Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[foj1]

The plot thickens .
The mail was the Dog's didn't consider Carlisle a good "cultural" fit ??
How could that have changed ??

I think Talia leaving has made them rethink.
I feel if they have cap room he would be a chance.

 

[Red Bull]

I think Talia leaving has made them rethink.
I feel if they have cap room he would be a chance.

Hmmm ,
A backflip like that would hardly signal rock solid conviction to the club/coaches cultural beliefs ...
Forever and a day , clubs have been seduced and altered the set framework ...

 

[MightyDons4]

Seems to line up with the Talia situation. Carlisle an upgrade on Talia but at much greater cost.

Talia is a good VFL player
Carlisle is a good AFL player
Massive upgrade

The plot thickens .
The mail was the Dog's didn't consider Carlisle a good "cultural" fit ??
How could that have changed ??

Positives outweigh the negatives. Carlisle's attitude problems have also been blown out massively.

 

[foj1]

Hmmm ,
A backflip like that would hardly signal rock solid conviction to the club/coaches cultural beliefs ...
Forever and a day , clubs have been seduced and altered the set framework ...

Sorry mate what is your point?

 

[Wiz83]

A work mate of mine is best mates with a North Melbourne player. Apparently the reason Carlisle has taken so long to announce his preferred club is because it was actually North Melbourne. But Carlisle & North met a couple weeks ago & both sides weren't happy with how the meeting went.

So now Carlisle is deciding who his next preferred club is & apparently it's out of St Kilda or the Doggies. NOT CARLTON.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Has sounded for a while now that Carlisle is not their man .
With the possibility of Adelaide jerking Geelong around re their first rounder , the Dog's may investigate the possibility of Henderson .

Except henderson isn't as good as carlisle + he's a sook too. Carlisle raged on feild, but atleast he still played and didn't walk out on club 3 weeks before season had even ended.

If a cultural fit is what dogs need, then they won't be looking at Henderson over Carlisle.

 

[Red Bull]

Sorry mate what is your point?

Well according to Dog's poster's here , the club/coach obviously thought Carlisle was a rotten egg and put a line through his name .

Enter the Talia business and Carlisle is a wanted man again ?

If so , just wondering what happened to the belief that Carlisle wasn't the type of person for Footscray .

Throughout history clubs have been notorious for bending thier own rules in being seduced by the player they convince themselves they need ...

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Well according to Dog's poster's here , the club/coach obviously thought Carlisle was a rotten egg and put a line through his name .

Enter the Talia business and Carlisle is a wanted man again ?

If so , just wondering what happened to the belief that Carlisle wasn't the type of person for Footscray .

Throughout history clubs have been notorious for bending thier own rules in being seduced by the player they convince themselves they need ...

According to bulldogs posters, it was a player who had beef with Carlisle.

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Two Planks , any change on his preference? Are Dogs legitimately in the frame or is it still all Carlton?

 

[Red Bull]

Except henderson isn't as good as carlisle + he's a sook too. Carlisle raged on feild, but atleast he still played and didn't walk out on club 3 weeks before season had even ended.

If a cultural fit is what dogs need, then they won't be looking at Henderson over Carlisle.

Do we really need to state again the one big difference between Carlisle and Henderson pertaining to round one next year ...

 

[Red Bull]

According to bulldogs posters, it was a player who had beef with Carlisle.

My recollection is it was more Beveridge ... could be wrong though ...

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Do we really need to state again the one big difference between Carlisle and Henderson pertaining to round one next year ...

Dogs will take the risk on the better player. They've done it in the past. They don't think he is getting a ban.

 

[Red Bull]

Dogs will take the risk on the better player. They've done it in the past. They don't think he is getting a ban.

 

[Two Planks]

Two Planks , any change on his preference? Are Dogs legitimately in the frame or is it still all Carlton?

St Kilda upped offer to 5 years and Carlton lowered their offer to 3 years. Manager has told blues that if they up their offer to 5 years even on less money than saints that is the preferred destination.

The reason he hasn't made public his preference is that he wants a 5 year deal from Carlton and is waiting to hear back from them.

Ball 100% in blues court. Give the 5 and they get the player.

 

[BRUUUUCE]

Carlisle to the dogs take it to the bank my cousin is best friends with his managers Receptionist and the offer is 1 mil for 6 yearis so they can top up the vfl team with 2 millionaire's

 

[VogonProsthetnic]

Carlisle to the dogs take it to the bank my cousin is best friends with his managers Receptionist and the offer is 1 mil for 6 yearis so they can top up the vfl team with 2 millionaire's

For that sort of money we could enter the market for Danger. No way would we be offering that figure.

 

[BRUUUUCE]

The receptionist is pretty switched on
Head down bum up type of bloke if you know what i mean

 

[CaptainMurphy]

St Kilda upped offer to 5 years and Carlton lowered their offer to 3 years. Manager has told blues that if they up their offer to 5 years even on less money than saints that is the preferred destination.

The reason he hasn't made public his preference is that he wants a 5 year deal from Carlton and is waiting to hear back from them.

Ball 100% in blues court. Give the 5 and they get the player.

So Dogs not in it at all?

 

[VogonProsthetnic]

We

The receptionist is pretty switched on
Head down bum up type of bloke if you know what i mean

We got Boyd because we were able to front load his contract so we could afford the massive upgrades Bont, Stringer, McCrae, Libba, Wally are going to need. Can't see us doing that 2 years running.

 

[Two Planks]

So Dogs not in it at all?

Not until he hears back from blues.

 

[ManOfClay]

Carlisle to the dogs take it to the bank my cousin is best friends with his managers Receptionist and the offer is 1 mil for 6 yearis so they can top up the vfl team with 2 millionaire's

You're a funny one.

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Not until he hears back from blues.

Thanks TP, appreciate the info.

 

[CaptainMurphy]

We

We got Boyd because we were able to front load his contract so we could afford the massive upgrades Bont, Stringer, McCrae, Libba, Wally are going to need. Can't see us doing that 2 years running.

Don't feed the trolls.

 

[BRUUUUCE]

Don't feed the trolls.

That's original

 

[BRUUUUCE]

You're a funny one.

Thanks i try its good to feel appreciated