If you could punch....

[Fotia2]

No, not at all. I have never liked Judd, even when he was at WC & I doubt I would ever really like him at Collingwood. Yes, he is a really good player but that's where it ends for me. I think it's a personal thing, you either hate a player or you like them. You hate players & I'm sure you would want to punch them to, mine just happens to be Judd.
Yes, it would have been good to have him at Collingwood, any club would have wanted him. He would never be my favourite player.

Fair enough! I know there are some players you just dont like for no particular reason!! A friend of mine used to despise Marcus Ashcroft from Brisbane. i dont know about you, but he seemed like one of the more quiet/likeable guys going around! Im not a big fan of Justin kozchitzche & I dont really have a reason!!

 

[MagpieScouser]

without a doubt id save my best punch for that dog called mal micheal

he turned his back on collingwood when we are the ones who gave him a chance at senior footy

then in the lowest of low acts ,after the 2002 grand final he texts jarrod molloy with the words'thanks for your premiership medallion

if thats not the act of a low life scumbag then i dont know what is

it would be a pleasure to smash my fist into his face

 

[Baby Duck]

For arguments sake, lets say Nathan was a chick. How does that stop him from calling another player a girl?

Exactly. Dale Thomas IS a girl. Undoubtedly a useful player, but a girl he will always be in my mind. Nablett is was a useful player also, his heart just wasn't in it.

 

[Bring-Back-Powell]

phil carman for being dumb enough to smack micheal tuck in the 77 prelim and missing not only 1 but 2 grand finals and costing collingwood the flag

That chip on your shoulder must be fairly huge

 

[The Karma Bus]

Has to be Chad Cornes..

 

[Claude Balls]

This thread is hilarious I especially enjoyed the little stoush between J-Mac and Pav for AA

I'd like to bloody the faces of the following players:

Adam Hunter
Ben Cousins
Chad Cornes
Stephen Milne

Justin Murphy - what a fickle, weak dog he was....

 

[choco123]

without a doubt id save my best punch for that dog called mal micheal

he turned his back on collingwood when we are the ones who gave him a chance at senior footy

then in the lowest of low acts ,after the 2002 grand final he texts jarrod molloy with the words'thanks for your premiership medallion

if thats not the act of a low life scumbag then i dont know what is

it would be a pleasure to smash my fist into his face

hahahahahahahaha. gotta admit pretty funny joke

that was really funny but an element of it is true as he pulled a similar stunt on brissy, pretended he was retiring then went to essendon is the ps draft for nothing

 

[SOLAK]

dale thomas

but i would want it he could punch me like 5 times in a row

then i would just give him one good one and he would be out for the count

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Damien Peverill

I reckon I could punch him pretty.

 

[oogac]

Im not greedy . . . The Carlton Mosquito Squad from the 80's

 

[Big Ronnie]

Steve Johnson or Cameron Mooney

Knock some brains in to them.
Happy for them to punch back, then I get to hit them again

 

[Deenamite]

Novak Djokovic.

 

[Hawks1523]

Novak Djokovic.

I'll get in that line.

 

[DEEZ_4_LIFE]

1 - Reiwoldt
2 - Treadrea

 

[GiveGasTheFlick]

Fraser Gehrig for me when is the ****ter going to have a crack at the biggers guys hes a weak prick.Only wish i could give him 6 of the best. lol Longyy would be a close second he has plastic sheets on hes bed.

 

[GiveGasTheFlick]

Gun talents such as Karl Norman and Laurence Angwin deserve a punch for wasting Carlton's time and money. Carlton would be out of the bottom four if Norman and Angwin had Setanta's work ethic and attitude.

I hate the bastards.

Houlihan and Ackland deserve a kidney punch to wake them up.

I'll pay that.