Recommitted Logan McDonald [OOC 2024]

[Elmer_Hauser]

I'm not as big on him personally (not enough points of difference IMO) and I'd rather the capital spent elsewhere but it would definitely be the most talented forwardline we've ever had

I think Freo definitely has issues about your backline and KPD stocks that need addressing, but the supremely talented Amiss aside, your club have had problems kicking large/match winning scores for several years now, I would absolutely do it if I was Freo.

I am very confident McDonald will eventually be a Coleman Medalist type of match winning foward..

You got to do whatever it takes to get him in purple, in my opinion

 

[RUNVS]

* me dead. This kid isn't worthy of holding Schultz's boots.

I cannot believe we are trading this guy in.

You say that like it is certain. I think Sydney will probably sign McDonald in a few months, and I will be relieved when we do.

 

[RonnieRaven]

I'm not as big on him personally (not enough points of difference IMO) and I'd rather the capital spent elsewhere but it would definitely be the most talented forwardline we've ever had

Modra and Clive?….

 

[Jeremias]

Won't leave this year but he's a big watch heading into next season obviously.

Fremantle will be very keen and have armed themselves with plenty of assets to get a deal done should he decide to head home.

 

[Puregold]

Wouldn’t be surprised if we put out an offer to Sydney now.
Your choice of two future firsts + the Liam henry pick

 

[RUNVS]

Wouldn’t be surprised if we put out an offer to Sydney now.
Your choice of two future firsts + the Liam henry pick

Truthfully that is what I am worried about, and if something happens Sydney have the fun task of trying to guess which clubs (of teams you have first rounders for) will be most shite in 2024.

 

[MakeshiftMartyr]

We showed you our draft hand please respond.

 

[Rod Stroker]

What if he decides to head home next year, but nominates WC? Like Kelly, Brockman, etc.

I don't really see anyone, apart from Jackson, wanting to play at Freo. I do, though, see best 22 players leaving Freo; Logue, Henry, Lobb, Schulz, Acres..

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

What if he decides to head home next year, but nominates WC? Like Kelly, Brockman, etc.

I don't really see anyone, apart from Jackson, wanting to play at Freo. I do, though, see best 22 players leaving Freo; Logue, Henry, Lobb, Schulz, Acres..

We would have traded in as many players as we lost (probably part of the problem) so maybe you need glasses to see better?

 

[Puregold]

What if he decides to head home next year, but nominates WC? Like Kelly, Brockman, etc.

I don't really see anyone, apart from Jackson, wanting to play at Freo. I do, though, see best 22 players leaving Freo; Logue, Henry, Lobb, Schulz, Acres..

Jordan Clark did
Before that Lobb, Hamling, Colyer, Wilson
Also Hogan, Bennell

Kelly is a gun but the eagles haven’t exactly got us covered in this realm.
Our problem seems to be keeping them after the front loaded section of their contracts is up

 

[Rod Stroker]

Jordan Clark did
Before that Lobb, Hamling, Colyer, Wilson
Also Hogan, Bennell

Kelly is a gun but the eagles haven’t exactly got us covered in this realm.
Our problem seems to be keeping them after the front loaded section of their contracts is up

I was more talking about the last couple of years, hence the players I mentioned. More out than in.

 

[Kanye West]

What if he decides to head home next year, but nominates WC? Like Kelly, Brockman, etc.

I don't really see anyone, apart from Jackson, wanting to play at Freo. I do, though, see best 22 players leaving Freo; Logue, Henry, Lobb, Schulz, Acres..

Jackson and maybe...
Clark?
Brodie?
O'Meara?

2021 and 2022 off seasons. People only see what they want to see though...

 

[Footy Smarts]

Am I the only one who thinks McDonald has been pretty unimpressive? No idea why Freo would go hard for him when they've got Amiss and Jackson already.

 

[RonnieRaven]

What if he decides to head home next year, but nominates WC? Like Kelly, Brockman, etc.

I don't really see anyone, apart from Jackson, wanting to play at Freo. I do, though, see best 22 players leaving Freo; Logue, Henry, Lobb, Schulz, Acres..

Do you recommend walking to vfl house and beg for handouts?

 

[RUNVS]

Am I the only one who thinks McDonald has been pretty unimpressive? No idea why Freo would go hard for him when they've got Amiss and Jackson already.

At the same age

 

[Footy Smarts]

At the same age

View attachment 1832388

This is sort of the point. Hawkins is the poster child for the slow developing key forward cause he was really poor until late in his fifth season.

But most gun key forwards don't start quite so slow. There are a lot of young key forwards with similar stats to that. How many have careers like Hawkins?

 

[RUNVS]

This is sort of the point. Hawkins is the poster child for the slow developing key forward cause he was really poor until late in his fifth season.

But most gun key forwards don't start quite so slow. There are a lot of young key forwards with similar stats to that. How many have careers like Hawkins?

I'll pick someone else then

 

[Rod Stroker]

Do you recommend walking to vfl house and beg for handouts?

worked for us. we'll probably go back for more, because the ones they gave us 2 weeks ago, we don't have any more.

 

[DeathlyAccurate]

I'll pick someone else then

View attachment 1832401

And that’s with JK having 10kg on Logan.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Moonatic77]

Wouldn’t be surprised if we put out an offer to Sydney now.
Your choice of two future firsts + the Liam henry pick

Would be a great move for Freo if they pulled that off

 

[bzparkes]

I'll pick someone else then

View attachment 1832401

But along with Hawkins, Kennedy's the poster child for slow starts...

 

[mattwa]

* me dead. This kid isn't worthy of holding Schultz's boots.

I cannot believe we are trading this guy in.

This guy is way better and more valuable than Schultz. Young KPF who's ready to explode. You would have had to give up Schultz + an early pick or 2 to get McDonald

 

[RUNVS]

Just because I feel like it I might add another



So yes, McDonald is progressing fine for his age.

 

[bzparkes]

Just because I feel like it I might add another

View attachment 1832435

So yes, McDonald is progressing fine for his age.

Wasn't Hall yet another slow starter?...

 

[RUNVS]

Wasn't Hall yet another slow starter?...

Along with Nick