Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[Brahma Bull]

What are peoples thoughts on Tadhg Kennelly?

and should i get Houli or Dyson?

 

[hellfire]

Just wondering what people think of these players???
Backs:
D myers Ess
X Ellis Haw
C johns Ess
M Maguie Stk

Midfield:
R Dyson Ess
T Cotchin Rich
R Shirly Adel

Forwards:
S Dew Haw
T Hawkins Geel

Has anyone got some good replacements

I wouldn't consider the ones in bold (personally, it's obviously up to you). The others are okay.

 

[Big Nasty]

Just wondering what people think of these players???
Backs:
D myers Ess
X Ellis Haw
C johns Ess
M Maguie Stk

Midfield:
R Dyson Ess
T Cotchin Rich
R Shirly Adel

Forwards:
S Dew Haw
T Hawkins Geel

Has anyone got some good replacements

The ones in Bold I would look at.

 

[Big Nasty]

What are peoples thoughts on Tadhg Kennelly?

and should i get Houli or Dyson?

Get Dyson

Alot of people are staying away from Kennely 'cause of coming back from injuries. I would say hold off.

 

[Big Nasty]

i need ppls opinions on::

leigh harding kan
s thompson kan
ibbotson kan
c bartram melb
connors rich
n thompson kan

on weather they will actually play and make money

Scott D Thompson should be a good emergency.

 

[beautime]

i need peoples opinions on

bock
slattery
hentschel

also I just traded kerr for priddis and have 169000 left over

Good/bad

 

[SJ]

Does anyone actually use the search engine before they ask about a player? Most have been asked about twenty times.

 

[beautime]

Does anyone actually use the search engine before they ask about a player? Most have been asked about twenty times.

could you direct me to where slattery, bock, and hentschel have been mentioned

thanks hero

 

[swansfan51]

could you direct me to where slattery, bock, and hentschel have been mentioned

thanks hero

Sorry I can't help you on the other 2, I don't think they've been discussed.

But to find threads on Bock search for "my 2007 season is screwed", "what is your worst ever selection?", "most over-hyped DT player 2007" or similar topics.

 

[Harmonic_9]

Will Dyson get many games for the bombers??And how did he go last year?
Cheers.

 

[SJ]

could you direct me to where slattery, bock, and hentschel have been mentioned

thanks hero

Wasn't referring to you champ.

 

[beautime]

Wasn't referring to you champ.

sorry mate

Slattery - worthy yes/no

 

[Toadvine]

pretty happy with this, what do you think

 

[SJ]

pretty happy with this, what do you think

A lot of your 23-30 players are not good choices.

 

[Toadvine]

Yeah i no what you mean like j.riewoldt, c.jones, and wight but what are some better choices then? i have 58k

 

[Sticks_Of_Fury]

Backs
R. Hayden
N. Bock
X.Ellis
G. Birchall
C. Newman
M. Nicoski
G. Johncock

A. Proud
D. Pfeiffer

Midfield
G. Ablett
S. Thompson
T. Johnstone
T. Boak
N. Stevens
S. Pendlebury


B. Houli
R. Palmer

Rucks
D. Gilmore
T. Simmonds

M. Bailey
S. Hampson

Forwards
J. Brown
S. Johnson
B. Deledio
R. Murphy
A. Didak
N. Thompson
L. Franklin

L. Hansen
C. Rioli

What do you think guys i have about 20k left any great worries i have taken a few chances. Would be great to get some feedback i have a a fair bit on the live for this years comp!

 

[HotCoffee]

Backs
R. Hayden
N. Bock
X.Ellis
G. Birchall
C. Newman
M. Nicoski
G. Johncock

A. Proud
D. Pfeiffer

Midfield
G. Ablett
S. Thompson
T. Johnstone
T. Boak
N. Stevens
S. Pendlebury
N. Stevens

B. Houli
R. Palmer

Rucks
D. Gilmore
T. Simmonds

Forwards
J. Brown
S. Johnson
B. Deledio
R. Murphy
A. Didak
N. Thompson
L. Franklin

L. Hansen
C. Rioli

What do you think guys i have about 20k left any great worries i have taken a few chances. Would be great to get some feedback i have a a fair bit on the live for this years comp!

Missing 2 rucks, you can't have Stevens twice. Where did all your cash go?!

 

[TigerGlory]

What are peoples thoughts on this side?

 

[Sticks_Of_Fury]

Missing 2 rucks, you can't have Stevens twice. Where did all your cash go?!

Woops! all fixed now. What do you mean by where did all your cash go?

 

[HotCoffee]

Woops! all fixed now. What do you mean by where did all your cash go?

I mean it doesn't look like there are enough genuine guns - too many mid priced average players.

 

[SJ]

What are peoples thoughts on this side?

Interesting leadership group.

 

[Sticks_Of_Fury]

I mean it doesn't look like there are enough genuine guns - too many mid priced average players.

Johncock
Stevens
Thompson
Ablett
Pendlebury
Newman
Brown
Johnson
Delidio
Franklin
Murphy
Simmonds
Didak
Johnstone

You dont think they are guns?? I expect them all to average around the 100 point mark. Of course they all wont however they do have the potential to. Everyplayer in my squad should play 22 games without injury.

 

[TigerGlory]

Interesting leadership group.

Its not final, but i knew you'd like it.

Generally, Steve Johnson does well in Supercoach, especially last year, i think him as Captain is a good choice personally.

 

[Mick_15]

ellis v roughhead v patfull v L.Fisher??

What do you think scarlett could be averaging this year? is he good value?

 

[rota69]

pretty happy with this, what do you think

Sorry but this team is not very good.