Kyabram DFL discussion 2024

[smooth mover]

What were they reported / suspended for ?

Seems to be a lot more reports this year. Umpires getting abit card happy?

Not 100% sure on Brandon's & James incidents, from what I'm told they we're both just late to a marking contest?

O'Rielly's was in our game & he was abit unlucky in my opinion! 1 of our boys took a mark & went to play on in centre of the ground which was very hard & slippery, as he took a step he seen Knackers coming at him so went to sidestep him & slipped on the centre, at the same time Knackers went to give him a bump all legal but because of the slip got him high! It was just 1 of those unfortunate series of incidents that all lined up at the wrong time! But I think the reprimand was a fair outcome as it shouldn't have been any game's missed.

 

[brownsnake]

I think more and more clubs will start filming games especially in the month before finals.
Some of the suspensions/reprimands I have seen over the last 2 years would get off with footage in a tribunal setting.

 

[fatkidinthepocket]

I think more and more clubs will start filming games especially in the month before finals.
Some of the suspensions/reprimands I have seen over the last 2 years would get off with footage in a tribunal setting.

This can also work in the reverse though.Will Holt playing for Wedderburn v Boort a couple of years ago not reported on the day got 3 weeks off the video.

 

[Normo3]

I think more and more clubs will start filming games especially in the month before finals.
Some of the suspensions/reprimands I have seen over the last 2 years would get off with footage in a tribunal setting.

People getting reprimanded for a push and shove these days..

 

[Take it easy]

Not 100% sure on Brandon's & James incidents, from what I'm told they we're both just late to a marking contest?

O'Rielly's was in our game & he was abit unlucky in my opinion! 1 of our boys took a mark & went to play on in centre of the ground which was very hard & slippery, as he took a step he seen Knackers coming at him so went to sidestep him & slipped on the centre, at the same time Knackers went to give him a bump all legal but because of the slip got him high! It was just 1 of those unfortunate series of incidents that all lined up at the wrong time! But I think the reprimand was a fair outcome as it shouldn't have been any game's missed.

I saw the Avola incident and same sort of thing 2 players went for the ball Avola seen him and tried to push him off the ball but made contact and accidentally made high contact and umpire reported him.
No malice at all and was a complete accident, no Rushy boys remonstrated but umpire reported him, even heard that second umpire didn’t think it was a reportable offence.
But that’s the way the KDFL is going at the moment.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

I saw the Avola incident and same sort of thing 2 players went for the ball Avola seen him and tried to push him off the ball but made contact and accidentally made high contact and umpire reported him.
No malice at all and was a complete accident, no Rushy boys remonstrated but umpire reported him, even heard that second umpire didn’t think it was a reportable offence.
But that’s the way the KDFL is going at the moment.

Kdfl or Gvfua ? I watched a game recently and from the frequency of changing decisions with hand to ear , it would be easy to assume the bloke in the grandstand was often overruling via the ear piece.

 

[smooth mover]

Kdfl or Gvfua ? I watched a game recently and from the frequency of changing decisions with hand to ear , it would be easy to assume the bloke in the grandstand was often overruling via the ear piece.

Only some KDFL game's have had the overseeing umpire in the earpiece! It's generally used for GVFL & MFL! We had it in 1 of our games when there was a split round in the GV! I believe there's only half a dozen of those units! So not all games get them..... But agree there may be some decisions getting changed at the time due to this technology!

 

[MortlockWatcher]

Has it got to that in grassroots football?
A third (or fourth) umpire playing God in the grandstand telling his puppets what to do?

Hopefully the off-field person has a clue about the game.
Thought this crap only happened in international cricket.

 

[vafa around the traps]

Do they have a third umpire in netball?

 

[tigstime69]

I saw the Avola incident and same sort of thing 2 players went for the ball Avola seen him and tried to push him off the ball but made contact and accidentally made high contact and umpire reported him.
No malice at all and was a complete accident, no Rushy boys remonstrated but umpire reported him, even heard that second umpire didn’t think it was a reportable offence.
But that’s the way the KDFL is going at the moment.

Definitely wasn’t a great deal in it. Both went to pick up a loose ball, Avola turned side on as Matt Caton was picking up the ball and went in a bit lower than Avola and Avola accidentally hit him in the face with his elbow. Was a free kick at best, stiff to get a week. Never took his eyes off the ball

 

[AaronSCHQ]

Has it got to that in grassroots football?
A third (or fourth) umpire playing God in the grandstand telling his puppets what to do?

Hopefully the off-field person has a clue about the game.
Thought this crap only happened in international cricket.

I’m not aware whether the umpires with communication is just for overturning calls. We had one last year at Merrigum and in the rooms at the half time break he was giving feedback to the central umpire. So I’m going to guess a lot of it is meant for coaching inexperienced umpires, not just overturning/overruling. Just a hunch.

 

[WB ute]

Brandon Avola - Avenel - 1 week
James Lloyd - Murch - Rep
Nathan O'Rielly - Stanhope - Rep

Not the best week to be missing Avola. Lakers just got a few goals closer

 

[WB ute]

Definitely wasn’t a great deal in it. Both went to pick up a loose ball, Avola turned side on as Matt Caton was picking up the ball and went in a bit lower than Avola and Avola accidentally hit him in the face with his elbow. Was a free kick at best, stiff to get a week. Never took his eyes off the ball

Seems like a classic case of the age-old scenario....star players either get targeted by umps or looked after like a relative .

 

[WB ute]

People getting reprimanded for a push and shove these days..

Some of these umps would have fainted with some of the goings on 20+ years ago Normo

 

[Normo3]

Some of these umps would have fainted with some of the goings on 20+ years ago Normo

Yep your not wrong, only gunna get worse aswell

 

[gomavs]

Stanhope 100+
Rushworth 18
Lancaster 100+
Murchison 80
Avenel 45
Gig 40
Shepp East 45

 

[phantom man]

Stanhope 100+
Rushworth 18
Lancaster 100+
Murchison 80
Avenel 45
Gig 40
Shepp East 45

Tally Vs Shepp East Should Be a Good Game On Sunday

 

[onthehill24]

Stanhope 100+
Rushworth 18
Lancaster 100+
Murchison 80
Avenel 45
Gig 40
Shepp East 45

Paulo to kick 7 for the bats

 

[jayco13]

Paulo to kick 7 for the bats

Kicked 5 in a half for ky ressies 2 weeks ago v Tat.... easy a lazy 10

 

[cheezeyfingers]

Whispers Barry Hall will be lacing the boots up for Swans on premiership reunion day vs Merrigum . Ex Avenel junior and in u18s team of century.

The big fella would still dominate

 

[far canal club]

Kdfl or Gvfua ? I watched a game recently and from the frequency of changing decisions with hand to ear , it would be easy to assume the bloke in the grandstand was often overruling via the ear piece.

Wouldn’t happen in the PDFL!

 

[onthehill24]

Stanhope 100+
Rushworth 18
Lancaster 100+
Murchison 80
Avenel 45
Gig 40
Shepp East 45

I reckon merrigum will roll gig

 

[Trueblue1234]

Paulo to kick 7 for the bats

Is Paulo playing for Lancaster ?

 

[superstar53]

first time poster, paulo will kick 12, smokey for league goal kicking

 

[jayco13]

Is Paulo playing for Lancaster ?

Not named in the senior team... I'll check the reserves line up