Herald Sun Super Coach 2007

[moony]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

1. Brown (BAC)
2. Johncock (BAC)
3. Mundy (BAC)
4. Boyle (BAC) res
5. Koschitzke (BAC)
6. Riggio (BAC) res
7. Cornes (BAC)
8. Birchall (BAC)
9. Gilbee (BAC)

10. Foley (CTR)
11. Ball (CTR)
12. Rischitelli (CTR)
13. Lappin (CTR)
14. Gibbs (CTR) res
15. Thomas (CTR) res
16. Cross (CTR)
17. Kerr (CTR)

18. Sandilands (RUC)
19. Darcy (RUC)
20. Hudson (RUC) res
21. Renouf (RUC) res

22. Davey (FWD) res
23. Riewoldt (FWD)
24. Pavlich (FWD)
25. Brown (FWD)
26. Fevola (FWD)
27. Franklin (FWD)
28. Cloke (FWD)
29. Murphy (FWD)
30. Edwards (FWD) res

thoughts and tips to improve appreciated.

 

[pol06]

sam fisher over nathan g brown. by a long long way

 

[SJ]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

LOL reconsider Judd? He will get you avg. of ateast 120 per week, thats 240 as captain. can't go wrong.

You've missed my point. That's why I will do well and you will not.

 

[moony]

sam fisher over nathan g brown. by a long long way

cheers mate

 

[Tigerrific]

Re: Do you think i can improve my SC team

DEF:
Sincalir
Adcock
Leigh Fisher
McPhee
McMahon
Birchall
Rooke

MID:
C.Bruce
S.Black
C.Enright
Giansiracusa
Deldio
B.Gibbs

Ruck:
White
Ackland

Fowards:
Brad Johnson
Paul Chapman
Brendan Fevola
Corey Jones
Alan Didak
Kayne Pettifer
Alwyn Davey

Bench:Tim Boyle, Dean D ick
D. Armitage, Daniel O'Keefe
Shane Neaves, Angus Graham
Leroy Jetta, Andrew Kraquer

Gibbs certainly hasn't set the world on fire yet and I wouldn't have him in my starting line-up (may be an ok reserve). Why dont you try someone like Lindsay Thomas instead.

Also I think I read somewhere that Didak is injured and will have a late start to the season. Someone else may be able to confirm this for you.

 

[lenny20]

sam fisher over nathan g brown. by a long long way

I disagree... if you're talking bout the melbourne nathan brown, then he dominated a couple of years ago. Only played 8 games last year through injury, never really hit his stride, so could be a bargain with a good pre-season under his belt.

Fisher came from nowhere to be very good for the saints last year, couldn't have played much better. Will be harder now that he is a known player, won't go under the radar, may be tagged, and given that it is a fitter saints team will have more competition for a place. Can't see him improving on last year.

Take a punt... back brown

Besides, pol06 is a saints fan... biased as

 

[peter_ford]

Re: Do you think i can improve my SC team

Gibbs certainly hasn't set the world on fire yet and I wouldn't have him in my starting line-up (may be an ok reserve). Why dont you try someone like Lindsay Thomas instead.

Also I think I read somewhere that Didak is injured and will have a late start to the season. Someone else may be able to confirm this for you.

yeah gibbs is nothing special, he seems out of place whereas guys like joel selwood look right at home and didak probably wont come back till round 3 or 4.

 

[jbomb3000]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Ok guys here goes

BACKS
C.Cornes
P.Bowden
J.Adcock
L.Fisher
N.Bock
A.Walker
B.Jones
T.Boyle (Em)
X.Ellis (Em)

I'm not 100% on Adcock or Bock, replacements for the same price?????

CENTERS
S.Mitchell
N.Stevens
S.Black
B.Delediuo
M.Murphy
N.Lappin
B.Gibbs (Em)
D.Armitage (Em)

I'm happy with my centers, happy to take a punt on Lappin while i have Gibbs as a Em

RUCKS
D.Cox
B.Hudson
L.Darcy (Em)
J.Griffin (Em)

I'm a bit torn about the rucks as i think Hudson and Darcy will both appreciate but not confident enough to start them both, might keep it as is and use one as a cash cow

FOWARDS
B.Fevola
J.Akermanis
C.Tarrant
N.Brown
L.Franklin
S.Milne
A.Hanson
J.Koschitzke (Em)
A.Edwards (Em)

I think this is proably my weakest point, Franklin's consistency worries me and while i think Milne and Hanson are good value not sure if i want to start both, mabey out of Milne, Hanson and Kosi keep one and replace the other 2 with 1 better player and a cheap player as a em???

