List Mgmt. Our List 2014 - Trade, De-list and Draft - (keep it all in here)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Yes it does.

Adams wants to go to Collingwood, always has. But we had the upper hand of having an ok 25 yr old ruck man to send up there which would be perfect for GWS. The only options Collingwood had of trading was Shaw, but its yet to be confirmed if he wants to go to GWS or they even want him.

Now GWS have Mumford they would no longer be looking at trading with us. So we can kiss Adams goodbye.

edit: Can assure you Adams prefers Collingwood, but in the end wouldn't be unhappy if he ended up at Carlton.
It doesn't change anything if Adams stated he wanted to move to Carlton.

A first round pick would get it done. Don't underrate the players you can draft with picks 11 to 13. That's where the Giants secured Adams in a compromised draft that didn't have Cameron, Treloar, etc. in the draft.

You claim to have inside info, but until we've heard anything official, it's just conjecture.
 
Interesting that my cousin wants out there... he has turned into a very serviceable player taking more after his uncle than his dad.

It could be that Leppitsch is having a massive cull up there to get rid of some of Crazy Vossy's worst recruiting mistakes and some of the younger players are thinking that they might be in the firing line and are jumping ship.
Dram are you related to the Polkinghornes from Hawthorn?
 
What would Jaksch cost? Betts compo pick and an experienced player?
He was pick #13 last year and played about 2 games
I'd say Bett's compo (if it was considered band 1 therefore - pick #13 ) - would be enough surely, hell he's more likely decreased in value due to no games and so many other forwards ahead.
 
He was pick #13 last year and played about 2 games
I'd say Bett's compo (if it was considered band 1 therefore - pick #13 ) - would be enough surely, hell he's more likely decreased in value due to no games and so many other forwards ahead.
no way he's worth just a second rounder. if we wanted to keep our first pick i'd start with a good player plus maybe a second rounder to begin with.

now that GWS have secured Mumford I don't see what they'd really like from us.
 
no way he's worth just a second rounder. if we wanted to keep our first pick i'd start with a good player plus maybe a second rounder to begin with.

now that GWS have secured Mumford I don't see what they'd really like from us.

May have to trade our first rounder jacksch

Though, the hawks could make a play for him.

They need a new breed of Key Positions player
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I can confirm that this person is a friggin' idiot. Worst wannabe going around.
She tweeted saying Shuey and Viney went to the same school, when Shuey was from Macellin College and Viney went to Carey Grammar, and when I corrected her she blamed that she got it straight from the radio. Absolute flog, doesn't even get her facts straight, cannot believe a word that comes from this tweeter.
 
no way he's worth just a second rounder. if we wanted to keep our first pick i'd start with a good player plus maybe a second rounder to begin with.

now that GWS have secured Mumford I don't see what they'd really like from us.

I would go for Laidler and Duigan plus our second round pick for Jaksch as a starter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top