What was the diference?
-
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Hille Bump vs Buddy Bump?
- Thread starter macdaddio
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Henry Jr
Norm Smith Medallist
There was more force in the Hille bump.....
Dunstall_Jr
Team Captain
Hille braced himself and got him in the chest.
Even though I disagree with the rule, Buddy got him in the head.
If Hille gets rubbed out, the game is in an even sadder state.
Even though I disagree with the rule, Buddy got him in the head.
If Hille gets rubbed out, the game is in an even sadder state.
go hawks!!!
Norm Smith Medallist
did he get off? also did flether get done?
all hawks players got off i hope i.e hodge and brown?
all hawks players got off i hope i.e hodge and brown?
What was the diference?
Brown and Gold... Black and Red.
Hodge and Brown got off.
Welsh got 4 weeks for kneeing Ellis.
Hille got off.
Fletcher got off.
It has nothing to do with glasses mate, and everything to do with consistency, lets get that straight.
Hawksgirl4eva
All Australian
Striking Welsh in a marking contest.
Hawksgirl4eva
All Australian
seriously they got put up for that gezzz
Yes I also was surprised it was looked at
Hawksgirl4eva
All Australian
i know it was a free kick at the most and a soft one at that, definetly not reportable.
One made head contact, the other didn't??What was the diference?
Being punched in the head is a soft free kick these days?
I'll agree that it was in no way reportable though.
arupist
Premium Platinum
Fair result all round.
arupist
Premium Platinum
Sorry, you're right about the Fletcher incident. Was thinking of something else in my previous post. Other results were correct IMO.
buddy had a tooth knocked out and got no free kickOne made head contact, the other didn't??
Being punched in the head is a soft free kick these days?
I'll agree that it was in no way reportable though.
Hille did not have to "tuck in" as you put it, you see him running front on, then turns. and he made incidental contact with Ladson's chin, nothing in it, just like Franklin's. Both made the contact based on the movement of the opponent, one got suspended though....
You, sir, have no idea.
Hille bumped Clinton Young front-on in the chest after Young (number 11) not Ladson (4) took a mark running with the flight.
50 m and goal, reprimand at most.
Hille bumped Clinton Young front-on in the chest after Young (number 11) not Ladson (4) took a mark running with the flight.
50 m and goal, reprimand at most.
Thought the decisions were about right (Haven't actually seen Fletcher's though). Thought Hille braced himself as best he could in the situation to not completely flatten Young, and with no contact to the head, a good decision. Welsh's was a dog act, and i wasn't going to complain with anything he got.
Any footage of the Fletcher incident?
I personally wouldn't of even given a 50 on Hilles incident, bloke is very heavy and really could of flattened young if he wanted to.
Welsh deserved what he got, was a complete dog act. Fletchers eh..very hard to judge.
Welsh deserved what he got, was a complete dog act. Fletchers eh..very hard to judge.
so i got the player wrong.... but the angle i saw i did see incidental contact to his chin.
I did not say Hille deserved weeks, never did i say that, i am saying that franklin got a week and i thought, based on the angle i saw that it was very simmilar, and hille was very lucky
