Judds Honour Board - Hats off to the champ!

[The Octopus]

Just saw list of what he has acheived. Only 27 y/o.

AFLPA Best First Year Player
1 x MVP Award
2 x Brownlows
1 x Brownlow R/U
5 x All Aust (One as captain)
5 x Club Champion B & F (includes 2010 as its a monty)
1 x Norm Smith
1 x Premiership Captain

WOW!

 

[Lazarus]

He's gonna win at least the next six B+Fs at Carlton. Seriously who is gonna beat him?

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Gibbs and Murphy...lol

 

[mk#1]

He's gonna win at least the next six B+Fs at Carlton. Seriously who is gonna beat him?

got a feeling matthew kruezer after next year will win a couple

 

[kid_a]

a part of me will always hate him for up and leaving us in a very dark time, but most of me will always love him for what he did in our jumper.

a true champion, and to be honest i let off a lttle cheer everytime i see him on the TV.

 

[blueboy25]

Gibbs and Murphy...lol

masten and notte.... lol

 

[WakeUpPies]

Wow did we merge the Carlton board and the main board?

Be right back I am going to make one for Robert Harvey, then maybe Wayne Carey.

 

[swanTodidak]

opps wrong board i saw judd`s name i thought it was dudd sorry

 

[Pj.Rj.Hj]

a part of me will always hate him for up and leaving us in a very dark time, but most of me will always love him for what he did in our jumper.

a true champion, and to be honest i let off a lttle cheer everytime i see him on the TV.

+1. I didn't realise til last night that I wasn't really pissed off with him anymore, though it still kind of hurts.

 

[Koutou43]

Chris Judd the greatest player of our life time!!!!!!!!

 

[JSFish]

Wow did we merge the Carlton board and the main board?

Be right back I am going to make one for Robert Harvey, then maybe Wayne Carey.

I was unaware that both Robert Harvey and Wayne Carey also won the Brownlow last night.

 

[Thommo 42]

Simon Black says hi.

3 x Premierships
1 x Norm Smith
1 x Brownlow
3 x Brownlow R/Up
3 x B&F
Back to Back B&F in Premiership Years (massive achievement given the side he was in)
4 x R/Up B&F

I'm sure there is more, but those are the ones I know from the top of my head

 

[Soul_Pie]

But I'm not wearing a hat.

 

[Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite]

Simon Black says hi.

3 x Premierships
1 x Norm Smith
1 x Brownlow
3 x Brownlow R/Up
3 x B&F
Back to Back B&F in Premiership Years (massive achievement given the side he was in)
4 x R/Up B&F

I'm sure there is more, but those are the ones I know from the top of my head

lol didn't realise this thread was a competition or comparison of some sort? seems simply like one acknowledging the achievements of one player. op doesn't compare him to anyone

 

[blues4flag]

Simon Black says hi.

3 x Premierships
1 x Norm Smith
1 x Brownlow
3 x Brownlow R/Up
3 x B&F
Back to Back B&F in Premiership Years (massive achievement given the side he was in)
4 x R/Up B&F

I'm sure there is more, but those are the ones I know from the top of my head

3 x B&Fs.

Though that said, not sure why you posted that?

Fair enough 2 more premierships but it doesn't add much to individual accolades.

5 B&Fs > 3 B&Fs
5 AAs > 3 AAs
1 AA captain > 0 AA captain
2 Brownlows > 1 Brownlow
1 premiership captain > 0 premiership captain
1 MVP > 0 MVP
1 Norm Smith = 1 Norm Smith

Even though Black's played 76 more games, he only has 2 more Brownlow votes over the course of his career.

In terms of individual honours, Gary Ablett Jr. would be right up there:

2 B&Fs (perhaps 3 after this season, though probably unlikely)
4 x AA, one as vice captain
Brownlow medal
2 x premiership player
3 x MVP
3 x AFLCA's POTY

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

In terms of individual honours, Gary Ablett Jr. would be right up there:

2 B&Fs (perhaps 3 after this season, though probably unlikely)
4 x AA, one as vice captain
Brownlow medal
2 x premiership player
3 x MVP
3 x AFLCA's POTY

Should probably have 2 Brownlows to Judd's 1. Was favourite for 2 other years as well, crazy.

 

[Thommo 42]

Lets just suggest that B&F's are reasonably easily won at Carlton, compared to say - Brisbane in the middle of a dynasty!

David Teague?

 

[blues4flag]

Lets just suggest that B&F's are reasonably easily won at Carlton, compared to say - Brisbane in the middle of a dynasty!

David Teague?

Rubbish. He won it in 08 over a man who kicked 99 goals and was AA FF. Won it last season in a top 8 side over Murphy (AA squad, top 10 in Brownlow), Gibbs (top 10 in Brownlow) and Fevola (AA team). This season was easier than the last two but we still finished top 8. David Teague won it 4 seasons before Judd came to the club.

Judd won two his two WC B&Fs in 2004 (7th) and 2006 (premiers).

Brisbane have only made the finals once in the last 6 years, yet Black only managed one B&F in that period. If anything, it's been easier to win a B&F at Brisbane in recent years than at Carlton.

 

[Monkey King]

Should probably have 2 Brownlows to Judd's 1. Was favourite for 2 other years as well, crazy.

Ahem ... 2006. Maybe you should call that two each yeah

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Surely Brock McLean will steal votes from Juddy next year?

 

[SpaceCow]

Surely Brock McLean will steal votes from Juddy next year?

Bull****. Brock McLean is an injured hack who we overpaid for.

 

[Monkey King]

Surely Brock McLean will steal votes from Juddy next year?

Injury troll.