Live All Australian Thread

[PP34]

Petrie over Goldstein. WTF is Kelly doing in the team?

 

[Lockyer24]

Scott Thompson the stiffest, I reckon he was better than Boyd and not far off Mitchell, just played in a crap side

Don't particularly care for Goldstein, would pick Petrie ahead of him every day of the week

 

[Big Red is back]

no goldstein what a joke.

Petrie better fwd so had to grab him instead

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Thompson is so much better than Boyd it isn't funny.

**** Luke Darcy.

 

[DO IT TO IT]

This year he has beat up on poor sides, and struggled against the big boys. Doesn't deserve it imo.

could say the same thing about judd, milne, petrie, boyd and a few others too.

gibson was shocking every time he played geelong and yet you think he should be aa.

 

[rose jam]

Scott Thompson the unluckiest

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

Boyd? Has he hit a target all year?

Easily the worst AA ever to make it. One of the worst kicks I have ever seen.

 

[PP34]

LMAOOOO I can't believe this is a serious post.

If would have been a total farce if any of the Collingwood six missed the team tonight. All have had dominant years and deserved AA honours.

Swan far from dominant this year mate. He's been great but dominant not the word.

 

[jackess]

I agree with about 50% of the team.

 

[Matthew2708]

Lol. This award is officially a ****ing joke.

Hmm.. it's only an opinion though. Very hard to pick a best 22 these days.

 

[Butler]

HF should be:

Johnson - Cloke - Fyfe

Midfielders are midfielders. They fight for the spot of best midfielders don't they?

Also Petrie as the back up ruck? He hasn't been the second best ruckman this year.

 

[beez]

gibson???? gibson???? gibson???

Trololololol

 

[apollo_creed]

is luke darcy on the panel is he?

gee that guys a ****wit.

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

Thompson is so much better than Boyd it isn't funny.

**** Luke Darcy.

Luke Darcy is a joke

 

[Bayer_]

Amazing a confidence player like Leon Davis makes it in yet again, an old hack like Scarlett is given a guernsey, yet Gibson misses out. Seems the AA is still the same big circle jerk we've become used to.

 

[Wacky Tiger]

Would love to know the criteria they use for the selections, some head shaking choices for sure.

Petrie WTF.

 

[rose jam]

Petrie over Goldstein. WTF is Kelly doing in the team?

Petrie makes sense in a balanced side.

Kelly clearly Geelong's best midfielder

 

[ImperialPurple]

No McPharlin... Thought he'd at least get a spot on the bench.

 

[Lach72]

If you want an accumulator then Thompson should be there before Boyd.

McPharlin is hideously unlucky. I'd have serious queries over Drew Petrie too.

 

[Sin City]

Drew Petrie? What the **** are they smoking?

 

[Dan]

Chewy gonna be mad...

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

If you want an accumulator then Thompson should be there before Boyd.

McPharlin is hideously unlucky. I'd have serious queries over Drew Petrie too.

I agree with all of this ^^^

 

[PP34]

Judd surely has to be Captain.

 

[Spector]

If we can name midfielders and half back flankers at HFF then we might as well just make the whole team midfielders selection panel.

Utter disgrace that Fyfe didn't get in, or Goldstein.

Just because you get big numbers as midfielder doesn't mean you can pop them wherever on the field. Have a look at that forward line and tell me if it would function in a real game.

 

[Bardo State]

Only got 2 players right in the backline IMO