Coach Our Next Coach

[all seeing eye]

Id be happy with Carr, if Bucks has some sort of senior mentor overseer role, otherwise Buckley for coach if that wasnt workable.

 

[TazD]

I'll never understand the Bucks love.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

If Tredrea endorses Carr, then so do I

 

[gbear]

I'll never understand the Bucks love.

Either do I really, but hey if it ain’t Hinkley I can at least return to watching port play live again.

 

[JUSTWORK]

I'll never understand the Bucks love.

He was a 50/50 free kick away from being a premiership coach.

 

[gbear]

View attachment 2029318

Funny he was rollled out today. Powers at be trying to placate the members. TBH it just shows how much Carr’s wagon is hitched to Hinkley!

 

[ibd77]

I'll never understand the Bucks love.

I guess there are a few points.

1. Ex Port player, won a Magarey, BF and a premiership.
2. Completely removed from the current board and footy department.
3. Not afraid to stamp his authority on the club he is invested in.
4. Hungry to win a flag.
5. Had time to reflect on his short comings at Collingwood.
6. Still has connections in Victoria which could help.

 

[DaTBird187]

As much as I’d like a completely new coaching structure as ours is puss

Deep down I know it’ll be something like

Coach: carr
Senior assistant: Chad
forward: westhoff
Mids: Hartlett
Def: Goldsack
Magpies: p stew

 

[DaTBird187]

“Be careful what you wish for. The grass isn’t often greener on the other side”

Kane Cornes on SEN this morning

"Kane Cornes go **** yourself"

Me on Big Footy just now.

 

[JUSTWORK]

I guess there are a few points.

1. Ex Port player, won a Magarey, BF and a premiership.
2. Completely removed from the current board and footy department.
3. Not afraid to stamp his authority on the club he is invested in.
4. Hungry to win a flag.
5. Had time to reflect on his short comings at Collingwood.
6. Still has connections in Victoria which could help.

7. One of the bigger names in football and would bring in some much needed attention and real interest to see us succeed
8. Think how Eddie will feel if Bucks finally gets that AFL flag with us.

 

[scotty13]

Would be top of my list to interview. Issue would be getting him out of Melbourne.

Surely for another crack at the top job he would move?

 

[elsler]

doubtful how much would he be making in his media roles a lot more than a coaches wage

 

[Windy Cindy]

7. One of the bigger names in football and would bring in some much needed attention and real interest to see us succeed
8. Think how Eddie will feel if Bucks finally gets that AFL flag with us.

And think of how Eddie will feel if he calls for us to wear the bars every week

 

[SonOfKek]

It won't be Bucks. As much as I would like it. They'll go with Carr or Stewie Dew.

 

[PowerBaz]

As #Malcom has always said you are better the second time around, it's hard to say what coming in somewhere fresh could do for him, there's no baggage, he's tactically astute it could work a lot better than some think.

Yeah I’m warming to it.

 

[JimmyBC]

It won't be Bucks. As much as I would like it. They'll go with Carr or Stewie Dew.

I think the 'succession' plan is shaky with Tredrea on the board.

 

[TeeKray]

doubtful how much would he be making in his media roles a lot more than a coaches wage

He'd be on ~$800k as senior coach at Port, doubt he's making that in the media.

 

[Shane_Mag]

I'll never understand the Bucks love.

I'm curious to see how he would go without Eddie McGuire breathing down his neck.

 

[Doctor Feel]

I think the 'succession' plan is shaky with Tredrea on the board.

Dunno about that. Id like to think as much as he likes carr, that it would still have to go through a proper process with some external influence.

 

[ploppy]

I don’t know how to get him. But the guy we need is John Longmire.

 

[JUSTWORK]

He'd be on ~$800k as senior coach at Port, doubt he's making that in the media.

You'd have to think he'd still have that burning desire to win a flag

 

[PJ Power]

I'm not a fan of Buckley's coaching, but I'll make the following observations:

1. He seems more re-engaged with our club than I expected, since he departed Collingwood and entered the media.
2. He hasn't denied links to coaching us.
3. Voss - although he hasn't achieved any more than Hinkley as a coach yet - is doing a much better job at Carlton than I expected, and he was a failure as a first-time coach.

 

[JimmyBC]

Buckley hasn't even poo pooed the Tasmania suggestion he's gettable if you wanna throw the bait out there I suspect, his Port history would have a pull for him I'd imagine.

I'm not 100% on board though we need to look at everyone, no one gave McRae the time of day two years ago.

 

[PeacefulWarrior]

Love Josh but Buckley is my man

Jagging him would bring some credibility back to the club.

Otherwise - has holly ransom got her level 4 coaching?

 

[PeacefulWarrior]

I don’t know how to get him. But the guy we need is John Longmire.

There is no one less gettable than him.
Less than zero chance