Judd did eye gouge Brown

[dan warna]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

judd gouges brown and brown might cop a suspension or fine.

thats just uber rich!

If brown does cop a match suspension i think that would be hilarious and just another indictment on the AFL.

 

[DynamoUltra]

Poor Brownie? Poor Brownie put himself in on national TV. You can't blame Judd for that. Brownie should give himself a right uppercut.

Maybe the tribunal should have suspended Judd in the first place because the evidence is there for all to see. Had the tribunal done their job there would not be an issue.

 

[Blues_Man]

I would say all those that questioned Browns integrity. Maybe Braun wouldnt be happy.

questioned his integrity ...like saying he was a liar ??? But didn't he just admit that he was a liar ??? the blokes an obvious half wit just like his brain dead old man...he has about as much credibility as Joh Howard .

His comments also prove what a complete and utter moron he really is .

 

[Del Piero]

No sympathy for Brown. Has shown what a complete twit he is.
Judd has done nothing wrong..Dawk idiots trying to drag his name through the mud based on Browns 'new' evidence cannot be taken seriously because Brown has confirmed he is a LIAR.
A suspension is over the top, a reprimand will suffice...

 

[jazz]

No sympathy for Brown. Has shown what a complete twit he is.
Judd has done nothing wrong..Dawk idiots trying to drag his name through the mud based on Browns 'new' evidence cannot be taken seriously because Brown has confirmed he is a LIAR.
A suspension is over the top, a reprimand will suffice...

LIAR to protect Judd. What are all you WC knobs so heated up about?

From the cheeky grin he gave when asked about it on On The Couch, you could see that he didn't think that big a deal of it. Players code - have you heard of it?

 

[kimbopen]

what? lieing either to the tribunal or now 10 weeks late, bring the tribunal process into question and the game into disrepute? how has this been the right thing?

btw, welcome to 10 weeks ago, but the video evidence was inconclusive, only the haters truly believe that judd actually delibereately eye gouged. Put hird in judds position and you might start to understand what happened.

No. It's only you Wee Girls supporters who are quaking at the thought that YOUR GOLDEN CHILD might have actually tarnished his reputation somewhat.

You & your mob seem to be the only ones leaping blindly to Judd's defence.

As for Son of Reep ... the less said the better.

 

[Flukey!]

Dirty dog - Brown just spilled the beans ON the couch.

All those pleading his innocence post your apologies here....

Blind Freddy knew - everyone knew

 

[kimbopen]

LIAR to protect Judd. What are all you WC knobs so heated up about?

From the cheeky grin he gave when asked about it on On The Couch, you could see that he didn't think that big a deal of it. Players code - have you heard of it?

C'mon, jazz. We all know that West Coke Knobheads don't think of anything or anyone other than themselves!

 

[Didz_is_God_4]

If Brown is punished for this, it's a sad day in football, because the sportsmanship will be gone.

 

[Benno From Berwick]

When did telling the truth became so difficult?

Right is right! In fact I think you should be the right thing all the time just becuase it is right! Does that make me a bad person?

Brown didn't need to defend anyone, not his role to pass judgement, just tell the truth as he knew it at the time.

 

[SodaPop]

No sympathy for Brown. Has shown what a complete twit he is.
Judd has done nothing wrong..Dawk idiots trying to drag his name through the mud based on Browns 'new' evidence cannot be taken seriously because Brown has confirmed he is a LIAR.
A suspension is over the top, a reprimand will suffice...

That's gotta be the most funniest thing I've heard!!
If you weren't a WestCoke supporter I'd think you'd be poking fun!!

Just re-inforces most peoples opinions that most Egirls supporters are brain dead! The club that's brought the most shame to the AFL

 

[peternorth]

the umpire at the time of the incident said it was contact to the face. if thats the case was a free kick to brown paid at the time?

 

[OzSparrow]

I query what the reaction would be if Browny's lie had actually resulted in Juddy getting suspended when he should perhaps not have been?

The ends do NOT justify the means.

To simply condone the lie because of "mateship" is baloney!

 

[Del Piero]

That's gotta be the most funniest thing I've heard!!
If you weren't a WestCoke supporter I'd think you'd be poking fun!!

Just re-inforces most peoples opinions that most Egirls supporters are brain dead! The club that's brought the most shame to the AFL

As opposed to the constant crying of Dawk supporters. Tell me what was Brown's agenda, hey twit ?
Judd has not lied, only Brown !!! Brown's backflip does not make Judd an eye gouger either !!! Bit complex for you hey ? Like most dawk fans only want simplistic logic.. I would draw you a picture but im afraid you would get out your pencil case and start colouring in ...