I'm new at this guys so any help/comments whould be appreciated, Cheers

 

[GmeUP]

How does this team look?

Backs: J.Bowden, Milburn, Waters, C.Johnson, Raines, Birchall, Kosi [Ellis, S.Hunt]

Centres: Cousins, Dal Santo, Moody, Murphy, Pendlebury, Lappin [Houli, Selwood]

Rucks: Cox, Sandilands [Griffen, Ryder]

Forwards: Hall, Pav, Riewoldt, G.Ablett, Monfries, N.G.Brown, T.Cloke [Edwards, Davey]

 

[Ted]

Andrew Carrazzo or Jordan McMahon?

 

[borgy]

Andrew Carrazzo or Jordan McMahon?

Carrazzo

 

[borgy]

Re: Do you think i can improve my SC team

Rucks are hopeless.

 

[borgy]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Ok guys here goes

BACKS
C.Cornes
P.Bowden
J.Adcock
L.Fisher
N.Bock
A.Walker
B.Jones
T.Boyle (Em)
X.Ellis (Em)

I'm not 100% on Adcock or Bock, replacements for the same price?????

CENTERS
S.Mitchell
N.Stevens
S.Black
B.Delediuo
M.Murphy
N.Lappin
B.Gibbs (Em)
D.Armitage (Em)

I'm happy with my centers, happy to take a punt on Lappin while i have Gibbs as a Em

RUCKS
D.Cox
B.Hudson
L.Darcy (Em)
J.Griffin (Em)

I'm a bit torn about the rucks as i think Hudson and Darcy will both appreciate but not confident enough to start them both, might keep it as is and use one as a cash cow

FOWARDS
B.Fevola
J.Akermanis
C.Tarrant
N.Brown
L.Franklin
S.Milne
A.Hanson
J.Koschitzke (Em)
A.Edwards (Em)

I think this is proably my weakest point, Franklin's consistency worries me and while i think Milne and Hanson are good value not sure if i want to start both, mabey out of Milne, Hanson and Kosi keep one and replace the other 2 with 1 better player and a cheap player as a em???

I'm new at this guys so any help/comments whould be appreciated, Cheers

Hansen is injured.

 

[PalaceEagles]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Backs:
A.Mcloed
D.Milburn
H.Shaw
J.Gibson
R.Hayden
J.Walker
C.Johnson (Melbourne)​

J.Koschitzke
X.Ellis​

Centres:
S.Black
M.Rischitelli
J.Lewis
M.Murphy
S.Byrnes

D.Rodan
B.Gibbs

Rucks:
C.Mooney
A.Sandilands

B.Hudson
J.White

Forwards:
B.Hall
N.Riewoltd

B.Fevola
R.Murphy
A.Monfries
N.Brown
L.Franklin​

A.Davey
A.Edwards​

Any thoughts? would be much appreciated​

 

[shiva25]

Re: My supercoach team...

Well lets see yours then.

Sorry cant give anything away but i am happy to say i will finish a lot higher than 99% of the teams that have been posted here

 

[Blinger]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Backs:
A.Mcloed
D.Milburn
H.Shaw
J.Gibson
R.Hayden
J.Walker
C.Johnson (Melbourne)​

J.Koschitzke
X.Ellis​

Centres:
S.Black
M.Rischitelli
J.Lewis
M.Murphy
S.Byrnes

D.Rodan
B.Gibbs

Rucks:
C.Mooney
A.Sandilands

B.Hudson
J.White

Forwards:
B.Hall
N.Riewoltd

B.Fevola
R.Murphy
A.Monfries
N.Brown
L.Franklin​

A.Davey
A.Edwards​

Any thoughts? would be much appreciated​

You are missing a midfielder. It looks like a solid team, yet I would keep experimenting with the line-up. There are players in your team that I think you can improve on, yet overall not a bad squad

 

[jbomb3000]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Hansen is injured.

Thanks for the heads up on hanson, any one else have any thoughts or comments???

