Herald Sun Super Coach 2007

[Ed_Gein]

Re: My supercoach team...

Sorry cant give anything away but i am happy to say i will finish a lot higher than 99% of the teams that have been posted here

Where did you finish last season? I look forward to giving you a decent challenge.

 

[Patty#32]

Re: Rate My Team...

- Get cheaper midfielders (as their are alot who still score well for low prices) EG. K.Johnson, J.Lewis, Griffen
- That gives you money to upgrade forward line....
- Maybe get Sandilands and someone cheaper as i believe Sandilands will be AA this year i chose Sandi and Darcy... if you need more cash??

 

[Patty#32]

Re: Backline strategy (SuperCoach)

I would probably not sepnd so much on backline as now im sure you have a crap midfieeld and not so strong forward line...
Get rid of Goddard for maybe someone like J.Adcock or someone around that price...
Gilbee for Sinclair/Johncock as WB have alot of running players from backline... McMahon, Griffen etc.

 

[motorvinnie]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

I need help.. critics and suggestions are welcome cheers

BACK LINE:
1. BOWDEN, Joel (RIC)
$644,500
2. BOWDEN, Patrick (RIC)
$504,400
3. PETRIE, Drew (KAN)
$461,700
4. RIVERS, Jared (MEL)
$440,800
5. PETTIGREW, Michael (PTA)
$296,200
6. O'HAILPIN, Setanta (CAR)
$259,900
7. DRUM, Marcus (FRE)
$196,800

CENTRE:
8. JUDD, Chris (WCE)
$687,700
9. GOODES, Adam (SYD)
$618,700
10. WEST, Scott (WBD)
$570,200
11. BLACK, Simon (BRL)
$513,800
12. SALOPEK, Steven (PTA)
$436,700
13. KOUTOUFIDES, Anthony (CAR)
$417,600

RUCK:
14. HUDSON, Ben (ADE)
$198,600
15. JAMAR, Mark (MEL)
$190,900


FORWARD:
16. FEVOLA, Brendan (CAR)
$499,700
17. AKERMANIS, Jason (WBD)
$483,200
18. LE CRAS, Mark (WCE)
$482,600
19. FRANKLIN, Lance (HAW)
$324,600
20. SAMPI, Ashley (WCE)
$305,300
21. FISHER, Brad (CAR)
$278,200
22. CLOKE, Travis (COL)
$259,300

RESERVES:
23. HANSEN, Lachlan (KAN)
$130,200
24. FRAWLEY, James (MEL)
$90,200
25. SELWOOD, Joel (GEE)
$110,200
26. BROWNE, Andrew (FRE)
$90,200
27. BAILEY, Max (HAW)
$105,600
28. GRAHAM, Angus (RIC)
$83,400
29. KOSCHITZKE, Justin (STK)
$164,900
30. KENNEDY, Josh (CAR)
$130,500

Help needed, all suggestions welcome.. cheers

 

[lion_gooner]

Re: Backline strategy (SuperCoach)

i reckon having a great backline is the key to having a good team and theres alot diffrence between class and duds in the backline so choose carefully im pretty sure i have lol

 

[Patty#32]

Rate My Supercoach Team

BACKS:
- Cornes
- Johncock
- Sinclair
- Waters
- Birchall
- Raines
- J.Walker
- J.Smith(EMG)
- T.Boyle(EMG)

CENTRES:
- Pearce
- Mitchell
- Rischitelli
- M.Murphy
- K.Johnson
- Giansiracusa
- L.Thomas(EMG)
- Houli(EMG)

RUCKS:
- Sandilands
- Darcy
- Sellar(EMG)
- Renouf(EMG)

FORWARDS:
- B.Johnson
- Hall
- Pavlich
- Fevola
- Franklin
- Monfries
- Brown
- Davey(EMG)
- Edwards(EMG)

ANY THING I NEED TO CHANGE GUYS?
ALL HELP APPRECIATED!!!

 

[Tuffshagga]

Whens Tomahawk (Hawkins) gunna get a game this year?

 

[SJ]

Whens Tomahawk (Hawkins) gunna get a game this year?

