Nominate the DUD of the decade!

[HardBoydGet]

Barry Brooks was one of St.Kilda's worst, dunno if he got 10 games though.

In the ilk of Daniel Wulf

 

[peejay]

Edit - need to have played at least *1* AFL game

Danny Roach - Pick 7 , i game no kicks, handballs, marks or frees - one tackle.

 

[i_need_a_pencil]

Kent Kingsley.... I used to laugh everytime he would mark the ball inside the 50, good times

 

[Sausage roll]

Guys, this is a no-brainer.

Jarryd Oakleigh-Nichols...by a mile.

This was a no 8 draft pick who actually had no idea what to do on a football field. It was quite extraordinary.

To think some still thikn Greg miller is a "good football person"- he chose JON. The guy has no judgement( doesn't he stil work for flying start?) and has dined out on Wayne Carey for years. A disgrace.

 

[Dangas]

simon phillips

 

[HardBoydGet]

Our Midfield > Your Midfield.

Also, I can randomly spit out Bulldogs players myself and it still won't be funny. You want a spud? Will Minson.

Yep. Your midfield's great. Especially with the NOMINATED Brett Peake. Geelong must be shitting themselves

 

[Subaru Impreza]

some players to randomly come across my mind:

Travis Cloke
Daniel Parker (played for Freo in the late 90's)
Ty Zantuck (Rich and Essendon)

 

[THE D]

Ezra Poyas

Still loved his VFL work though!

Que Phil Cleary voice: "Poyas kicks it right down the throat of big Nick Sautner. Gee he's so classy isn't he? His kicks are like works of art"

 

[PHX]

Was Daniel McAlister would partly qualify as he was still dudding it up in the early 2000s.

 

[Wokko]

Richie Cole

Even with a 6th in the Pies B&F, was a total dud.

 

[chrismcgrath]

Why? We've got an elite midfield. I'd much rather take a punt on a Key Position player. They're getting rarer and rarer these days.

So are kozzies kicks!

 

[Murraj1966]

So are kozzies kicks!

So are Sydney's wins.

Oh and Will Minson.

 

[Mr Magoo]

Fergus Watts ~ number 1 draft pick..

 

[AG]

Fergus Watts ~ number 1 draft pick..

No he wasn't.

He has struggled with injuries since school football.

 

[chrismcgrath]

So are Sydney's wins.

Oh and Will Minson.

So are your premierships!!

 

[Invigoration]

Brock McLean
/thread

 

[AG]

Brock McLean
/thread

[TG]Watch some football[/TG]

 

[CharlieMortdecai]

Shannon Watt.

Nice guy apparently, but DUD!

Holds the record for most games played without a brownlow vote, but could be pipped by Jason Blake this year.

Hate to say it, but North has 5 of the top 10 in that list. (Although Freeborn and Power played elsewhere, and I reckon Firrito will get at least one this year). Then again, just shows how much the maggots hate us.

 

[Murraj1966]

So are your premierships!!

72 years.

 

[CharlieMortdecai]

72 years.

No, they won in 2005. So it's only been 5 years since the last swans premiership. Lot of teams have waited longer than that.

But you knew that already.

 

[TheGoatBaron]

72 years.

Took 69 years to win your first and lucky premiership mate, so you cannot talk and St.Kilda was an after-thought in joining the league, the VFL back then asked Port Melbourne and Williamstown to join the VFL before St.Kilda.

No, they won in 2005. So it's only been 5 years since the last swans premiership. Lot of teams have waited longer than that.

But you knew that already.

lol I think he is referring to our long drought mate, but appreciate the effort though.

 

[Swanny36]

72 years.

lol, FAIL! Sydney >>>> Aints.

My nomination for DUD of the Decade goes to *Drum Roll*

Guy Richards, NFI how he got TEN F****N YEARS ON OUR LIST!
Absolute joke to keep renewing his contracts.

 

[jackster83]

Darren Pfeiffer was pretty terrible. First round pick, pissed about off the field, got delisted 3 times and played a handful of mostly shit games.

 

[pickman]

Alastair Nicholson, Simon Godfrey.......................but seriously A. Rocca!

Agree with Anthony Rocca, worst 200 game player ever

 

[Big Blow Hard]

Does Daniel McAllister qualif?. Drafted in about 97, finished in 02 I think. Top 10 pick, 6 games or so. Delisted, then unfathomably redrafted by Sheedy at about pick 64. Lasted another season.