Strategy Just play: Hardwick's simple plan to unleash Tigers

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Are you suggesting that when our coach says this is the best list he has had since last year when he made that statement again, he is telling porkies?
Was not suggesting anything just voicing my long held opinion. If i was to surmise id say when Hardwick says that he may well be correct but in no way does that mean we are a top 4 team or even a cert to make the 8.
If the coach thinks that id say hes deluded like so many others.
 
The Standard Pre-Season Puff Piece to get memberships up. Right up there with Wayne Campbell pronouncing one pre season that we were going make the Top 4
Yeah it's not like 17 other clubs do the same thing or anything
 

No ... i am talking about the finals win being a pass mark that was set for 2015.
We didn't achieve a finals win - the club said it was a bare pass mark.
Peggy said last year the board did not ignore that criteria but they pushed ahead with a coaching extension, which I find dd.
Why extend a contract if someone fails the club's own benchmarks?
 
No ... i am talking about the finals win being a pass mark that was set for 2015.
We didn't achieve a finals win - the club said it was a bare pass mark.
Peggy said last year the board did not ignore that criteria but they pushed ahead with a coaching extension, which I find dd.
Why extend a contract if someone fails the club's own benchmarks?

I apologise in that case.
I thought you were regurgitating the trumped up lie of Hardwick promising we'll make finals this year. Which he never did.
Carry on.
 
Not sure if it has been said, but I love the thread title. Unleashing some tigers on the pitch would probably end the game before it starts, but we could get some genuine first century Roman entertainment happening which I for one would applaud :D

You guys opening a banter thread for round 1? If not, there's plenty of room on the Carlton board one.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

thats because it is..

even if its not a good list (thats coming from Mopsy, bloke who rates everyones list as being better than ours) it is still better than the list he had when he arrived, even 2-3 years ago.
WTF i have rarely spoken about other teams lists, amazing the ability of some to read other peoples minds .

Hmm what did i say about our list oh yes and it has been constant, we have a decent best 22 that is capable of competing with most other sides.
We will finish somewhere between 7th - 14th . That is make the 8 if all goes well and if a few things go wrong slide. If we have a horror run with injuries i would not be surprised to see a bottom 2 finish.
In short our best 22 is middling imo and we fall away after that equating to a very shallow and weak overall list.Just my opinion and nothing to get upset about.
 
Not sure if it has been said, but I love the thread title. Unleashing some tigers on the pitch would probably end the game before it starts, but we could get some genuine first century Roman entertainment happening which I for one would applaud :D

You guys opening a banter thread for round 1? If not, there's plenty of room on the Carlton board one.

The last time we 'unleashed' anything it was the 'Giesch', so we're better ff shelving the word or notion of unleashing anything!
 
WTF i have rarely spoken about other teams lists, amazing the ability of some to read other peoples minds .

Hmm what did i say about our list oh yes and it has been constant, we have a decent best 22 that is capable of competing with most other sides.
We will finish somewhere between 7th - 14th . That is make the 8 if all goes well and if a few things go wrong slide. If we have a horror run with injuries i would not be surprised to see a bottom 2 finish.
In short our best 22 is middling imo and we fall away after that equating to a very shallow and weak overall list.Just my opinion and nothing to get upset about.
Perhaps he is referring more to the list age profile? There are some glaring gaps (perhaps the cream we are adding?) and a lot of "potential". Could also be referring to the list in terms of the position players were originally drafted which goes back to potential.
End of the day I think it is/was a throw away line to a question which has come back to haunt him giving the media and his critics something to hang him on, particularly when we aren't going well.
 
Yes they do. But we specialise in it. In fact, we are so good at it, we don't actually need to win any finals games. Saying we will is enough for Richmond supporters

No

we do it no more or less than other clubs.

We just notice it more because we are richmond supporters, we dont take notice of other clubs as much.

If you became a Geelong supporter tomorrow for a year, you would notice they do it just as much

same as every other club.
 
Not sure if it has been said, but I love the thread title. Unleashing some tigers on the pitch would probably end the game before it starts, but we could get some genuine first century Roman entertainment happening which I for one would applaud :D

You guys opening a banter thread for round 1? If not, there's plenty of room on the Carlton board one.

Lol your soft mods ban anyone from our board who posts in that thread. So big pass
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Strategy Just play: Hardwick's simple plan to unleash Tigers

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top