Nominate the DUD of the decade!

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

I'd say it should be a first round draft pick, he should have stayed on the list for 4-5 years and hovered around the 30-50 game mark. Plenty of nominees from the first round of the 2000 draft with Luke Livingston, McDougall, Dylan Smith, Angwin, Trent Sporn and James Davies (did he get to ten games). Factor in battlers like Pettifer and Wiggins, punchlines like McMahon and blokes who just don't seem to give a s**t like Motlop and it's a pretty awesome first round collection.
 
I'd say it should be a first round draft pick, he should have stayed on the list for 4-5 years and hovered around the 30-50 game mark. Plenty of nominees from the first round of the 2000 draft with Luke Livingston, McDougall, Dylan Smith, Angwin, Trent Sporn and James Davies (did he get to ten games). Factor in battlers like Pettifer and Wiggins, punchlines like McMahon and blokes who just don't seem to give a s**t like Motlop and it's a pretty awesome first round collection.

Of all the years to have 3 1st round picks. :thumbsdown:
 
I bet you were saying that when he put it down Cousins gullet in the 05' Grand Final ;)

And my reasoning is not defensive, it's true! I'd take Kosi, hell I'd take Tambling over Luke Ablett.

Just looking back at the 2000 Draft list, you guys could have had Alan Didak, Shaun Burgoyne or Daniel Kerr. Having 1 of those 3 players, could have been the difference between, the Saints winning and losing last year's premiership mate. ;)
 
Just looking back at the 2000 Draft list, you guys could have had Alan Didak, Shaun Burgoyne or Daniel Kerr. Having 1 of those 3 players, could have been the difference between, the Saints winning and losing last year's premiership mate. ;)

Why? We've got an elite midfield. I'd much rather take a punt on a Key Position player. They're getting rarer and rarer these days.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Why? We've got an elite midfield. I'd much rather take a punt on a Key Position player. They're getting rarer and rarer these days.

Alan Didak plays Half-Forward, most times, if he's not in the Midfield, doesn't he? He could have played both for St.Kilda and is far more consistent than Adam Schneider in my opinion.
 
Nominate the DUD of the decade! Must have played at least 10 AFL games to be qualified!
I'll go with JON.

Why should it be a minimum 10 games - plenty of top 10 picks have played less than 5 - surely that is dudness by definition.
 
This season: Richard Tambling.

I have never been a hater and I am not say this just because he was a high draft pick and expectations. Richmond football club have worse player e.g. POLAK.

But we have been in the first 10 rounds the worst team in the competition. He has been in our worst 6 players nearly everyone of our games this season. And he only ever gets dropped if he has an injury concern. Comes straight back in once his niggle is over.

Really pisses me off. Is not being made to work for his spot. Not his fault hes the dud/spud of the season, its partly the clubs fault.

I guess you know more about what he is being asked to do than Hardwick.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Nominate the DUD of the decade!

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top