Mega Thread Non-Freo AFL Discussion 2024 Part 2

[Docker82]

Exactly what I was alluding too.

Barrass - pretty good, but form has been patchy (disinterested, you may be right).

McGovern - has been very good, but can his body keep it up ?.

Centre = hit and miss.

Forward spine, (two) is ok, but needs strong reinforcement.

Overall, where is the next crop of reinforcements ?.

I’ve heard Noah Long is the next Zak Butters and that Jack Williams is the next Tom Hawkins…

In all seriousness I think Ginbey and Hewitt will go alright and Hough is the sort of medium defender you barely notice (in a good way). Outside of Reid, I haven’t seen too much to be excited about from their other youngsters tbh. Just a bunch of role players at best.

 

[Raz]

do you yell out, "come on number 9"? lol

sometiomes lol

but as i only watch on TV the commentors let me know who is who

i remember the good old days buying the RECORD at games to know whos who and even writng scores in there lol

 

[FreoGirl]

sometiomes lol

but as i only watch on TV the commentors let me know who is who

i remember the good old days buying the RECORD at games to know whos who and even writng scores in there lol

the old guy next to me still does that - I've tried to show him how he can just look it up on his phone

 

[Raz]

the old guy next to me still does that - I've tried to show him how he can just look it up on his phone

nahh. i never use phone if i watching .

i just watch and enjoy. but i do realise many do use phones

 

[Clemen]

I saw someone else post this from a Twitter/X post; genuinely thought it was a wind up or a "lol' thing. Surely it's not a serious consideration...?!?!

To be fair, her previous coach while playing for the Diamonds, Lisa Alexander, applied for the Roos coaching job Caitlin probably got the idea of a high performance coach switching codes.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Vintage]

It’s worked before

 

[thistimeforsure]

Didn't mind Razor as an umpire.

He and David Rodan seem to be the only umpires that show their personality.

I suspect the rest are actually robot clones produced in an AFL secret lab!

C’mon Margetts showed his personality…. it’s just that he had the personality of a f***ing arrogant cheating dickhead


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[dont bowl there]

I’ve heard Noah Long is the next Zak Butters and that Jack Williams is the next Tom Hawkins…

In all seriousness I think Ginbey and Hewitt will go alright and Hough is the sort of medium defender you barely notice (in a good way). Outside of Reid, I haven’t seen too much to be excited about from their other youngsters tbh. Just a bunch of role players at best.

IMO Ginbey is also in the role player at best category. It's ****ing dire for the Eagles, their best prospect outside of Reid is Hewitt who has had serious foot issues this early. If he can get fit he's A-grade potential but then I don't see any of their other young players getting close to that.

 

[Lach72]

IMO Ginbey is also in the role player at best category. It's ****ing dire for the Eagles, their best prospect outside of Reid is Hewitt who has had serious foot issues this early. If he can get fit he's A-grade potential but then I don't see any of their other young players getting close to that.

Noah Long is a great little player, kinda a faster Baker type. Ginbey cannot kick that well, so that limits him.

hewett is good enough, that’s certain imo. Depends whether his body holds up. Missing a whole year to a foot isn’t great.

 

[arsesmart]

always a little surpsised how much time Fremantle fans spend discussing other teams especially the Eagles

I guess those who do are big time AFL fans and love the sport and know it well

ME . i dont even know all the names on the Fremantle list

But hey go Freo !

I can't stand to watch the WC play, even in Derbys. I have an inherent aversion to their colours.

There is so much hype around them over here though, you still get incidental exposure to them even if actively trying to avoid it.

But yes, agree, discussing them on here is a no go for me

 

[holybishop]

 

[Quazar2]

How much is Barrass on..?! Wasn't it Sydney that allegedly were interesting or maybe even in negotiations with management of his last off-season..?!?! I can conceivably see a world where Barrass asks for a trade or they offer him out, I wonder if Sydney would like to add him to their defense stocks, especially if they CAN'T win a Granny this year....?!

Hmmmmm.......

 

[dont bowl there]

always a little surpsised how much time Fremantle fans spend discussing other teams especially the Eagles

I guess those who do are big time AFL fans and love the sport and know it well

ME . i dont even know all the names on the Fremantle list

But hey go Freo !

They are our biggest and only real rival, it makes sense that fans talk about them and hope more than any other club that they fail.

 

[FreoGirl]

wow, has this ever happened before?

'He missed the mark': Giants star reprimanded for MRO criticism

The AFL has reprimanded Giants midfielder Tom Green for criticism of the MRO and Tribunal

www.afl.com.au

 

[Purple Suit]

wow, has this ever happened before?

'He missed the mark': Giants star reprimanded for MRO criticism

The AFL has reprimanded Giants midfielder Tom Green for criticism of the MRO and Tribunal

www.afl.com.au

Tom Green? Are they sure it wasn't Toby?

 

[Nothing]

Tom Green? Are they sure it wasn't Toby?

Read the headline, thought Toby.

Would never have known it wasn't if you didn't bring Tom to my attention.

 

[greatgatsby]

Read the headline, thought Toby.

Would never have known it wasn't if you didn't bring Tom to my attention.

Toby would never criticise the Tribunal, he enjoys the pleasure of their company several times a year.

The AFL really is Orwellian at times. Tom's comments were similar to those made recently by a number of knowledgeable observers of the game. He didn't accuse them of corruption or wrongdoing, merely muddle-headedness.

 

[Hamann188]

Toby would never criticise the Tribunal, he enjoys the pleasure of their company several times a year.

The AFL really is Orwellian at times. Tom's comments were similar to those made recently by a number of knowledgeable observers of the game. He didn't accuse them of corruption or wrongdoing, merely muddle-headedness.

Yeah I thought the same thing too, I mean I can read between the lines and guess what he probably wanted to say, but he chose his words wisely and the AFL was straight onto him.

It really does feel like they are sending a "just shut up and smile" message out there to the players and coaches, and don't you even dare consider bring any decisions made by the rule makers and adjudicators into question.

 

[oldgoat]

Langer will bring Elite honesty to an organisation clearly lacking any of it.

That wont work then will it.

 

[FreoGirl]

Even Hinkley doesn't want them lol

'I am coaching Port': Power the focus as Hinkley dismisses Eagles talk

Ken Hinkley insists he remains focused on leading Port Adelaide to a premiership, dismissing speculation linking him to West Coast

www.afl.com.au

 

[FreoGirl]

also Fagan and Clarkson will face the tribunal this Friday on racism claims - will this have any impact on Brisbane?

 

[anchor man]

That wont work then will it.

I am sure it will.

 

[DeanS]

but as i only watch on TV the commentors let me know who is who

Don't bet on it.

 

[Hamann188]

Even Hinkley doesn't want them lol

'I am coaching Port': Power the focus as Hinkley dismisses Eagles talk

Ken Hinkley insists he remains focused on leading Port Adelaide to a premiership, dismissing speculation linking him to West Coast

www.afl.com.au

Quick! Everybody to the Eagles "Coach for 25" board!

This is going to be hilarious.

 

[Hamann188]

also Fagan and Clarkson will face the tribunal this Friday on racism claims - will this have any impact on Brisbane?

I thought I'd read that they weren't going tor be be named in the report, it was just going to be Hawthorn FC.