Traded Josh Dunkley - [Traded with F3 (Melb), F3 to Brisbane for #21, F1, F2, F4 (Geel)]

[Lore]

If you don't have the self-discipline not to attack other posters and derail the thread with crap every other time you post, thread bans will be applied.

Mods are not here to babysit.

Reporting bad posts instead of replying to them would also be extremely helpful if you wish to continue posting here.

 

[Mofra]

If he got walked to the draft surely he wouldn’t get by the bombers, he’s exactly what they need & given the s**t they are in, no one wants to play for them so he would fit right in

PSD more likely - North would seriously look at him before the Bombers would get a chance.

 

[iameviljez]

We've asked for your first two rounders knowing they'll be 16 and similar again next year. That's the middle. The s**t offer you presented is nothing but insulting.

Frankly, it's already a gift horse of an offer.

 

[Hoges64]

I would have though pick 15, F 1st with 39 & 65 going back to Brisbane would have been a start.

It's the start of slight unders for us and the least we should begrudgingly accept. Still values him worse than Taranto.

 

[Mofra]

It's the start of slight unders for us and the least we should begrudgingly accept. Still values him worse than Taranto.

It does but we'd accept the reality of the circumstances though.
There's accepting unders, then there's being a walkover which has the potential to bite you in subsequent trading years

 

[Warwick]

Geez, the panic on here...

7 days to go.

We haven't even started to tango yet.

 

[Vivy]

If he got walked to the draft surely he wouldn’t get by the bombers, he’s exactly what they need & given the s**t they are in, no one wants to play for them so he would fit right in

Doubt he gets far at all. Doubt it gets to the PSD either.

This could be great neutral viewing if the dogs do let it get there

 

[Foxman98]

Geez, the panic on here...

7 days to go.

We haven't even started to tango yet.

Yep the price has been set and its up to you to work it out and get back to us

 

[Hoges64]

Geez, the panic on here...

7 days to go.

We haven't even started to tango yet.

I don't think anyone is panicking, the people on here are discussing the ludicrousy of the Brisbane offer, and the additional ludicrousy of the Brisbane supporters who are trying to defend it.

 

[HarryFlashman]

Doubt he gets far at all. Doubt it gets to the PSD either.

This could be great neutral viewing if the dogs do let it get there

Would be pretty funny, we don’t have a dog in the fight, so just grab the popcorn & enjoy the show.

 

[Vivy]

Would be pretty funny, we have dog in the fight so just grab the popcorn & enjoy the show. Bris have a habit of grandstanding and

It's great already.

Bulldogs say we need 15 and the Lions tell em to get stuffed and trade it out. Fantastic

 

[iameviljez]

I don't think anyone is panicking, the people on here are discussing the ludicrousy of the Brisbane offer, and the additional ludicrousy of the Brisbane supporters who are trying to defend it.

It's also the fact that Brisbane have already traded out their R1 pick and still want it done.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

The problem comparing this deal to Taranto is we didn’t get any picks back after giving away 12/19. The dogs are looking at the (reported) Lions offer and probably feeling a little insulted. They’re insanely similar players so the value is pretty accurate as Taranto was a pick 2 and Dunkley has probably a better cv so far.

The issue for the Bears needing points for the 2 F/S picks is a problem that they knew would occur months ago and hardly a shocker. I can’t figure out why Gold Coast haven’t been mentioned in the media since the report of a stalemate has come out today? They’d be much more likely to get a fair deal for the dogs done and it’s only an hour away from Brisbane. If the lions don’t play ball surely that is the play now?

 

[ashep]

If Josh puts on his big boy pants and stops listening to his dad, 14 & 17 would get it done.

 

[Mofra]

It's also the fact that Brisbane have already traded out their R1 pick and still want it done.

Nek minnet: Bulldogs trade out 30 & 39 to Freo for Lobb & spare change...

 

[Mofra]

If Josh puts on his big boy pants and stops listening to his dad, 14 & 17 would get it done.

What a handover of the baton - Josh Kennedy to Dunkley. Similar types

 

[ashep]

What a handover of the baton - Josh Kennedy to Dunkley. Similar types

Exactly what we need. Would be an incredible fit for us.

 

[BLACAE]

Can paint it any which way you want. It’s a bad result for a team that supposedly should be in their window still.

The next team will be more likely to call your bluff because you aren’t going to always forego deals to keep losing players for nothing.

No, what will happen is players, and in particular, player managers will ensure a deal can be done before they let it get to this stage. Pickering should've learnt from the first time 2 years ago. Maybe teams shouldn't chase a player unless they are legitimately trying to get deals done in good faith. In this case;

1. Pickering has failed for the second time
2. Brisbane has also screwed over Dunkley selling him a picture and not willing to pay for it.

In the real world, people ensure they have a way of paying before committing. If I want to buy a caravan, Sports car and a house I don't then spend most of my money on the caravan and car and then ask the person to drop the price of the house.

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Warwick]

Calm down. There is a week to go.

Look how the Bulldogs offered their 2nd round pick for Akermanis in 2006 (actually traded down that pick beforehand to bring in another player).

It happens, how many times do you end up dealing with the exact same picks you had at the start of the week?

 

[RoyBoy17]

No, what will happen is players, and in particular, player managers will ensure a deal can be done before they let it get to this stage. Pickering should've learnt from the first time 2 years ago. Maybe teams shouldn't chase a player unless they are legitimately trying to get deals done in good faith. In this case;

1. Pickering has failed for the second time
2. Brisbane has also screwed over Dunkley selling him a picture and not willing to pay for it.

In the real world, people ensure they have a way of paying before committing. If I want to buy a caravan, Sports car and a house I don't then spend most of my money on the caravan and car and then ask the person to drop the price of the house.

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Two firsts was enough for an out of contract player even with seconds coming back.

The fact remains that two firsts is better than nothing. End of story. If he goes in the PSD so be it. We have Ashcroft and Fletcher and can keep next years first.

 

[BEEG]

Geez, the panic on here...

7 days to go.

We haven't even started to tango yet.

You guys have ****ed up royally.

 

[RoyBoy17]

You guys have *ed up royally.

Says the person who supports a club that values getting McStay over keeping a young gun in Henry and is palming off Grundy for a packet of chips to a premiership contender. I think that is effing up royally.

 

[Hoges64]

Two firsts was enough for an out of contract player even with seconds coming back.

No, it wasn't, and your List management team know that.

 

[Dangerousfield]

Never thought Brisbane could get this done. Two F/S & Dunkley was always too much, Gold Coast or Swans to swoop late.

 

[BEEG]

Says the person who supports a club that values getting McStay over keeping a young gun in Henry and is palming off Grundy for a packet of chips to a premiership contender. I think that is effing up royally.

Pies want Henry, he wants to go, getting someone who fits our style is handy especially when it's for free.

Grundy issue is being corrected as we don't value a ruck at that price, silly contract and getting out now instead of trying to get out in 2 years with no currency is a good idea.

You guys have an opportunity to get a kid who is 25 and will instantly improve your midfield and actually wants to come to your club, absolute disrespect shown to the Bulldogs with that offer.

 

[Thomasno]

Never thought Brisbane could get this done. Two F/S & Dunkley was always too much, Gold Coast or Swans to swoop late.

Don’t see how the swans have a foot in the door when the point of moving to Brisbane was his GF lives here