Coach Our Next Coach

[Butters Made Me Do It]

Nah I don't want another dumbass head coach relying on assistants for tactical nous

Yeah we don’t need another ‘great communicator’ which seems to mean he lets the boys do whatever the **** they want

 

[TeeKray]

Yeah we don’t need another ‘great communicator’ which seems to mean he lets the boys do whatever the fu** they want

Hinkley isn't a great communicator, he's a poor communicator. In fact, it's his biggest weakness right alongside his low standards.

 

[Magus]

I don't like the 'assistant from a successful club' route. That's what landed us with Hinkley. A lot of those guys are just in the right place at the right time. But pretty much every club hires from that pool which means every premiership coach ends up coming from that pool which reinforces the philosophy.

I think more than anything it should be a personality type you are looking for. You want someone who is ruthless and promotes high standards but is also a great communicator and has natural empathy for the players he is coaching. After that, you look for the more technical aspects from your assistants.

Bomber Thompson assistants were all duds but those under Clarkson have worked out more often that not.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

I don't like the 'assistant from a successful club' route. That's what landed us with Hinkley. A lot of those guys are just in the right place at the right time. But pretty much every club hires from that pool which means every premiership coach ends up coming from that pool which reinforces the philosophy.

I think more than anything it should be a personality type you are looking for. You want someone who is ruthless and promotes high standards but is also a great communicator and has natural empathy for the players he is coaching. After that, you look for the more technical aspects from your assistants.

You'll notice I didn't nominate anyone from Richmond or Geelong.

Richmond play a specific style that they have adapted a list to beautifully. But it took a long time and may not be readily transferable.

Geelong are a bit different again and get a huge advantage from their home ground. They recruit well but now fail in finals. I'm not sure their physical approach is as relevant to modern football as it could be.

West Coast, Collingwood and Hawthorn have a style that is transferable and sustainable. That's what I want us to establish. That is Port Adelaide football.

 

[TeeKray]

You'll notice I didn't nominate anyone from Richmond or Geelong.

Richmond play a specific style that they have adapted a list to beautifully. But it took a long time and may not be readily transferable.

Geelong are a bit different again and get a huge advantage from their home ground. They recruit well but now fail in finals. I'm not sure their physical approach is as relevant to modern football as it could be.

West Coast, Collingwood and Hawthorn have a style that is transferable and sustainable. That's what I want us to establish. That is Port Adelaide football.

Fair enough.

I guess I probably see us as coming from a bit further back than others. I think we're further away than just an astute tactical mastermind. I think the whole culture and standards of the club have been allowed to degenerate since 2004 to the point where we need someone who will totally flip the place on its head culturally ala what Clarkson did when he got to Hawthorn or Roos did when he got to Sydney.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Fair enough.

I guess I probably see us as coming from a bit further back than others. I think we're further away than just an astute tactical mastermind. I think the whole culture and standards of the club have been allowed to degenerate since 2004 to the point where we need someone who will totally flip the place on its head culturally ala what Clarkson did when he got to Hawthorn or Roos did when he got to Sydney.

And that is all true. But I didnt say anything about a tactical mastermind. I want the best applicant from a team that plays, if not exactly a bulletproof style, one that is strong, consistent and successful.

Within that framework of course exists the need for a robust and supportive culture and successful standards to be adhered to.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Hinkley was the right coach at the time when we first signed him.

However when GC came calling after the finals loss, that was a monumental **** up on our part.

 

[DazalenkoUBewty]

Hinkley isn't a great communicator, he's a poor communicator. In fact, it's his biggest weakness right alongside his low standards.

But truthfully, he's a very good communicator and he holds very high standards.

 

[Relativity]

Our club has FA smarts about coaching contracts. How we could not learn from the Chocko "mid season renewal clause" debacle to shitting the bed over a mid contract offer on Hinkley from GC is indicative of the gormless management of our club.

 

[AFC AFeederClub]

which Ken will you choose, every Ken has good points and bad points, you decide

Ken Cunningham
Kenny Rogers
Kenny G
Ken Norton
Ken Rosewall
Kenny Everitt
Ken Jeong
Ken Wyatt
Ken Sutcliffe
Ken Hinkley
Ken, the doll
Ken Judge
Ken Duncan
Ken Oath

 

[Grave Danger]

which Ken will you choose, every Ken has good points and bad points, you decide

Ken Cunningham
Kenny Rogers
Kenny G
Ken Norton
Ken Rosewall
Kenny Everitt
Ken Jeong
Ken Wyatt
Ken Sutcliffe
Ken Hinkley
Ken, the doll
Ken Judge
Ken Duncan
Ken Oath

 

[Zakk Wylde]

But truthfully, he's a very good communicator and he holds very high standards.

There's no doubt the players love him, and there's proof of that. He's also a fantastic salesman.

But his standards are a disgrace.

 

[Steve Dore]

which Ken will you choose, every Ken has good points and bad points, you decide

Ken Cunningham
Kenny Rogers
Kenny G
Ken Norton
Ken Rosewall
Kenny Everitt
Ken Jeong
Ken Wyatt
Ken Sutcliffe
Ken Hinkley
Ken, the doll
Ken Judge
Ken Duncan
Ken Oath

Kenny Everett



Even dead for 25 years he couldn't do a worse job than the incumbent.

 

[VineValerian]

which Ken will you choose, every Ken has good points and bad points, you decide

Ken Cunningham
Kenny Rogers
Kenny G
Ken Norton
Ken Rosewall
Kenny Everitt
Ken Jeong
Ken Wyatt
Ken Sutcliffe
Ken Hinkley
Ken, the doll
Ken Judge
Ken Duncan
Ken Oath

Ken Tucky….…….

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

Our club has FA smarts about coaching contracts. How we could not learn from the Chocko "mid season renewal clause" debacle to shitting the bed over a mid contract offer on Hinkley from GC is indicative of the gormless management of our club.

corporate amnesia.

none of the 2009 board members, ceo or football ops manger, were around in 2017.

we fans were there in 2009 and still were there in 2017, when the current mob made the rubbish 2 year extension with the 3rd year if you make the finals condition.

 

[Marmozet]

 

[Papa G]

View attachment 830503

WTF is that?

 

[Doctor Feel]

WTF is that?

I believe it is the same picture of brad scott posted every day.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

How a fly sees Brad Scott. Terrifying!

 

[AwwThatsApples]

It's not going to be Buckley

 

[Us against the rest]

I feel sick, Scott are you serious, Bucks before Scott.

 

[El_Scorcho]

I'd swap him for Buckley in a heartbeat. There is a lot going on at Collingwood that's out of Buckley's hands.

 

[Launchpad McQuack]

I'd swap him for Buckley in a heartbeat. There is a lot going on at Collingwood that's out of Buckley's hands.

Also that after 8.5 years it's clear a Hinkley-coached Port just doesn't have it.

 

[Schulzenfest]

More like Nathan Suckley

 

[Powertron]

More like Nathan Suckley

Sharp!