Traded James Aish [traded to Collingwood for #26 and St Kilda's 2016 second round pick]

[mattymac]

So telling a kid to tell whatever club drafts him to get stuffed after 2 years and demand a trade to one club only so they can get him cheap is considered fair play?

And here I thought higher of Adelaide supporters.

I didn't comment on the morality of it, just pointed out it wouldn't be draft tampering or coming to terms with a contracted player as was suggested.

 

[BM123]

Port's cap is reportedly full to the brim after luring Ryder on 750k.

Probably overrated Ryder by a fair bit then.

 

[mattymac]

Probably overrated Ryder by a fair bit then.

The "missing piece of the premiership puzzle" was a phrase that got a fair flogging

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

ryder on 750k lol

 

[Great8]

Yes, yes that makes sense.

Terrible post. FWIW, I do think Adelaide are the frontrunners, but in reality there's been articles suggesting a number of Vic clubs in the frame, so no, we can't rule out Vic clubs.

I know his family quite well and this whole wanting to come home thing couldnt be further from the truth. James is very intrigued by the whole Melbourne football culture and would be very interested in moving to a Vic based club. I think the Crows are well down the list, he would be more than happy to go anywhere to play footy

 

[legendstatus]

Been told by his management that he wants to be traded to a Victoria club, hearing but not 100%, that it'll be the Pies.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Cleric]

I know his family quite well and this whole wanting to come home thing couldnt be further from the truth. James is very intrigued by the whole Melbourne football culture and would be very interested in moving to a Vic based club. I think the Crows are well down the list, he would be more than happy to go anywhere to play footy

And yet his Uncle said he wont be going to Victoria and will never play for Port.
Its that time of the year.

 

[Turbocat]

Been told by his management that he wants to be traded to a Victoria club, hearing but not 100%, that it'll be the Pies.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Mmm that could be interesting after the Beams trade.

 

[iBeng]

Guys, hes going to West Coast, my mate told me, bookmark it.

 

[Eons]

Guys, hes going to West Coast, my mate told me, bookmark it.

Yep, his Grandma is sick who lives there.

 

[Great8]

And yet his Uncle said he wont be going to Victoria and will never play for Port.
Its that time of the year.

I think a lot of that is tongue in cheek. I see his uncle a few times a week and usually joke about him ending up at Port and he just laughs. Funnily enough he does believe Port has shown more interest than the Crows but he is good mates with KT so they probably have a joke about it. His gut feel is that he will be at Collingwood next year.

 

[iBeng]

Maybe he just really liked Crisp and wants to join him at Collingwood?

We should be able to get the deal done with their first, second and...Seedsman.

 

[Iva Bigun]

There was noise at the time that before he was drafted, i.e. while he wasn't contracted to anyone, we indicated we'd get him home if he wanted to come home after his rookie contract expired.

Also, FYI the AFL threw out Malthouse's vindictive rubbish about Betts and Tippet was not a case of coming to terms with a contracted oppo player at all, suggest reading up.

Where there's smoke as they say

 

[dlanod]

Keep it on-topic and save the team trolling, including non-Aish-related teams' drafting and trading, for Bay 13.

 

[Madagascar]

Maybe he just really liked Crisp and wants to join him at Collingwood?

We should be able to get the deal done with their first, second and...Seedsman.

LOL, yep, Brisbane in the end did pay overs in the Beams deal. Crisp, boy oh boy what a beauty. Probably should have been an untouchable, probably having a better year than any other Brisbane midfielder except maybe Beams. Damn. Should have traded Aish last year IMO, when he had more currency.

Aish playing OK today though.

 

[iBeng]

LOL, yep, Brisbane in the end did pay overs in the Beams deal. Crisp, boy oh boy what a beauty. Probably should have been an untouchable, probably having a better year than any other Brisbane midfielder except maybe Beams. Damn. Should have traded Aish last year IMO, when he had more currency.

Aish playing OK today though.

I was joking but hey, lets make this all about how we lost that trade in every way.

 

[Madagascar]

I was joking but hey, lets make this all about how we lost that trade in every way.

The James Aish trade thread DOES tie in to the Beams (or was is it Crisp) *Jokes* trade thread last year. It will come up from time to time unfortunately.

Edit: It's important to remember that you were the one to bring it up.

 

[F_therest]

Aish hasn't impressed me that much anyway. Has some nice skills but not sure he has the mental toughness and aggressiveness required...

 

[Go Woods]

Maybe he just really liked Crisp and wants to join him at Collingwood?

We should be able to get the deal done with their first, second and...Seedsman.

Way overs 1st round pick more than adequate

 

[cotter101]

Boy oh boy. Every thread that contains Collingwood and Brisbane posters is just going to be one big pissing contest between the two over the Beams trade for the next 50 years.

We're all happy with the deal we got, let's move on.

 

[Crawb]

Collingwood to self-impose a deadline on negioations and comically break their own deadlie again this time around?

 

[iBeng]

Collingwood to give us a list of untouchables, instead giving us a fringe player for them who becomes a solid contributor for us...?

 

[blueiris]

Ben Kennedy and their first round pick

 

[Prochard123]

Ben Kennedy and their first round pick

for Hanley and your first round pick

 

[iBeng]

for Hanley and your first round pick

Throw in Cloke