News Josh Hill has agreed to come to Hawthorn

[HawksILove]

Harbrow compo pick is not that bad maybe between 26 to 29.

 

[HawksILove]

Hawks should some how try and involve Daniel Merret into this deal.

Pick 19 to the Lions, Hill and Merret to Hawks, Sherman to Dogs.

Bulldogs would have to try and sweeten the lions for giving up Merret to Hawks.


This would solve the Hawks Back problems as well. Just a thought if we look at entertaining a 3 way deal for Hill

Hawthorn won't trade their first two picks Pelchen said

 

[HeHateMe]

so.....
Bulldogs lose: Hill, Compo
Bulldogs gain: Sherman
Lions lose: Merret, Sherman
Lions gain: #19, Compo
Hawks Lose: #19
Hawks gain:Merret, Hill

 

[The Birch]

I'd like to see that happen, but it's a big risk for the Hawks to let go pick19 if Hill and Merret prove to be flops. Both are a little inconsistant maybe to let go pick 19.

Good get for the Dogs to only give up Compo pick and Hill to get Sherman!

Voss would also love Picl 19 and the compo pick as well!

Pelchen I'm not so sure about???

 

[floki]

This one was cooked up yesterday by someone on the dogs board or a variation of it, might even be somewhere in this thread actually, Pelchen has stated as recently as last night (TWR) we won't be parting with picks 19 or 37 as we intend to carry them through to the ND.

:spade:

 

[Innit]

so.....
Bulldogs lose: Hill, Compo
Bulldogs gain: Sherman
Lions lose: Merret, Sherman
Lions gain: #19, Compo
Hawks Lose: #19
Hawks gain:Merret, Hill

Id class that as a win, we'll see what eventuates

 

[HeHateMe]

Harbrow compo pick is not that bad maybe between 26 to 29.

yeah it isn't i wasn't saying that, i would use comp, 2nd round, and both 3rd rounds on kids then upgrade 2 of Skipper, Peterson, Moss or Brust.
downgrade Tuck and idk who else.
then we would have to de-list 6 players.
that's a fair turnover.
We dont really have to hold on to the #19 unless we are affter a kid in the draft thet might go before we can get him.

 

[LuvMyHawks]

Picks 19 & 37 are off limits for this trade period!! Well known, Pelchen not prepared to part with them, and rightly so!

 

[BYWs Dimi Pumpa]

yeah it isn't i wasn't saying that, i would use comp, 2nd round, and both 3rd rounds on kids then upgrade 2 of Skipper, Peterson, Moss or Brust.
downgrade Tuck and idk who else.
then we would have to de-list 6 players.
that's a fair turnover.
We dont really have to hold on to the #19 unless we are affter a kid in the draft thet might go before we can get him.

From what i have heard there are three KPD in the ND who can slot in to a team straight away? Please correct me if i'm wrong.

It's highly doubtful that three KPD will last past pick 20.

Id rather hang on to 1st and 2nd round pick and go to the draft.

I'd offer the dogs pick 52 (better than pick 61) and package up with Ladson.

Ladson is surplus to requirements even though I Still think he has much to offer our club.

 

[HeHateMe]

but all in all i would rather trade pick 52 or 51 and ladson for hill as well guys.

don't think that is going to happen though.

 

[streetspirit]

Hadn't seen this posted before - apologies if double-post - just an insight into our initial approach (according to Denham anyway, who couldn't even get the fact that Suckling is now senior listed right).

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/new...ap-grigg-collins/story-e6frg7mf-1225936186345

Hawthorn's acquisition of Hale may scuttle its plans to trade in contracted Western Bulldogs forward Josh Hill. The Hawks initial deal to the Dogs for Hill involved the swap of the rookie-listed Matt Suckling, who played five games for Hawthorn this year. It was met with an immediate rejection from the Dogs.

 

[eldorado]

The Hawks initial deal to the Dogs for Hill involved the swap of the rookie-listed Matt Suckling, who played five games for Hawthorn this year. It was met with an immediate rejection from the Dogs.

What?

Haven't they seen his kick?

It's beautiful!

 

[MuzzHawk]

so.....
Bulldogs lose: Hill, Compo
Bulldogs gain: Sherman
Lions lose: Merret, Sherman
Lions gain: #19, Compo
Hawks Lose: #19
Hawks gain:Merret, Hill

Bulldogs get shafted. We would have to sweeten, possibly with the pick we got back from the Roos

 

[Messenger]

Hadn't seen this posted before - apologies if double-post - just an insight into our initial approach (according to Denham anyway, who couldn't even get the fact that Suckling is now senior listed right).

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/new...ap-grigg-collins/story-e6frg7mf-1225936186345

Seriously, why don't we offer Lachlan Veale. I can't blame the Dogs for telling us to beat it.

 

[TwoBeaus]

Pelchen, Hooper, Thorp, Dowler, Zac Dawson, Mat Little, Cam Pederson all go to Brisbane

Sherman to Hawks

Yes i know it involves kidnapping at gun point, but make it happen Jeff.

We havent taken a player from Port for a while, perhaps rioli for motlop

 

[HawksILove]

The Dogs also look unlikely to move Josh Hill to Hawthorn.
The Dogs wanted the Hawks' compensation pick which it gave to North Melbourne for David Hale.
Unless the Dogs receive the Hawks' second and third-round selections for Hill, the deal will not happen.


http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/chris-tarrant-in-limbo/story-fn69a32t-1225936468808

 

[Splodge15]

Silly suggestion from the Dogs, if true. He's not worth that.

Looks like it will have to be a 3 or 4 club deal.

 

[HawksILove]

3rd pick and maybe Ladson

 

[Leather Poisoning]

I'd say that the dogs wanted the pick to use in a trade for Sherman.

They'll be a little peeved at how things are tracking.

 

[Hawkzzz]

I'd say that the dogs wanted the pick to use in a trade for Sherman.

They'll be a little peeved at how things are tracking.

That's exactly what they want. But we're not in the business of helping the dogs improve their list. If Hill was worth a second round pick the club would have done the deal.

Just heard on SEN (10.45 pm) there might be a play for a KPD come Monday. The commentator (forgot his name) seems to think we're cooking something up before the deadline.

Who knows. It's the silly season and so much crap is said to make discussions interesting. Would be nice though. Would much rather this than wasting too much time on Hill (which won't get done).

 

[Messenger]

We can all check out Josh next time Willy visits Box Hill.

 

[Hodge2NormSmith]

If they want a second and a third round pick - in the spirit of negotiation we give two third round picks - they give their compo pick and one of the third rounders to Brisbane to get Sherman.

If we keep our first and second round picks I'm happy, If one of them is used to pick up a good KPD then even better.

 

[SodaPop]

We can all check out Josh next time Willy visits Box Hill.

Wonder what the dogs will get for him this time next year once his contract runs out?

 

[Hungry Hawk]

Asking for pick 37 is overs, regaurdless of our needs. We hav'nt tried Breust. Shiels or Savage may be worth punt in the forward line.

Leon Davis's name has been thrown around and I would prefer to offer pick 119 for him.

I'm with the Pelch, keep our pick 19 and 37 for the national draft.

 

[HawksILove]

Can Curnow from the Boxhill Hawks play that position?