![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/western_sydney.png)
- Apr 12, 2012
- 47,696
- 44,650
- AFL Club
- GWS
- Thread starter
- #2,001
Arm was free? So no harm no foul yeah or no?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Arm was free? So no harm no foul yeah or no?
That was one aspect of Laura Kane's drivel that I hated. Healy was trying to compare the umpire's decision at the time to the MRO decision, but she's like 'oh, well, the umpires do a good job, but the MRO gets to pore over multiple camera angles". And while umps do miss things (GWS fans know that!), if a good vs bad tackle can't be adjudicated by an ump, then the rules are crap.No idea.![]()
![]()
Gee. I wonder what the call would been if Caldwell was concussed?![]()
MATCH REVIEW: Trio cleared after Crows' tough win over Bombers
The Match Review findings from Friday night's round 19 game are inwww.afl.com.au
BEN KEAYS, Nate Caddy and Matt Guelfi have avoided suspensions after the Match Review Officer looked at their three incidents in Adelaide's win over Essendon on Friday night.
Keays (for a tackle on Jye Caldwell), Caddy (for a collision with Jordan Dawson) and Guelfi (for a tackle on Sam Berry) were cleared for incidents in the Crows' stunning victory.
The MRO said Keays "exercised his duty of care" in executing his tackle on Caldwell, whose head hit the ground.
Caldwell was substituted as he underwent a head injury assessment before being cleared of concussion.
Caldwell been playing really well. Looks a ripper. I know we didn't get to keep him, but another tick to CarussoIt will be interesting what happens with the Ben Keays tackle on Jye Caldwell. Jye had an arm free, and was still concussed (which demonstrates that releasing an arm isn't the holy grail of protecting a player), so did Keays meet his duty of care or not? Let's see what the MRO does.
I will go out on a limb and say minimum 3 weeks.Gee. I wonder what the call would been if Caldwell was concussed?
50/50Who would we rather see win between the Cats and the Dogs?
DrawWho would we rather see win between the Cats and the Dogs?
Yes, conflicted about this match, as well as the Melbourne-Freo match tomorrow on who I want to win!50/50
Cats loss opens up the top 4.
Dogs loss keeps away pressure from the top 8, plus we hate them.
If either Brisbane or Fremantle lose we finish the round in the top 4.So if Sydney beat the lions we are in 4th?
Yeah that’s what I thought …. Sydney being more likely than Melbourne to winIf either Brisbane or Fremantle lose we finish the round in the top 4.
But they were saying Papley, Rampe and possibly Hayward are injured..good for us if Sydney wins as we are in competition with Brisbane for a possible top 4 spot, but Swans will get at least finish top 2 (and probably win the minor premiership)Sydney leading by 7 at 1/2 time.
They were trailing by 22 at 1/4 time.
Top 4 is what matters for us, unconcerned where South finish.But they were saying Papley, Rampe and possibly Hayward are injured..good for us if Sydney wins as we are in competition with Brisbane for a possible top 4 spot, but Swans will get at least finish top 2 (and probably win the minor premiership)
True..we have a 3-0 finals record against the SwansTop 4 is what matters for us, unconcerned where South finish.
They hold no fear for me at finals time.