Injured Players Returning?

[Jaymin]

A fair few people are probably in the same boat as me for Prelim Final weekend. Most games will depend on the availability of the following players...

Milburn
Chapman
Lucas
Vince
P.Burgoyne (match review)
Simmonds (match review)
McIntosh
Garland
Wirrpanda
Wilkes (concussion?)

Whats the liklihood of most of these guys returning?

 

[Zmithy]

Luckily i only have Milburn out of those players and the word is he will be back next week. Bad thing is my opponent also has him so its not much of a win win situation.

Did most of the other big names pull up ok from the weekend?

 

[catsdynasty]

I haven't seen the richmond Vs Hawthorn match what did SImmonds do? Will he get anything?

 

[Weekend Hussler]

I haven't seen the richmond Vs Hawthorn match what did SImmonds do? Will he get anything?

Probably the most pathetic report I have ever seen.

Charge will get thrown out. The umpire, in my opinion, should be suspended for life.

 

[AC for PM]

Agreed, it was a shove to the neck more than anything on Murphy i think, couldnt believe the report when i saw the replay!
Need Chappy back.

 

[Hodges]

Need Chappy back too. The rest can wait.

 

[sifo]

ive had 17 injuries, 13 requiring trades this yr. n have milbrun wilkes chappy simmonds n peter burgopyne atm

 

[Cruiser23]

You forgot my man Chris Johnson

I desperately need Chapman, Milburn and CJ back because I'm carring 3 zeros at the moment. Horrible coaching selections haven't helped with my bench players being robbed of playing. Only got 1780 last week and dropped out of the top 500, I need to get back in there, was my aim at the start of the year.

 

[Benno_900]

McIntosh will be back this week.

 

[magpies77]

porpz may be back this week (i will be very surprised & happy if its true)

 

[Star]

Hey Jaymin

Is Myers any chance to play again this year?

 

[sharpie]

Hey Jaymin

Is Myers any chance to play again this year?

Quoted as out for season on most injur boards (unfortunately)

 

[Jaymin]

Hey Jaymin

Is Myers any chance to play again this year?

Nah gone for the year.

 

[Bound For Glory]

Burgoyne can accept a reprimand for his bump and the Simmonds report got thrown out. Anyone that has Hodge, he has been offered a week for striking.

 

[Daz]

N.Brown? I was worried the first time when he had the 'flu'. Need the Tiges to think they can make the finals and rush him back.

 

[DT_fanatic]

wilkes should be right, according to the weagles he didn't suffer any major injury. just hope they dont rest him or anyhting.

 

[Cruiser23]

N.Brown? I was worried the first time when he had the 'flu'. Need the Tiges to think they can make the finals and rush him back.

I saw him walking along Flinders St on my way back home from the Blues Roos game. It was just a quick glance but he seemed like he was limping.

 

[Alvin Purple]

Is Hille definetly out I don't have an emergency ruckman.

 

[asanque]

Any word on N.Foley?

 

[SkankDanker]

Is Hille definetly out I don't have an emergency ruckman.

I am fairly sure his season is over with a broken hand.

 

[DonMania#5]

Is Hille definetly out I don't have an emergency ruckman.

Out for the season.

 

[dplggr47]

A fair few people are probably in the same boat as me for Prelim Final weekend. Most games will depend on the availability of the following players...

Milburn
Chapman
Lucas
Vince
P.Burgoyne (match review)
Simmonds (match review)
McIntosh
Garland
Wirrpanda
Wilkes (concussion?)

Whats the liklihood of most of these guys returning?

Vince looks like another week away.

porpz may be back this week (i will be very surprised & happy if its true)

Porpz is very unlikely to play this week. he'll need confirmation from specialists whether the bruising is gone, but even if it is, he won't be rushed in this week. possibly the week after, but seriously, looking at Tadhg Kennelly continuously dislocate his shoulder, just makes you wonder even if Porpz played, teams would target him and he might not even last long on the field.

 

[kenny712]

Desperately need Chapman and Milburn back. Been 3 down for 2 weeks now and was very lucky to scrape through into the Prelim.

 

[SkankDanker]

Vince looks like another week away. Porpz is very unlikely to play this week. he'll need confirmation from specialists whether the bruising is gone, but even if it is, he won't be rushed in this week. possibly the week after, but seriously, looking at Tadhg Kennelly continuously dislocate his shoulder, just makes you wonder even if Porpz played, teams would target him and he might not even last long on the field.

Seeing Kennelly do that shows you just what commitment these players have and what they are prepared to do to stay on the park. Not the appropriate thread for this, but I hate it when players are called soft when really they are not - they don't make it to AFL level if they are soft. I guess it all becomes relative after a while, but the problems they must have in later life with arthritis etc. must be shocking.

I hated having Porps in my team and seeing him run around with his arm dangling - it was actually a relief to trade him.

 

[catsdynasty]

I don't have him and am playing against a mate who has him this week for the prelim but does anyone no if Dale Thomas will get up this week I just read something on the collingwood website saying he is a chance but that means crap I've been around long enough to no that that means absolute crap. WIll he get up??????