Mega Thread Non-Freo AFL Discussion 2024 Part 2

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

St Kilda haven't actually been that bad this year, they've just done a reverse Port by losing the close ones. Lost 6 games by under 2 goals, whilst winning only 3. Hopefully they can catch the lions by surprise at Marvel.
 
I tipped them for bottom four before the season started. I’m going to be wrong there but the reason I did so was I thought they had a bottom four list - I underestimated Brad Scott as a coach IMO but still think I’m right about their list.
I think you're right. Minimal top end. It's really just Merrett and 1/10 games Stringer actually tries in. So many beige 100 game journeymen that keep them competitive but are zero chance of winning anything.

They really need to rebuild properly.
watch it be their 1/5 they show up for

It's fine as long as we show up too.
 
Useless GC. I had to turn the match off it was so infuriating watching them butcher so many forward entries and shots. With a sprinkle of dodgy pro-Brisbane umpiring to go with it. I bet GC lose away to WC and Richmond and finish below the Pies.
 
I tipped them for bottom four before the season started. I’m going to be wrong there but the reason I did so was I thought they had a bottom four list - I underestimated Brad Scott as a coach IMO but still think I’m right about their list.

Their percentage is bottom 4 and I think tells a true story. I would say you got it pretty close.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Brisbane will probably make another GF or at least get pretty close. Not too sure why people expected a different result.
Yeah not saying the Lions aren't good but given their outs the Suns shouldn't have been blown away.

Just poor. Their players aren't right between the ears.
 
Yeah not saying the Lions aren't good but given their outs the Suns shouldn't have been blown away.

Just poor. Their players aren't right between the ears.
Suns and Bombers both have massive demons between ears.

It will be interesting to see how long/if Dimma has what it takes to get an interstate side going. I reckon he might have underestimated the job he took between the travel and the culture of failure.
 
Yeah not saying the Lions aren't good but given their outs the Suns shouldn't have been blown away.

Just poor. Their players aren't right between the ears.
The silver spoon doesn't help them when the going gets tough.

Agree it's mainly mental. Everything they've achieved (i.e. not much) has been gift wrapped and they still aren't as good as teams that are fully at the mercy of the draft system.
 
Everyone talks about booting Norf from the comp, Melbourne's lack of crowds is a disgrace.

Unbelievable the lack of scrutiny that club gets.
Most Victorian clubs are pathetic in that regard when playing non-Victorian opposition tbh.

It's almost like they think their team has a bye unless playing a team from the same city. If any non-Victorian teams' supporters had the same attitude they'd fold within a season yet Victorian fans some the nerve to call Freo and Port "minnows" when they average 40+ thousand at each game and have one home derby all year. Absolute hypocrites.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Mega Thread Non-Freo AFL Discussion 2024 Part 2

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top