Opinion Nahas? Thoughts?

[nut]

I think we should trade him to any club that wants him and he wants to go too.... Like saints ... for pick 112. No use trying to squeeze out "great" deal for a player who is most likely going to get delisted.

 

[TJTIGER]

I think we should trade him to any club that wants him and he wants to go too.... Like saints ... for pick 112. No use trying to squeeze out "great" deal for a player who is most likely going to get delisted.

Maybe we're holding out to use him as a little extra (like cherry on top) in a trade or upgrade. To get something over the line ? Seems like we are playing things pretty close to our chests. Which I quite like, I know Robbie may not be highly valued ? But you just never know.......

 

[DustinsGuns]

I wouldn't be surprised if we keep him

So far Tuck, White & McGuane are gone. If Newman goes to the Veteran's list that means we have 4 senior spots.

National Draft:
Pick 12 - 18 yeard old
Pick 50 odd - 18 year old
Pick 70 odd - Ricky Petterd upgrade

PSD:
Pick 12 odd - Matt Thomas.

Considering our low draft picks I wouldn't be surprised. I guess if we get compensation for White & McGuane it might change.

 

[nut]

I wouldn't be surprised if we keep him

So far Tuck, White & McGuane are gone. If Newman goes to the Veteran's list that means we have 4 senior spots.

National Draft:
Pick 12 - 18 yeard old
Pick 50 odd - 18 year old
Pick 70 odd - Ricky Petterd upgrade

PSD:
Pick 12 odd - Matt Thomas.

Considering our low draft picks I wouldn't be surprised. I guess if we get compensation for White & McGuane it might change.

Yer we will get a compo pick inbetween pick 12 and 50 for Mcguane and White.

I wouldn't think Nahas will survive .... and I doubt we can upgrade our pick 50 with him.

 

[NUFC Tiger]

Would try and shop him around but if not, wouldn't object to him being on the rookie list for a season given the draft is supposed to be shallow and Nahas has shown he can play a bit at AFL level (unlike someone like Relton Roberts)

 

[deliberate!!]

 

[cairo tiger]

I wouldn't be surprised if we keep him

So far Tuck, White & McGuane are gone. If Newman goes to the Veteran's list that means we have 4 senior spots.

National Draft:
Pick 12 - 18 yeard old
Pick 50 odd - 18 year old
Pick 70 odd - Ricky Petterd upgrade

PSD:
Pick 12 odd - Matt Thomas.

Considering our low draft picks I wouldn't be surprised. I guess if we get compensation for White & McGuane it might change.

I would throw petterd but like the rest.

nahas has to go.

 

[Truetiger]

Has he been delisted yet lol

 

[richerjames]

He will stay with white gone.

 

[tigerz18]

if out of contract will not be offered a new one.
if in contract will stay for 1 year and pull a Jordan McMahon, unless another team is stupid enough to trade for him. he has ZERO currency.

 

[fake tyrone]

Had a few good seasons and was my favourite player but season 2013 was one to forget. I read on another board that he was unhappy at the Tigers and if that is the case then we won't get the best out of him and should probably go.

White leaving for Port Adelaide has put him in an interesting position.

 

[Riskingheadandshin]

Andy Krakour or Nahas?

Sent from my GT-N7105 using Tapatalk 2

Neither.

 

[Riskingheadandshin]

He will stay with white gone.

Why? White barely got a game and Nahas didn't.

 

[fumbler]

Nahas to be a VFL senior player

 

[THE_GUN]

I wouldn't be surprised if we keep him

So far Tuck, White & McGuane are gone. If Newman goes to the Veteran's list that means we have 4 senior spots.

National Draft:
Pick 12 - 18 yeard old
Pick 50 odd - 18 year old
Pick 70 odd - Ricky Petterd upgrade

PSD:
Pick 12 odd - Matt Thomas.

Considering our low draft picks I wouldn't be surprised. I guess if we get compensation for White & McGuane it might change.

Need to add Derickx & Nahas to that list so we will have 6 spots with 1 taken by Hampson leaving us with 5 to fill
I think we will only take 3 in the Draft and 1 Psd selection

Wouldnt be suprised to see 1 more player traded in before the end of trade period, Hopefully Nahas to a club like Brisbane/Stkilda for maybe Karnezis or another youngster

 

[ScallyWag1]

Need to add Derickx & Nahas to that list so we will have 6 spots with 1 taken by Hampson leaving us with 5 to fill
I think we will only take 3 in the Draft and 1 Psd selection

Wouldnt be suprised to see 1 more player traded in before the end of trade period, Hopefully Nahas to a club like Brisbane/Stkilda for maybe Karnezis or another youngster

If we walked out of the trade period with Hampson and Karnezis, at the expense of White, McGuane and Nahas, AND managed to flip Derrickx for a late pick I'd be absolutely wrapped.

 

[Grechy]

Maybe we're holding out to use him as a little extra (like cherry on top) in a trade or upgrade. To get something over the line ? Seems like we are playing things pretty close to our chests. Which I quite like, I know Robbie may not be highly valued ? But you just never know.......

I don't think we're playing much close to our chest. I think we're done and dusted this trade period. I can't even see any rumour, interest or links to any player.

 

[richerjames]

Why? White barely got a game and Nahas didn't.

White was sub mate. Need a small fwd even for back up. He will stay.

 

[TJTIGER]

I don't think we're playing much close to our chest. I think we're done and dusted this trade period. I can't even see any rumour, interest or links to any player.

Long way to go yet Grechy......I'm not sure how many saw the big boy trade. I certainly didn't nor did I hear anything hinting at it. That's why I wrote, you just never know.....keeping a crack in the door....

 

[Riskingheadandshin]

White was sub mate. Need a small fwd even for back up. He will stay.

AFL site:
• There has been some interest in Robbie Nahas from West Coast, none from Carlton. It's early interest at this stage and they expect more enquiries over the next week or so.

Mate, he is gone one way or another.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Manager says Nahas feels he will have better opportunities elsewhere

 

[Frustrated Tiger]

Manager says Nahas feels he will have better opportunities elsewhere

So do most of us. ...

 

[RunningBounce]

Thanks for your contributions. The Brissy game was the one that broke the camels back.

Yep. I reckon he was playing for his AFL career in that game. I was a bit pissed, but I seem to remember him having a shot on goal and missing the lot. You could actually hear his career deflate.

Having said that, I'd rather see him play VFL at Punt Road than at Port Melbourne.

 

[Grechy]

Long way to go yet Grechy......I'm not sure how many saw the big boy trade. I certainly didn't nor did I hear anything hinting at it. That's why I wrote, you just never know.....keeping a crack in the door....

I hope you're right I'm rather bored this trade period.

 

[Grechy]

I wouldn't be surprised if we keep him

So far Tuck, White & McGuane are gone. If Newman goes to the Veteran's list that means we have 4 senior spots.

National Draft:
Pick 12 - 18 yeard old
Pick 50 odd - 18 year old
Pick 70 odd - Ricky Petterd upgrade

PSD:
Pick 12 odd - Matt Thomas.

Considering our low draft picks I wouldn't be surprised. I guess if we get compensation for White & McGuane it might change.

I would so much rather we take a punt on Maverick Weller then Matt Thomas with PSD 12.