the West he will quit so there is no chance of him going to Tigerland..

Although that could be a idle threat.....if he is actually leaving.....

Enjoy retirement Hay.

 

[F-U]

The dole line looks far more attravtive then Hawthorn atm

 

[Robin Hood]

Enjoy retirement Hay.

Enjoy thinking Glass is better than the undisputed Key Defender of the year.

 

[feher]

Your all idiots. Reports say that if he doesnt go to the West he will quit so there is no chance of him going to Tigerland..

Although that could be a idle threat.....if he is actually leaving.....

hahaha he is 25, he aint gonna give up money, i can almost guarrantee that!

 

[94_Eagles]

Glass has held his FF to 6 goals in the last 6 weeks. Including Fev and Lloyd. Pretty good effort if u ask me.

 

[Robin Hood]

Glass has held his FF to 6 goals in the last 6 weeks. Including Fev and Lloyd. Pretty good effort if u ask me.

not doubting its a good effort, its just ludicrous b4 than eagles fans are sayin he is better than scarlett.

 

[superstar]

The dole line looks far more attravtive then Hawthorn atm

People are getting $300000 on the dole these days? My boss is in for a rude awakening if that's true.

 

[tige19]

I'll take Glass over Hay any day of the week. In fact I'll take Glass over any fullback in the league, bar one (and the way things are going, soon I wouldn't swap Glass even for him!)

Can someone save this and keep it for the BF yearly Awards?? surely this post will win hands downs as the most pathetic post this year.

Still cant believe what my eyes are witnessing. Mate you have serious problems........... anyway who the hell is Glass??? someone fill me in .

cheers

 

[Robin Hood]

People are getting $300000 on the dole these days? My boss is in for a rude awakening if that's true.

no one said the dole paid $300,000 but maybe Hawthorn is that much a ******** hole he would rather live on $15,000 than go to glenferrie. ******** i know i would.

 

[Robin Hood]

Can someone save this and keep it for the BF yearly Awards?? surely this post will win hands downs as the most pathetic post this year.

Still cant believe what my eyes are witnessing. Mate you have serious problems........... anyway who the hell is Glass??? someone fill me in .

cheers

Dont bother saving it just give him the Award for the next 20 years.

 

[superstar]

no one said the dole paid $300,000 but maybe Hawthorn is that much a ******** hole he would rather live on $15,000 than go to glenferrie. ******** i know i would.

Apologies to dogs fans for pre-edited comments.

 

[Robin Hood]

That's because you support the dogs. The prospect of a job probably doesn't appeal (unless it's tax free).

I barrack for Geelong - the dole is taxed.

 

[zero]

the problem with hay and gaspar is that they are the premier backmen at their clubs, and week in week out they take the biggest threat, have to run and create all day. they are injury prone, because they shoulder the heaviest load in the comp. "hey jon, not bad on tredrea last week, jon brown this week....."

now i think gaspar is over the hill, but if the eagles take on hay and treat him right, make him the second or third defender, rather than being accountable to the treadreas (although he can do that when neccessary, on rotation for example), experience and leadership for all our young KPPs, dont play him if hes not 100%, basically maximize his games per season, then i think hes got 3 or 4 good years left, then a couple of veteran years too.

johnson and a second rounder for him is a little biassed in the eagles favour, but if he really wants to leave.....

 

[Goldenblue]

Enjoy thinking Glass is better than the undisputed Key Defender of the year.

Where did I say Glass was better than Scarlett??

Glass I said was better than Hay.

Scarlett deserves to win the AA spot by a touch over Glass on form and consistency.

 

[Altum Volantes]

Can someone save this and keep it for the BF yearly Awards?? surely this post will win hands downs as the most pathetic post this year.

Still cant believe what my eyes are witnessing. Mate you have serious problems........... anyway who the hell is Glass??? someone fill me in .

cheers

Why bother comment when you obviously don't watch one of the players in this topic play?...

What's that? you mean the majority of the posters in this topic are in the same boat as yourself?? Well theres a big shock.

Anyway, to suggest Darren Glass is a hack would be very wrong, to suggest he's amoung the best 2-3 full backs going around would be over the top but the fact of the matter is, the Eagles already have a very promising full back prospect in Darren Glass which would suggest they don't need to pay out for an injury prone Jon Hay who may or may not one day recapture his excellent form of 3 years back.

But that said, I'd welcome Hay coming to the Eagles, for the right price of course, another key defensive option would add some more depth to the side.

 

[Robin Hood]

Where did I say Glass was better than Scarlett??

Glass I said was better than Hay.

Scarlett deserves to win the AA spot by a touch over Glass on form and consistency.

start of the thread eagle fans were saying that - Scarlett would better than glass even if he wasnt consitent

 

[Goldenblue]

Why bother comment when you obviously don't watch one of the players in this topic play?...

What's that? you mean the majority of the posters in this topic are in the same boat as yourself?? Well theres a big shock.

Anyway, to suggest Darren Glass is a hack would be very wrong, to suggest he's amoung the best 2-3 full backs going around would be over the top but the fact of the matter is, the Eagles already have a very promising full back prospect in Darren Glass which would suggest they don't need to pay out for an injury prone Jon Hay who may or may not one day recapture his excellent form of 3 years back.

But that said, I'd welcome Hay coming to the Eagles, for the right price of course, another key defensive option would add some more depth to the side.

Would you put Hay in the best 22 if he was at the Eagles?

My fear BJJ, is that Hay may end up being another Collica and play a few games with the Eagles, injury and form may keep him in and out and he will end up playing WAFL for the rest of his career.

Draft picks on youth are the only way to go, not injury prone players.

 

[Goldenblue]

start of the thread eagle fans were saying that - Scarlett would better than glass even if he wasnt consitent

Then don't quote my post.

 

[Total Package]

anyway who the hell is Glass??? someone fill me in .

cheers

Funny because 12 months ago I was saying "Who the hell is Scarlett???"