 

[Butane]

As opposed to the constant crying of Dawk supporters. Tell me what was Brown's agenda, hey twit ?
Judd has not lied, only Brown !!! Brown's backflip does not make Judd an eye gouger either !!! Bit complex for you hey ? Like most dawk fans only want simplistic logic.. I would draw you a picture but im afraid you would get out your pencil case and start colouring in ...

Brown says 'i lied, Judd eye gouged me'....how does that not make Judd an eye gouger?

 

[doodlefeatures]

As opposed to the constant crying of Dawk supporters. Tell me what was Brown's agenda, hey twit ?
Judd has not lied, only Brown !!! Brown's backflip does not make Judd an eye gouger either !!! Bit complex for you hey ? Like most dawk fans only want simplistic logic.. I would draw you a picture but im afraid you would get out your pencil case and start colouring in ...

What's 'Dawk'? Is that a "funny" name for Hawk? hahaha - good one, you're a classic

 

[Flukey!]

As opposed to the constant crying of Dawk supporters. Tell me what was Brown's agenda, hey twit ?
Judd has not lied, only Brown !!! Brown's backflip does not make Judd an eye gouger either !!! Bit complex for you hey ? Like most dawk fans only want simplistic logic.. I would draw you a picture but im afraid you would get out your pencil case and start colouring in ...

Thats a bullshit post.

You critisize Brown for sticking up for Judd and call him a liar.
Judd lied too when he said he wasnt guilty.
Take your rose colored glasses off mate - they are impairing your ability to see clearly.

 

[Del Piero]

Brown says 'i lied, Judd eye gouged me'....how does that not make Judd an eye gouger?

what ? Your making things up now..

 

[Del Piero]

Thats a bullshit post.

You critisize Brown for sticking up for Judd and call him a liar.
Judd lied too when he said he wasnt guilty.
Take your rose colored glasses off mate - they are impairing your ability to see clearly.

OMG twit logic !! So Brown's backflip automatically makes Judd guilty !!
There needs to be intent from Judd...Where exactly has this been proven ?

 

[Dippers Donuts]

Surprise surprise, Browny lied for Judd.
Wow.

Course Judd gouged him - should have got two weeks at the time. The video evidence was conclusive.

Stupid AFL cannot suspend/fine Brown now - to do so would admit Judd gouged.

 

[FuManchu]

Surprise surprise, Browny lied for Judd.
Wow.

Course Judd gouged him - should have got two weeks at the time. The video evidence was conclusive.

Stupid AFL cannot suspend/fine Brown now - to do so would admit Judd gouged.

You dont quite fathom the seperate nature of the incidents. One went to the tribunal and was acquited of the incident partly because of the false testimony of a player. That false testimony is a completely seperate issue and can draw a penalty. Judd being guilty is irrelevant now, he has gone thru the process for his incident. Brown hasnt yet.

 

[The Rat]

OMG twit logic !! So Brown's backflip automatically makes Judd guilty !!
There needs to be intent from Judd...Where exactly has this been proven ?

Get over it, Judd's just as fallible as any other footballer

 

[Dippers Donuts]

You dont quite fathom the seperate nature of the incidents. One went to the tribunal and was acquited of the incident partly because of the false testimony of a player. That false testimony is a completely seperate issue and can draw a penalty. Judd being guilty is irrelevant now, he has gone thru the process for his incident. Brown hasnt yet.

You must be a collingwood supporter...oh hang on...

Yes they are separate but related issues here.

The AFL will not have the balls to fine/suspend Brown. The uproar from the AFL community will prevent that.

Or do we go back and drag Chick into this given his dodgy testimony.

It's about nuance.

 

[The Rat]

You dont quite fathom the seperate nature of the incidents. One went to the tribunal and was acquited of the incident partly because of the false testimony of a player. That false testimony is a completely seperate issue and can draw a penalty. Judd being guilty is irrelevant now, he has gone thru the process for his incident. Brown hasnt yet.

You're right and if the AFL wants to stop this sort of thing happening they should suspend Brown (very hard for me to say)

He's given himself up on a plate to be made an example of

 

[FuManchu]

You must be a collingwood supporter...oh hang on...

Yes they are separate but related issues here.

The AFL will not have the balls to fine/suspend Brown. The uproar from the AFL community will prevent that.

Or do we go back and drag Chick into this given his dodgy testimony.

It's about nuance.

Its about bringing the integrity of the whole tribunal process into question. The AFL will most probably fine him.