Not for a while.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

I need help.. critics and suggestions are welcome cheers

NON-SCORING PLAYERS

1. Dempster (BAC) 02. Frawley (BAC) 03. Bowden (BAC) 04. Drum (BAC) 05. O'hAilpin (BAC) 06. Bowden (BAC) 07. Rivers (BAC) 08. Whelan (BAC) 09. Pettigrew (BAC) 010. Goodes (CTR) 011. Selwood (CTR) 012. Deledio (CTR) 013. Browne (CTR) 014. Koutoufides (CTR) 015. West (CTR) 016. Jones (CTR) 017. Judd (CTR) 018. Jamar (RUC) 019. Graham (RUC) 020. Bailey (RUC) 021. Biglands (RUC) 022. Kennedy (FWD) 023. Akermanis (FWD) 024. Sampi (FWD) 025. Le Cras (FWD) 026. Franklin (FWD) 027. Fevola (FWD) 028. Fisher (FWD) 029. Koschitzke (FWD) 030. Cloke (FWD

You've overloaded too heavily on midfielders.

 

[lion_gooner]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

max bailey has done his knee and will be put for the season which is a shame

i really would have liked to have been able to pick him

 

[Crave]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

Backs:
A.Mcloed
D.Milburn
H.Shaw
J.Gibson
R.Hayden
J.Walker
C.Johnson (Melbourne)​

J.Koschitzke
X.Ellis​

Centres:
S.Black
M.Rischitelli
J.Lewis
M.Murphy
S.Byrnes

D.Rodan
B.Gibbs

Rucks:
C.Mooney
A.Sandilands

B.Hudson
J.White

Forwards:
B.Hall
N.Riewoltd

B.Fevola
R.Murphy
A.Monfries
N.Brown
L.Franklin​

A.Davey
A.Edwards​

Any thoughts? would be much appreciated​

Im pretty sure Riewoldt has a dodgy hamstring at the minute...might want to look at someone else for round one. Dont stress if he scores well as player's prices dont change till after round 4.

 

[moony]

Re: Rate My Supercoach Team

BACKS:
- Cornes
- Johncock
- Sinclair
- Waters
- Birchall
- Raines
- J.Walker
- J.Smith(EMG)
- T.Boyle(EMG)

CENTRES:
- Pearce
- Mitchell
- Rischitelli
- M.Murphy
- K.Johnson
- Giansiracusa
- L.Thomas(EMG)
- Houli(EMG)

RUCKS:
- Sandilands
- Darcy
- Sellar(EMG)
- Renouf(EMG)

FORWARDS:
- B.Johnson
- Hall
- Pavlich
- Fevola
- Franklin
- Monfries
- Brown
- Davey(EMG)
- Edwards(EMG)

ANY THING I NEED TO CHANGE GUYS?
ALL HELP APPRECIATED!!!

not a bad side mate the only thing i would change is to get a little more depth in the rucks if you could somehow get someone like hudson in on the bench would be good.

cheers and good luck with it

 

[worthy]

Re: Rate My Supercoach Team

Not too bad, just a couple of areas:

J. Smith - won't play for several weeks, great chance to cash in a cash cow and pick him up cheap when he starts playing.

Sellar - maybe others more likely to play.

K. Johnson - better available
Waters - Might be ok ????

Backs and Centres could be stronger.

That's the first and last time I pass advice.

 

[Crave]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

MY TEAM IS:

Backs:
J. Bowden (Rich)
Mattner (Ade)
McPhee (Ess)
Gibson (Kang)
Polak (Rich)
Walker (Freo)
Kosi (Saints)

Reserves:
Frawley (Melb)
Ellis (Hawks)

Centres:
Dal Santo (Saints)
West (Dogs)
Hodge (Hawks)
Prismall (Cats)
Rodan (Port)
Black (Lions)

Reserves:
Gibbs (Blues)
Selwood (Cats)

Rucks:
Sandilands (Freo)
Darcy (Dogs)

Reserves:
Sellar (Ade)
Leuenberger (Lions)

Forwards:
Richardson (Rich)
Nathan G. Brown (Rich)
Fevola (Blues)
Neitz (Melb)
Williams (Hawks)
Lloyd (Ess)
Pavlich (Freo)

Reserves:
Jericho (Ade)
Krakeour (Port)

Any thoughts?

Get rid of Mattner...I used him a few times in 05 and had him in for 2 rounds last season...pretty weak in scoring for a midfielder. As for Darcy...seeing as prices dont change till Round 4, pick someone like Ryder in his place...free up almost 100K, this will allow you to boost another position and look at Darcy before jumping on him too early on.

 

[Jeremias]

Andrew Carrazzo or Jordan McMahon?

Definitely Carrazzo.

