Highest aggregate score in a game (both teams scoring 100) - and LOWEST aggregate scores

[Connor7395]

One from South Bunbury's "Tale of the Tiger" document:

375 - WA - Carey Park 34.11.215 def South Bunbury 24.16.160 - South West FL - 1987

 

[Hawksboy72]

1982 VFL Reserves
Hawthorn 30.17.197
Collingwood 29.8.182
TOTAL
59.25.379

 

[Todman]

Opening round C Grade 1985 Eastern Suburban Churches Football Association.
407 point aggregate

Noble Park United

37​

17​

239​

Vs

Black Rock

25​

18​

168​

Same day Diamond Valley FL Div 1 344 points

Montmorency

32​

24​

216​

Vs

Reservoir

20​

8​

128​

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Opening round C Grade 1985 Eastern Suburban Churches Football Association.
407 point aggregate

Noble Park United

37​

17​

239​

Vs

Black Rock

25​

18​

168​

Same day Diamond Valley FL Div 1 344 points

Montmorency

32​

24​

216​

Vs

Reservoir

20​

8​

128​

A score of 168 and you lose by 71 points.

That’s awfully stiff.

 

[Connor7395]

Opening round C Grade 1985 Eastern Suburban Churches Football Association.
407 point aggregate

Noble Park United

37​

17​

239​

Vs

Black Rock

25​

18​

168​

Same day Diamond Valley FL Div 1 344 points

Montmorency

32​

24​

216​

Vs

Reservoir

20​

8​

128​

Finally a second game with a 400 point aggregate and both teams scoring 100!
80's ESCFA seems untapped because of so many missing scores from free online soruces (entire divisions missing from The Age as well)

 

[Sinjin Smith]

I'd love to see the breakdown of who kicked the goals and how many for these games.

 

[MortlockWatcher]

Technically that was an under-19's game, not sure if one can classify that as professional.

The VFA placed an asterisk next to a few scores like this in Geelong West Thirds matches because they were allowed to continue after the number of Geelong West players on the field fell below 14. From memory, as few as nine Roosters players were on the ground at the end of this match. When you are almost at double the strength of your opponents, a score of 110.27 definitely needs an asterisk.

For example on May 24 1981, Brunswick's Thirds piled on 77.44.506 and kept Geelong West scoreless. It was noted in the VFA Recorder the following weekend that neither the score nor the 506-point margin would count in official records as the Roosters did not field a full team.

 

[worbod]

Representative game:

349 - Vic - Clunes FL 35.21.231 def Maryborough DFL 17.16.118 - 1971

 

[Todman]

Bendigo FL 1991 1st Semi Final
Castlemaine	32​	25​	217​
Sandhurst	15​	15​	105​

 

[Todman]

Lexton FL 1946 2nd Semi Final
Waubra	31​	19​	205​
Navarre	16​	17​	113​

 

[worbod]

From Tasmania: Cooee 34.14 (218) vs 21.6 (132), April 28, 1984

 

[MortlockWatcher]

Panton Hill FL - 1987 2nd Semi Final

Keon Park 31.6.192
Coolaroo Rovers 27.18.180

(Match aggregate - 58.24.372)

 

[Gibbsy]

From Tasmania: Cooee 34.14 (218) vs 21.6 (132), April 28, 1984

Who was the opponent?

 

[worbod]

Who was the opponent?

Whoops, the opponent was Latrobe.

 

[Toucan Soup]

I've been doing some work on the SQAFA (South Qld Australian Football Association) First Division results - and found this one to share:

1982 Round 8 - 367 : South Brisbane 39 - 12 - 246 d Acacia Ridge 18 - 13 - 121

Bear in mind that there are some scores I haven't been able to locate yet - and whilst some of those are likely to have been thrashings, there is a fair chance that none relate to any games where both teams scored 100+.

(If anyone has any SQAFA/BAFL details to share, please feel free to contact me.)

 

[Toucan Soup]

In fact, having looked at the opening post again, I could offer these also:

All from SQAFA First Division

322 - 1987 Round 5: Aspley 32 - 12 - 204 d University of Qld 18 - 10 - 118
301 - 1982 Round 14: South Brisbane 24 - 16 - 160 d Aspley 21 - 15 - 141
300 - 1982 Round 6: South Brisbane 23 - 17 - 155 d Strathpine 21 - 19 - 145 (a margin of only 10 points)

Defence was not a priority in the 1982 season. Sherwood was the superior team of the competition in 1982. However, whilst they posted some mammoth scores, the Magpie defence was also good enough to keep other clubs well under 100 points.

