McGuane bump on Farren Ray

[evo]

I'd be surprised if they don't make an example of him among all the concussion talk in the media.

yeah, I fear the worst.

 

[foleyisagun]

Upon first seeing it at the game, didn't really think there was much in it. To be perfectly honest, thought he ironed him out beautifully. However, the replay indicates that it was a fair bit higher than I thought, so seeing how the MRP has been treating incidents like these lately it doesn't look too good, maybe 2-4 weeks?

On a similar note, I loved Batchelor's (i think) bump on Ray later in the game. Having a rough start to the season is Farren.

 

[CAS79]

crude but high. nothing in the rules about leaving the ground either. player ok to take the kick, not concused so maybe 1-2wks depending on the carryover points.

There might be nothing in the rules about leaving the ground but we know it's certainly taken into interpretation when considering intent by the MRP.

 

[Copulator]

I give him 2 weeks, tops.

 

[tquinn]

mcguane - 3 weeks, can be downgraded to 2.

cyril rioli given 2 weeks, cannot get a deduction given prior points

 

[Leg End]

I'll say 2-3 weeks, pretty low impact, the fact Ray got up and kicked the goal will be in his favour

Agreed. Bit like Barry Hall's lovetap to Faker - should have been reprimand at worst.

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

mcguane - 3 weeks, can be downgraded to 2.

cyril rioli given 2 weeks, cannot get a deduction given prior points

McGuane's penalty seems reasonable imo