 

[borgy]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Backs:

A.Mcloed
D.Milburn
H.Shaw
J.Gibson
R.Hayden
J.Walker
C.Johnson (Melbourne)​

J.Koschitzke
X.Ellis​

Centres:
S.Black
M.Rischitelli
J.Lewis
M.Murphy
S.Byrnes

D.Rodan
B.Gibbs

Rucks:
C.Mooney
A.Sandilands

B.Hudson
J.White

Forwards:
B.Hall
N.Riewoltd

B.Fevola
R.Murphy
A.Monfries
N.Brown
L.Franklin​

A.Davey
A.Edwards​

Any thoughts? would be much appreciated​

Thats another team with Monfries in it. Is he worth consideration?

Overall not a bad team, well done

 

[moony]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

backs
N D Brown
G Johncock
D Mundy
J Koschitzke
C Cornes
G Birchall
L Gilbee

T Boyle
M Riggio

centres
N Foley
L Ball
S Black
N Lappin
S Mitchell
D Kerr

B Gibbs
L Thomas

rucks
A Sandilands
B Hudson

L Darcy
B Renouf

forwards
N Riewoldt
M Pavlich
N G Brown
B Fevola
L Franklin
T Cloke
R Murphy

A Edwards
A Davey

reasonably happy with my team but still could change a bit before round 1

 

[SJ]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Thats another team with Monfries in it. Is he worth consideration?

Overall not a bad team, well done

I have him too.

 

[borgy]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

I have him too.

Why? What was his average last year and why do you have him this year?

 

[SJ]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

backs
N D Brown
G Johncock
D Mundy
J Koschitzke
C Cornes
G Birchall
L Gilbee

T Boyle
M Riggio

centres
N Foley
L Ball
S Black
N Lappin
S Mitchell
D Kerr

B Gibbs
L Thomas

rucks
A Sandilands
B Hudson

L Darcy
B Renouf

forwards
N Riewoldt
M Pavlich
N G Brown
B Fevola
L Franklin
T Cloke
R Murphy

A Edwards
A Davey

reasonably happy with my team but still could change a bit before round 1

That's one of the best I've seen so far. I've got Gibbs too (as would many others) - is he really going to be the best value? He hasn't done much so far.

 

[SJ]

Re: My supercoach team...

1. Saddington CARL (BAC)
2. Miller MELB (BAC)
3. O'hAilpin CARL (RESERVE)(BAC)
4. Hansen NORTH (RESERVE)(BAC)
5. Rooke GEEL (BAC)
6. Polak RICH (BAC)
7. Scarlett GEEL (BAC)
8. Gilbee FOOTS (BAC)
9. Raines RICH (BAC)
10. Lappin BRIS (CTR)
11. Houli ESS (RESERVE)(CTR)
12. Thomas NORTH (RESERVE)(CTR)
13. Bartel GEEL (CTR)
14. Prismall GEEL (CTR)
15. Murphy CARL (CTR)
16. Hodge HAW (CTR)
17. Griffen FOOTS (CTR)
18. Mooney GEEL (RESERVE) (RUC)
19. Ottens GEEL (RUC)
20. Darcy FOOTS (RESERVE) (RUC)
21. Cox WCE(RUC)
22. Koschitzke STK (FWD)
23. Hawkins GEEL (RESERVE) (FWD)
24. Edwards NORTH (RESERVE) (FWD)
25. Franklin HAW (FWD)
26. Waite CARL (FWD)
27. Johnson FOOTS (FWD)
28. Fevola CARL (FWD)
29. G.Ablett GEEL (FWD)
30. N.Brown RICH(FWD)

thoughts?

i got 4.5K left

Mate way too many Geelong players. 8/30 - you've got to be kidding me.

Edit: Also, Mooney as a reserve? Unbelievable. Don't expect to go well with that side.

 

[SJ]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Why? What was his average last year and why do you have him this year?

66.24.

 

[richmond fanatic]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Backs
Gilbee
Johncock
C.Cornes
Mundy
McPhee
Koschitzke
Hunter

McGuane
Boyle

Centres
Kerr
Ball
Rischitelli
Cross
Lappin
S.Thompson

Rodan
Thomas

Rucks
Sandlilands
Hudson

Griffin
Cloke

Forwards
Riewoldt
N.Brown
T.Cloke
Aaron Davey
Fevola
R.Murphy
Ottens

Edwards]
A.Davey

Suggestions, critics would be much appreciated