 

[Toucan Soup]

And whilst I'm at it, I had a look back at the "QAFL level" competition. I have found records of 25 games resulting in an aggregate score of 300 or more, where both teams amassed 100+ points.
This includes the two shown in the opening post. Do you want the others to add to the list?

Two interesting ones, simply because of the narrow final margin:

303: 1980 Rd 21 (Gabba) - Sandgate 23-14-152 d Morningside 22-19-151 (1 point)
326: 1983 Rd 6 (O'Callaghan Park) - Windsor Zillmere 25-14-164 d Sherwood 24-18-162 (2 points)

 

[Connor7395]

And whilst I'm at it, I had a look back at the "QAFL level" competition. I have found records of 25 games resulting in an aggregate score of 300 or more, where both teams amassed 100+ points.
This includes the two shown in the opening post. Do you want the others to add to the list?

Two interesting ones, simply because of the narrow final margin:

303: 1980 Rd 21 (Gabba) - Sandgate 23-14-152 d Morningside 22-19-151 (1 point)
326: 1983 Rd 6 (O'Callaghan Park) - Windsor Zillmere 25-14-164 d Sherwood 24-18-162 (2 points)

Absolutely, thank you for your work.

 

[Toucan Soup]

Connor7395 , lets see how we go here:

The following is a list of QAFL results that match the criteria (aggregate score of 300+ where both teams manage a score of 100+), in descending order:

344: 1987 Rd 9 – Southport 37-22-244 d Morningside 14-16-100 (Owen Park)
339: 1987 Rd 6 - Wilston Grange 30-21-201 d Sherwood 21-12-138 (Hickey Park)
336: 1984 Rd 5 – Coorparoo 32-21-213 d Wilston Grange 18-15-123 (Hickey Park)
332: 1987 Rd 16 – Southport 28-18-186 d Wilston Grange 22-14-146 (Owen Park)
326: 1983 Rd 6 - Windsor Zillmere 25-14-164 d Sherwood 24-18-162 (O'Callaghan Park)
322: 1978 Rd 16 – Sandgate 33-21-219 d Kedron 15-13-103 (Lemke Road)
321: 1981 Rd 17 – Morningside 28-15-183 d Sandgate 21-12-138 (BCG)
320: 1982 Rd 10 – Coorparoo 31-17-203 d Wilston Grange 18-9-117 (Giffin Oval)
320: 1984 Rd 4 – Kedron 29-22-196 d Sherwood 19-10-124 (John Wren Oval)
318: 1984 Rd 13 – Southport 26-16-172 d Mayne 23-8-146 (Owen Park)
318: 1984 Rd 17 – Kedron 24-19-163 d Western Districts 24-11-155 (John Wren Oval)
317: 1981 Rd 16 – Mayne 25-21-171 d Western Districts 21-20-146 (BCG)
317: 1984 Rd 13 – Sherwood 27-14-176 d Kedron 22-9-141 (Cansdale Street)
316: 1985 Rd 17 – Morningside 26-12-168 d Kedron 23-10-148 (Hawthorne Park)
311: 1974 Rd 14 – Morningside 27-14-176 d Kedron 21-9-135 (Hawthorne Park)
306: 1979 Rd 21 - Western Districts 28-17-185 d Mayne 17-19-121 (Chelmer)
305: 1980 Rd 18 - Western Districts 25-21-171 d Windsor Zillmere 20-14-134 (BCG)
305: 1981 Rd 20 – Morningside 24-20-164 d Mayne 21-15-141 (BCG)
304: 1975 Rd 12 – Morningside 30-10-190 d Sandgate 17-12-114 (Hawthorne Park)
304: 1983 Rd 7 – Sherwood 27-23-185 d Western Districts 17-17-119 (Cansdale Street)
303: 1980 Rd 21 – Sandgate 23-14-152 d Morningside 22-19-151 (BCG)
302: 1954 Rd 2 – Sandgate 28-17-185 d Mayne 18-9-117 (Perry Park)
302: 1975 Rd 18 – Sandgate 27-20-182 d Wilston Grange 18-12-120 (Hickey Park)
301: 1988 Rd 16 – Mayne 28-18-186 d Western Districts 16-19-115 (Chelmer)

It first occurred in 1954 - and then didn't re-appear for a further 20 seasons. It certainly reflects a certain era of local football. Since 1988, only one result has got close (298 points in 1990).

