Rumour Interesting Rumour (was "News")

[TradeDraft]

We wouldn't get pick 11 if that was to happened, right? Sounds like complete BS though.

Dustin Martin would be Worth more then Pick 11

 

[Jonno94]

Dustin Martin would be Worth more then Pick 11

Not for the money he wants.

 

[jmac70]

Swanny was in the paper just a month ago saying he would play out his days at Collingwood.

He would have known these changes were on the cards, and I don't believe they will influence him

I hope to god you are right.

 

[TradeDraft]

 

[RuFiO]

you want me to be wrong?

I hope you're right so you can tell your sister, you were right.

 

[BusterBob]

Fair enough.

We must retain Daisy especially as we will have ample cap space made available with all the exits.

The thing is I can see the players really feeling the heat if applied by Eddie but by Bucks? I don't see it unfortunately.

Bucks is on record as saying he doesn't "motivate" the players so how would they respond if he is "baking" them?

Bucks is usually such a cool customer, I reckon that him showing them real heat would have been extra effective - because it's not often done.

 

[BEEG]

Why would Swan go his mates with plenty of blokes down there good mates with Beams and Sidbottom

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

there's no way Swan or O'Brien will go, and I don't think Shaw will either.

I'm even thinking Daisy will stay

I would like to see O'Brien swapped for something worthwhile because of his disposal and happy to see the end of Shaw if we get something good in return. I am into the idea of a rebuild. Good riddance to Daisy at $700000 a year for 4 years. If Swan wants out and goes I'll be gutted.

 

[RuFiO]

Why would Swan go his mates with plenty of blokes down there good mates with Beams and Sidbottom

Are you saying Swan's good mates with Beams & Sidebottom?
Or Swan's good mates with other people at the club?
Or just that Beams & Sidebottom are good mates?

 

[dubber]

I would like to see O'Brien swapped for something worthwhile because of his disposal and happy to see the end of Shaw if we get something good in return. I am into the idea of a rebuild. Good riddance to Daisy at $700000 a year for 4 years. If Swan wants out and goes I'll be gutted.

You just want to play with new & shiny toys don't you?

 

[BusterBob]

Expecting another article about Roos being the best coach ever, and Buckley and Daniher were both morons.

As long as Grundy doesn't write an article about Jolly's attitude to him at training I'm all good.

Ah yes, that article could come back to haunt Jolly ... finds himself in a similar position now.

 

[Magpie4Life]

If we have to keep Shaw to keep Swan, then keep Shaw. Swan is a gun and I thought he was one player who showed heart on Saturday night.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Dustin Martin would be Worth more then Pick 11

No he wouldn't. Hes inconsistent and a flashy show boater who can't finish in front of goals.

 

[BusterBob]

Why would Swan go his mates with plenty of blokes down there good mates with Beams and Sidbottom

And I reckon he values being a Pies man.

 

[BEEG]

[quote"RuFiO, post: 30084746, member: 25557"]Are you saying Swan's good mates with Beams & Sidebottom?
Or Swan's good mates with other people at the club?
Or just that Beams & Sidebottom are good mates?[/quote]

Well I know his good mates with Beams I am sure his mates with plenty blokes down there

 

[Williamc99]

If we have to keep Shaw to keep Swan, then keep Shaw. Swan is a gun and I thought he was one player who showed heart on Saturday night.

Well Swanny was one of the only players who actually did anything of note on Saturday. Would be a massive loss if he went.

 

[loki04]

Swanny was in the paper just a month ago saying he would play out his days at Collingwood.

He would have known these changes were on the cards, and I don't believe they will influence him

Shaw was saying last week he is a pie through and through yet there are loud noises coming out that we are offering them both up for trade.

 

[loki04]

Well Swanny was one of the only players who actually did anything of note on Saturday. Would be a massive loss if he went.

Top 6 player in the comp of course it would be a massive loss.

IF we trade him for a packet of twisties I'll be ropeable.

 

[loki04]

Ridiculous! They can get Thomas for nothing, why would they help us get Martin by giving up Yarran and a draft pick?
Maybe mick still has a soft spot for us after all!

Maybe it relates back to the fact we can match their offer and have said we would rather this trade?

 

[Williamc99]

I can understand delisting the players we have or potentially get rid of Daisy but to trade Swan would be a massive mistake. He is probably one of the best midfielders we have. We'd be definitely going backwards then.

 

[TheWing121]

Cannot see Swan going elsewhere he has some form of loyalty, I could see him quitting football but not going elsewhere.

Shaw is the same it is just ridiculous that he will go elsewhere

 

[CoreyBurnett1]

Martin Signed with Richmond!

 

[frizzle]

Martin Signed with Richmond!

Was always going to.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Well Swanny was one of the only players who actually did anything of note on Saturday. Would be a massive loss if he went.

Wayne Carey said he was the most valuable player on the ground.

 

[Williamc99]

Well he was the only one who did anything forward. He kicked the most goals on Saturday night for our side didn't he? He was single handedly keeping us in it.