 

[SJ]

Re: Rate My Supercoach Team

not a bad side mate the only thing i would change is to get a little more depth in the rucks if you could somehow get someone like hudson in on the bench would be good.

cheers and good luck with it

Looks like everyone's sides are just getting closer and closer to the exact same 22.

 

[Crave]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

I need help.. critics and suggestions are welcome cheers

BACK LINE:
1. BOWDEN, Joel (RIC)
$644,500
2. BOWDEN, Patrick (RIC)
$504,400
3. PETRIE, Drew (KAN)
$461,700
4. RIVERS, Jared (MEL)
$440,800
5. PETTIGREW, Michael (PTA)
$296,200
6. O'HAILPIN, Setanta (CAR)
$259,900
7. DRUM, Marcus (FRE)
$196,800

CENTRE:
8. JUDD, Chris (WCE)
$687,700
9. GOODES, Adam (SYD)
$618,700
10. WEST, Scott (WBD)
$570,200
11. BLACK, Simon (BRL)
$513,800
12. SALOPEK, Steven (PTA)
$436,700
13. KOUTOUFIDES, Anthony (CAR)
$417,600

RUCK:
14. HUDSON, Ben (ADE)
$198,600
15. JAMAR, Mark (MEL)
$190,900


FORWARD:
16. FEVOLA, Brendan (CAR)
$499,700
17. AKERMANIS, Jason (WBD)
$483,200
18. LE CRAS, Mark (WCE)
$482,600
19. FRANKLIN, Lance (HAW)
$324,600
20. SAMPI, Ashley (WCE)
$305,300
21. FISHER, Brad (CAR)
$278,200
22. CLOKE, Travis (COL)
$259,300

RESERVES:
23. HANSEN, Lachlan (KAN)
$130,200
24. FRAWLEY, James (MEL)
$90,200
25. SELWOOD, Joel (GEE)
$110,200
26. BROWNE, Andrew (FRE)
$90,200
27. BAILEY, Max (HAW)
$105,600
28. GRAHAM, Angus (RIC)
$83,400
29. KOSCHITZKE, Justin (STK)
$164,900
30. KENNEDY, Josh (CAR)
$130,500

Help needed, all suggestions welcome.. cheers

You wont get many points from the players in bold. Bailey is injured, so you can replace him with a kid and use 20k elsewhere.

 

[Crave]

Off the top of my head, Hall, O'Keefe and Goodes are really the only big score getters from the Swans.

Spot on!

 

[Crave]

Im surprised very few have gone for Jobe Watson...gets a tonne of it every week and its not unlike him to pick up 10 possessions in any quarter, as he plays so close to stoppages. Great football brain too.

 

[dmc333]

Im surprised very few have gone for Jobe Watson...gets a tonne of it every week and its not unlike him to pick up 10 possessions in any quarter, as he plays so close to stoppages. Great football brain too.

Maybe his value is spot on though, he was major value last year.

 

[moony]

Re: Rate My Supercoach Team

Looks like everyone's sides are just getting closer and closer to the exact same 22.

yeah its starting to get that way maybe we will all go down in a screaming heap together

 

[Crave]

Maybe his value is spot on though, he was major value last year.

Yeah, good point.

 

[lion_gooner]

maybe people are worried about the 2nd season blues thats why im not picking birchall,symes or watson

 

[Blinger]

Re: Rate My Supercoach Team

yeah its starting to get that way maybe we will all go down in a screaming heap together

Must say my team is a fair bit different to what I have seen posted.

 

[T-I-G-E-R-M-A-N]

Re: "Post Supercoach Teams here!!!"

1. Gibson (BAC) 02. McPharlin (BAC) 03. Raines (BAC) 4. Birchall (BAC) 5. Brennan (BAC) 6. Hansen (BAC) 7. Frawley (BAC) 8. Wirrpunda (BAC) 9. Bowden (BAC) 10. West (CTR) 11. Embley (CTR) 12. Harris (CTR) 13. Foley (CTR) 14. Thomas (CTR) 15. Higgins (CTR) 16. Giansiracusa (CTR) 17. Thompson (CTR) 18. West (RUC) 19. Pattison (RUC) 20. Cloke (RUC) 21. Graham (RUC) 22. Mooney (FWD) 23. Monfries (FWD) 24. Pavlich (FWD) 25. Ablett (FWD) 26. McDougall (FWD) 27. Johnson (FWD) 28. Edwards (FWD) 29. Fevola (FWD) 30. Schulz (FWD)

Dont no how the teams gonna fir out lol... giving it a crack, comments and help appreciated cheers