Who does he play for?
And Essendon supporters won't get it........................
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Who does he play for?
this is a good question - exchange mid-fields and the gap closes substantially.Lance clearly the better player but here is a serious question:
How would they go if the role's were reversed. Buddy plays for Collingwood and Cloke plays for the Hawks?
First off, I am NOT suggesting the Buddy is only better because he plays for the Hawks, just curious. Buddy would not be getting 10 shots a game with our midfield supply, that's a given and he would probably be getting double teamed (a la Tarrant) every week. Would definentely still get 65+ goals for the year though. As for Cloke I'm guessing he would play further up the ground as that is his strong point. Most of the goalkicking would be going through Roughead with some cameo performances from Cloke.
guess the only small thing Clokey has over them is that he has performed in finalsCollingwood fans should stop even trying to justify the crap in this thread.
Buddy by a county mile over Cloke.......... End of story.
Now Cloke V Roughead is a better comparison.
Also it's Roughead >>>>>>> Cloke.
Roughead has 69 goals compared to Clokes mid 30.
Cloke is a good footballer but if you watch him closely when he is put on a quality backman he really struggles.
Croad has torn him a new one the last few times they have played against each other.
guess the only small thing Clokey has over them is that he has performed in finals
Lance clearly the better player but here is a serious question:
How would they go if the role's were reversed. Buddy plays for Collingwood and Cloke plays for the Hawks?
First off, I am NOT suggesting the Buddy is only better because he plays for the Hawks, just curious. Buddy would not be getting 10 shots a game with our midfield supply, that's a given and he would probably be getting double teamed (a la Tarrant) every week. Would definentely still get 65+ goals for the year though. As for Cloke I'm guessing he would play further up the ground as that is his strong point. Most of the goalkicking would be going through Roughead with some cameo performances from Cloke.
Lance clearly the better player but here is a serious question:
How would they go if the role's were reversed. Buddy plays for Collingwood and Cloke plays for the Hawks?
First off, I am NOT suggesting the Buddy is only better because he plays for the Hawks, just curious. Buddy would not be getting 10 shots a game with our midfield supply, that's a given and he would probably be getting double teamed (a la Tarrant) every week. Would definentely still get 65+ goals for the year though. As for Cloke I'm guessing he would play further up the ground as that is his strong point. Most of the goalkicking would be going through Roughead with some cameo performances from Cloke.
Then everyone will laugh at you as well, and perhaps this thread can sink to the murky depths once more.
Completely wrongNo doubt Franklin is a better player, but at least Cloke plays for his team, Buddy plays for himself.
and just no...I think after tonight & last week's performance, a certain somebody has clearly edged in front.
I think after tonight & last week's performance, a certain somebody has clearly edged in front.
are u serious???? ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hahahahahahahahahahaI think after tonight & last week's performance, a certain somebody has clearly edged in front.
you're as stupid as the people who think Cloke is as good as Franklingod damn it this thread is annoying. it is beyond me why it hasnt been locked yet. ppl saying that cloke is anywhere near franklin back then AND now are kidding themselves and so are the ppl that think cloke is a 'good' CHF, it's a joke, he has had a piss poor year this year with the exception of a few games. he is easily ur weakest link through the spine.
god damn it this thread is annoying. it is beyond me why it hasnt been locked yet. ppl saying that cloke is anywhere near franklin back then AND now are kidding themselves and so are the ppl that think cloke is a 'good' CHF, it's a joke, he has had a piss poor year this year with the exception of a few games. he is easily ur weakest link through the spine.
Franklin is a long way ahead of Cloke, but Cloke is a very good player in his own right and anyone who thinks otherwise is as delusional as those saying that Cloke is better than Franklin.
How would they go if the role's were reversed. Buddy plays for Collingwood and Cloke plays for the Hawks?
I don't think anyone in their right minds honestly believes Cloke is even close to Franklin.