HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,228
- 101,329
- AFL Club
- Carlton
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Huge Rumor
- Thread starter JBMKII
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No it doesn't.
Huge rumour eh....more like huge load of garbage.
You cant ontrade a bloke...u can ontrade pix but not a player.
Ban yaself.
He meant a three way deal:
Melbourne
IN: Reid, 14
OUT: Johnstone, 4
Collingwood
IN: Judd
OUT: Reid, Davis, 14
West Coast
IN: Johnstone, Davis, 4
OUT: Judd
I agree the way he wrote it was impossible, but it is still possible. There are other reasons why this thread is bullshit, but it not being possible isn't one of them.
So, players are being told of possible trades down Collingwood way? Good to see you dumped your source into it, I'm sure he'll be pleased.
- Banned
- #56
One rather large problem here. Judd wants to play at Carlton and will not agree to play at Collingwood. Therfore this cannot happen.
He wasn't told anything...he heard it just like people hear other Rumours...i don't think they would be telling the players not involved in possible tardes...but they might tell eachother...i'm sure if you and i were mates and played on the same team....i would tell you that i was trade bait if i was upset about it...wouldn't you?
I am sure Ben Davies would be in the inner sanctum of the Pies! Be very surprised if he is on the list next year.
It was a toss of a coin...he could end up at the pies if WCE agree...i'm sure he wouldn't care that much....he hasn't come out and said...i only want to be tyraded to Carlton...he just said that you were his preference.
He thinks that he's gone...but hasn't been told as of yet...he told me that before the sydney final.
No he didnt ...read it again. Doesnt even know how to spell the names.
You're just interested in any potential new suitor so you are helping him out.
Why wouldnt u assume its just primo garbage ?
Pick 3 & 4 are interchangeable. Which boasts the question which is better?
Pick 20 + Kennedy (which they haven't even got on the table atm)
versus
Johnstone & Davis
Personally I don't want to trade Davis but Johnstone is a nice trade.
Swap Davis for N.Brown/Rusling and that is better than 3,20& Kennedy.
So Judd for 4, Johnstone & Rusling/N.Brown sounds good...in theory.
Pick 20 + Kennedy (which they haven't even got on the table atm)
versus
Johnstone & Davis
Personally I don't want to trade Davis but Johnstone is a nice trade.
Swap Davis for N.Brown/Rusling and that is better than 3,20& Kennedy.
So Judd for 4, Johnstone & Rusling/N.Brown sounds good...in theory.
Actually, I havent heard he wont play at Collingwood, I havent even heard that he wants to play at Carlton from his own mouth. What we have heard, via someone else is that carlton is his preferred option.
Juddtastic
Team Captain
You're an idiot, he'll play at collingwood if we deal with them..... Carlton are his preferred team- not only
Cannot trade a player already acquired in a trade for 1 season, so pure BS.
The eagles want picks. They don't want to do a deal involving one player out and two players in. That is too hard for list purposes.
It will be Carlton for picks.
It will be Carlton for picks.
Well if this rumour is true and you have named him on an internet forum as your source I reckon you have put the nail in his coffin.
What about.....
Pick #4, Pick #14 & Sean Rusling?
Pick #3 = Pick #4...they are inter-changable
Sean Rusling = Josh Kennedy...if not more proven.
Pick #14 >> Pick #20.
hahaha...as if anyone from the pies coaching staff is going to take notice of Big Footy...they base it on what they have done this year!
He won the Collingwood's Williamstown B & F....but didn't play a senior game or get onto the emergency list.
I'd say that they would base it on the above...not something a person puts on a forum....don't you?
But, haven't you given away #14 to get #4? If not, then please advise how you are going to get your hands onto it. I'm sure Demon supporters will be keen to know.
Cothin is going to Richmond...keep dreaming that he will slip to 3.
