Autopsy Like an expansion team: Tigers make history on day of sadness, rebirth

Remove this Banner Ad

😂 your comparing is clearly biased . He has a long history of picking speculative pics well before others have rated them which have subsequently failed across varied rounds of pics including high pics Eg Conca , Tambling, Jon , Vickery and the well publicised behind tree Dea . It was crazy behaviour.
‘Lack of resources ‘ is a lame excuse and in accurate. The early period of his involvement is where most clubs had spotters around the country who lived within communities and Richmond had as many as any club . Difference is he continually just ignored those people and pinned his career on being someone who found diamonds in the rough .
Martin and Cotchin were both highly rated and many thought could / should have went #1 in their draft year , the fact the ended up at Richmond with 3 & 2 respectively and full filled their potential , has saved fine eyes of scrutiny .

Francis Jackson was Richmond's sole full time recruiter 2006-07-08. True, or false?

The Richmond recruiting department was not fully staffed v other clubs until at least 2014. True, or false?

Around 80% of Richmond's dynasty Premiership players were recruited with Francis Jackson in charge of recruiting, and the other 20% were recruited with him as a member of the recruiting team. True, or false?

There was a massive disparity in football department spending - including recruiting - between the richest and poorest clubs which led to the introduction of the soft cap in 2015(mysteriously, right as Richmond were in a position to start matching spending with the richest clubs.) True, or false?
 
Last edited:
Francis Jackson was Richmond's sole full time recruiter 2006-07-08. True, or false?

The Richmond recruiting department was not fully staffed v other clubs until at least 2014. True, or false?

Around 80% of Richmond's dynasty Premiership players were recruited with Francis Jackson in charge of recruiting, and the other 20% were recruited with him as a member of the recruiting team. True, or false?

There was a massive disparity in football department spending - including recruiting - between the richest and poorest clubs which led to the introduction of the soft cap in 2015(mysteriously, right as Richmond were in a position to start matching spending with the richest clubs.) True, or false?
**** me , honestly . Your suggesting he gets a free pass from 2006-2014 claiming being under resourced and then want to claim those as success storiies by way of saying they were part of the premiership years .
Pics v results was deplorable !
 
**** me , honestly . Your suggesting he gets a free pass from 2006-2014 claiming being under resourced and then want to claim those as success storiies by way of saying they were part of the premiership years .
Pics v results was deplorable !




I suppose people can read the exchange and figure out their view of it now.

The bloke has done an amazing job for Richmond. You can catch some debate and analysis & my comparisons of Richmond's recruiting with FJ as boss here from page 15:

 

Log in to remove this ad.

I suppose people can read the exchange and figure out their view of it now.

The bloke has done an amazing job for Richmond. You can catch some debate and analysis & my comparisons of Richmond's recruiting with FJ as boss here from page 15:


Picked Dusty, Jack, Tross, chimp, shedda good enough for me
 
**** me , honestly . Your suggesting he gets a free pass from 2006-2014 claiming being under resourced and then want to claim those as success storiies by way of saying they were part of the premiership years .
Pics v results was deplorable !
😂 your comparing is clearly biased . He has a long history of picking speculative pics well before others have rated them which have subsequently failed across varied rounds of pics including high pics Eg Conca , Tambling, Jon , Vickery and the well publicised behind tree Dea . It was crazy behaviour.
‘Lack of resources ‘ is a lame excuse and in accurate. The early period of his involvement is where most clubs had spotters around the country who lived within communities and Richmond had as many as any club . Difference is he continually just ignored those people and pinned his career on being someone who found diamonds in the rough .
Martin and Cotchin were both highly rated and many thought could / should have went #1 in their draft year , the fact the ended up at Richmond with 3 & 2 respectively and full filled their potential , has saved fine eyes of scrutiny .
What's your vendetta here? How could his work be considered deplorable when he drafted our dynasty?

He wasn't even around for drafting Tambling and JON. His first two picks at Richmond were JR8 and Edwards.

He didn't just nail his top 5 picks, his 2014 rookie draft may well be the best ever - Short, Castagna, Lambert, Soldo.

But it doesn't really matter, you're not open to changing your view anyway, even if he drafts our next dynasty in November.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy Like an expansion team: Tigers make history on day of sadness, rebirth

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top