I may be a tad biased, but I wouldn't have thought St Kilda and Essendon have a better forward line than us.
Herald Sun
8. ESSENDON
The top-liners: Jake Stringer (18 Games in 2021, 93 Average SuperCoach Score), Will Snelling (19, 81), Devon Smith (19, 65), Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti (20, 63), Alec Waterman (13, 55), Archie Perkins (19, 50), Harrison Jones (16, 49), Brayden Ham (17, 48)
The top-ups: Kaine Baldwin (0, 0), Tom Hird (0, 0)
MICK SAYS
Essendon’s top three goalkickers last year were Jake Stringer (41 goals), Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti (34 goals) and Cale Hooker (33 goals). Hooker is retired and a cloud hangs over the availability of McDonald-Tipungwuti. That is a dilemma for coach Ben Rutten, but it will also provide some great opportunities to others. Stringer can’t keep the scoreboard ticking over alone as a midfield-forward. Peter Wright simply has to step up and become the Bombers’ forward 50 contested marking beast. But Wright himself also needs some support. Harrison Jones is developing and will get more opportunities, but Rutten could also look to use youngster Kaine Baldwin and even defender Aaron Francis in attack. On the smalls front, Devon Smith and Will Snelling will need to significantly lift their output both on the scoreboard and with their tackling and pressure if McDonald-Tipungwuti is missing. A couple of early surprises could be the lightning quick James Hird Academy graduate Tex Wanganeen and creative West Australian Nick Martin.
9. ST KILDA
The top-liners: Tim Membrey (21 Games in 2021, 79 Average SuperCoach Score), Jack Higgins (19, 75), Mason Wood (7, 71), Josh Battle (14, 64), Max King (20, 62), Dean Kent (7, 59), Dan Butler (22, 53), Ryan Byrnes (16, 53)
The top-ups: Cooper Sharman (4, 68), Josiah Kyle (0, 0)
MICK SAYS
Max King has the physical attributes to become one of the top-three key forwards in the competition. He took the third-most contested marks of any player in 2021 and with another pre-season of weight training under his belt he could become the competition’s No. 1 contested marker this year. If he masters his goalkicking, King could quite easily have a Coleman Medal hanging around his neck at year’s end. King and Tim Membrey form a formidable combination as key forwards and have great synergy. Rowan Marshall poses a threat when he is in attack, although I’d like to see him hit the scoreboard more than he does. Josh Battle is hard to match up on and kicks long goals. Dan Butler and Jack Higgins bring creativity and goal kicking ability while Jade Gresham has a high football IQ. Where St Kilda can improve is getting a better balance between their deep entries inside-50 and their hit-up entries.
10. WEST COAST
The top-liners: Jack Darling (22 Games in 2021, 75 Average SuperCoach Score), Jamie Cripps (22, 73), Josh Kennedy (18, 70), Oscar Allen (21, 64), Liam Ryan (14, 62), Jake Waterman (14, 58), Jamaine Jones (12, 55), Zac Langdon (16, 49), Jack Petruccelle (17, 47), Willie Rioli (0, 0)
The top-ups: Xavier O’Neill (7, 43), Connor West (5, 51)
MICK SAYS
Let’s be blunt. West Coast’s forward 50 pressure was woeful last year and must improve. They ranked last in the AFL for forward 50 pressure. There are more questions than answers about the Eagles’ attack entering 2022. Will Jack Darling play? He was their leading goalkicker last year. Can Josh Kennedy continue to deliver or will his ageing legs get the better of him? Kennedy and Darling kicked 83 goals between them last year. The pressure to cover their output — if it drops or disappears — squarely falls on Oscar Allen, Liam Ryan, Jamie Cripps, a returning Willie Rioli and the speedy Jack Petruccelle. If the West Coast forwards are all fit and available, they are an efficient group that deserves to be ranked 10th. But they could also hit the wall this year.
Forget having them over us, how does Essendon's forward line get ranked over anyone?