I'm still working on lower grade scores, getting my database sorted out. The only comparable result I can find was in the AFLQ Premier Division in 2011 (underpinning the NEAFL comp locally):

315: 2011 Rd 6 – Sandgate 31-13-199 d Burleigh 18-8-116 (Bill Godfrey Oval )

Thanks.

 

[Connor7395]

Connor7395 , lets see how we go here:

The following is a list of QAFL results that match the criteria (aggregate score of 300+ where both teams manage a score of 100+), in descending order:

344: 1987 Rd 9 – Southport 37-22-244 d Morningside 14-16-100 (Owen Park)
339: 1987 Rd 6 - Wilston Grange 30-21-201 d Sherwood 21-12-138 (Hickey Park)
336: 1984 Rd 5 – Coorparoo 32-21-213 d Wilston Grange 18-15-123 (Hickey Park)
332: 1987 Rd 16 – Southport 28-18-186 d Wilston Grange 22-14-146 (Owen Park)
326: 1983 Rd 6 - Windsor Zillmere 25-14-164 d Sherwood 24-18-162 (O'Callaghan Park)
322: 1978 Rd 16 – Sandgate 33-21-219 d Kedron 15-13-103 (Lemke Road)
321: 1981 Rd 17 – Morningside 28-15-183 d Sandgate 21-12-138 (BCG)
320: 1982 Rd 10 – Coorparoo 31-17-203 d Wilston Grange 18-9-117 (Giffin Oval)
320: 1984 Rd 4 – Kedron 29-22-196 d Sherwood 19-10-124 (John Wren Oval)
318: 1984 Rd 13 – Southport 26-16-172 d Mayne 23-8-146 (Owen Park)
318: 1984 Rd 17 – Kedron 24-19-163 d Western Districts 24-11-155 (John Wren Oval)
317: 1981 Rd 16 – Mayne 25-21-171 d Western Districts 21-20-146 (BCG)
317: 1984 Rd 13 – Sherwood 27-14-176 d Kedron 22-9-141 (Cansdale Street)
316: 1985 Rd 17 – Morningside 26-12-168 d Kedron 23-10-148 (Hawthorne Park)
311: 1974 Rd 14 – Morningside 27-14-176 d Kedron 21-9-135 (Hawthorne Park)
306: 1979 Rd 21 - Western Districts 28-17-185 d Mayne 17-19-121 (Chelmer)
305: 1980 Rd 18 - Western Districts 25-21-171 d Windsor Zillmere 20-14-134 (BCG)
305: 1981 Rd 20 – Morningside 24-20-164 d Mayne 21-15-141 (BCG)
304: 1975 Rd 12 – Morningside 30-10-190 d Sandgate 17-12-114 (Hawthorne Park)
304: 1983 Rd 7 – Sherwood 27-23-185 d Western Districts 17-17-119 (Cansdale Street)
303: 1980 Rd 21 – Sandgate 23-14-152 d Morningside 22-19-151 (BCG)
302: 1954 Rd 2 – Sandgate 28-17-185 d Mayne 18-9-117 (Perry Park)
302: 1975 Rd 18 – Sandgate 27-20-182 d Wilston Grange 18-12-120 (Hickey Park)
301: 1988 Rd 16 – Mayne 28-18-186 d Western Districts 16-19-115 (Chelmer)

It first occurred in 1954 - and then didn't re-appear for a further 20 seasons. It certainly reflects a certain era of local football. Since 1988, only one result has got close (298 points in 1990).

I'm still working on lower grade scores, getting my database sorted out. The only comparable result I can find was in the AFLQ Premier Division in 2011 (underpinning the NEAFL comp locally):

315: 2011 Rd 6 – Sandgate 31-13-199 d Burleigh 18-8-116 (Bill Godfrey Oval )

Thanks.

All scores added

 

[Gibbsy]

Was really barracking for the 300 aggregate in this weekend's Southport v Frankston VFL finals match. It just fell short at 298, but still a phenomenal scoreline in 2024. From Frankston's perspective, kicking 16.7 in three quarters of football and yet still losing by 92 points is quite remarkable.

AFL - News, Fixtures, Scores & Results - AFL.com.au

Australian Football League. All the latest AFL news, video, results and information

www.afl.com.au

Southport	6.8	16.10	22.13	30.15 (195)
Frankston	0.0	4.2	9.4	16.7 (103)