If you could pick 5 players...

[Sir Robert]

Missed the from another team part did you...

Lol -yep. Was too Mad.

Based on new requirements:

Ablett.
Judd.
J Riewoldt..
N Brown (gun stopper).
Sandilands

Apologies Hodge and Bartel.

 

[AG]

Riewoldt
Franklin
Ablett
Goddard
Lake

4 bestish players plus a key defender.

 

[bombermick]

Bias towards younger players

Franklin
J.Riewoldt
Gary Ablett Junior
Brendan Goddard
Mark LeCras

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Lake
Judd
Franklin
Goddard
Le Cras

 

[BEEG]

Sandliands - Best ruck in the comp by a mile
Ablett - Best mid in the comp and only 25
Pendlebury - Can play inside and out will be the next big thing only 23
Goddard - Can do it all
Franklin - Can play CHF or FF will kick 100 goals next year freak

 

[joxstrap]

Franklin
Goddard
Riewoldt
Ablett
Lake

 

[Bulldog1954]

Sandilands
Franklin
Goddard
Ablett
Hill

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Sandilands
Ablett
Goddard
Franklin
Pavlich

 

[Lach72]

Ablett - Need that inside mid and he's the best.
Franklin - Help Pav and can rotate CHF/FF
Nathan Brown - Young gorilla full back, right age slot for our team.
Goddard - Great Swing man.
Dustin Martin - Inside Mid, right age bracket, a beast in the packs

 

[NAUGHT5]

Judd
Ablett
Hodge
Goddard
Sandilands

You could plonk Cain Ackland at FF and he'd still win the Coleman.

 

[Wee Jessies]

I don't quite understand why people are selecting for the next decade, if you pick the best 5 in the comp now to complement your current list you sew up the premiership for the next five years (unless you relocate to New York).

1. Ablett
2. Goddard
3. Lake
4. Judd
5. N Riewoldt

If I was going strategically to weaken the best teams

1. Hodge
2. Judd
3. Didak
4. Swan
5. Goddard

 

[krusden]

Didak- Adds lots of x factor, hate him though
J.Riewoldt- Gun forward, him and Nick
Swan- Gives our midfield some steel.
Frawley- Gun young backman
Sandilands- Best ruckman.

St Kilda-
B-Gwilt Frawley Gilbert
HB-Gram Fisher Ray
M-Montagna Dal Santo Goddard
HF-Didak N.Riewoldt Jones
F-Milne J.Riewoldt Schnieder
R-Sandilands Hayes Swan
Int-Steven Dawson Armitage
Sub- Geary

Excellent use of the concept, rather than just naming the 5 players the working of em into the team is

For Mine:

Lance Franklin at CHF, could move with Roo in between there and FF.
Ablett - Flank.
Goodes - HB Flank is a spot for him, but like Goddard he could play essentially where he wanted to.
Judd - Can't not have him in the side.
Chapman - Fully fit Paul chapman is a dangerous thing.



St Kilda-
B-Gwilt Dawson Gilbert
HB-Gram Fisher Goodes
M-Montagna Dal Santo Goddard
HF-Ablett L. Franklin Jones
F-Chapman N.Riewoldt Schnieder
R-Kosi Hayes Judd
Int-Steven Milne Armitage
Sub- Geary

Team would have changed if Rooke and Kirk hadn't gone this year with Rooke replacing probably franklin and Kirk Chappy.

 

[Tigerman_12]

Naitanui/Kreuzer: young ruckman
Franklin: freak, still young.
Frawley: best kpd for age.
Gibbs: young and skills. Would suit Cotchin and Martin, and could swap with Deliedo for half back.
Judd: the captain of the team. Best captain in the competition.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

G.Ablett-Obvious
Goddard-Fwd,Back,Mid.You name it.
N.Riewoldt-With Cousin Jack.What a combo.
Lake-Missing bit in our backline puzzle.
Kieran Jack-Alot to like about this kid.Ironically the next Paul Kelly.

 

[legend166]

Ablett
Judd
Sandilands
Lake
Riewoldt

 

[Dazb86]

Riewoldt
Hodge
Ablett
Franklin
Frawley

We'd win a flag easily...

 

[Richo83]

A FB, CHF, ruck and two mids, which equals Lake, Franklin, Sandi, Ablett and Swan.

I could pick Goddard, Judd, Hodge or Riewoldt, and it's very close. Fittingly enough IMO these are the top nine players in the league. Possibly a small forward or flanker type like LeCras or Didak given we struggle for forwards.

I do like naught5's idea of just picking mids and relying on the forwards to kick the goals though.

 

[Silvagnis]

B: Armfield Jamison Russell
HB: Bower Hurley Goddard
C: Simpson Mclean Gibbs
HF: Yarran Franklin Waite
F: Betts Henderson Garlett
R: Sandilands Judd Ablett

I/C: Kreuzer Lucas Murphy Walker

Apologies to Lenny Hayes.

 

[Suma Magic]

Youth is the key:

Hill
Martin
D Swallow
J Reiwoldt
Hurley

 

[Prem87]

Pavlich
Brown
Judd
Ablett
Hayes

 

[AG]

Youth is the key:

Hill
Martin
D Swallow
J Reiwoldt
Hurley

Key for what?

 

[camiam]

great thread no one can have a go at each other on this one

1. swan
2. ablett
3. judd
4. sandilands
5. riewoldt

 

[Morro]

FB Frawley
CHF Franklin
Goodes CHB or utility
Ablett best mid
Sandilands best ruckman

Basically fills all our current big holes.

 

[WCE_phil]

Brian Lake
Brendan Goddard
Alan Didak
Jacob Surjan
Aaron Davey

FB Surjan Glass Schofield
HB Hurn Brown Goddard
C Gaff Kerr Sheppard
HF Lecras Kennedy Didak
FF Naitanui Lake Davey
R Cox Masten S Selwood
Int Waters Shuey Strijk
Sub Embley

Surjan is the best small defender in the league imo and represents a huge need for our team. A specialist instead of just playing a small midfielder down there.

Goddard. The tall version of shannon hurn. Would give the best rebounding half back line in the competition.

Didak. Collingwoods best player and the only mid sized forward in the league better than lecras

Brian Lake. The best full forward to have not played his career there. I still see it as one of the biggest travesties in AFL football of the last quarter century. Lake as a FF could kick 100 goals in a season imo.

Davey. The guy is just silk. Can play anywhere from the half back line to deep forward. Speed and silky skills.

Now i could have just gone and picked who i thought were the best 5 players in the league and gone well there you go. But i decided to add to our current list and build a team covering our major deficiencies.

 

[fddf]

Rhys Conca
Jake Batchelor
Brad Helbig
Shaun Grigg
Bachar Houli

......OH WAIT lol

Grigg/Houli lol