Phantom Brownlow

[Lewie_8]

I did this over a short period of time, so i know some people might not agree on all the votes, I've done up to round 5 so far and this is my Leaderboard, i will post each round in a seperate comment! This might help for those looking to do multis this year for each team.

Leaderboard (Round 5) - Top 10
Watson - 11
Pendlebury - 9
Murphy - 9
Judd - 9
Moloney - 8
Swan - 7
Mitchell - 7
Cox - 7
Bartel - 7

Alot of players just below on 6 votes!

 

[Lewie_8]

Round 1
Richmond vs Carlton
3 Murphy
2 Gibbs
1 J Riewoldt

Geelong vs St Kilda
3 Enright
2 Bartel
1 Hayes

Collingwood vs Port Adelaide
3 Johnson
2 Pendlebury
1 Swan

Adelaide vs Hawthorn
3 Dangerfield
2 Mitchell
1 Reilly

Fremantle vs Brisbane
3 Sandilands
2 Black
1 Pavlich

Essendon vs Western Bulldogs
3 Watson
2 Stanton
1 Ryder

Melbourne vs Sydney
3 Moloney
2 Okeefe
1 Mcglynn

West Coast vs North Melbourne
3 Cox
2 Priddis
1 Swallow

 

[Lewie_8]

Round 2
St Kilda vs Richmond
3 Deledio
2 Milne
1 Dal Santo

North Melbourne vs Collingwood
3 Pendlebury
2 Swan
1 Cloke

West Coast vs Port Adelaide
3 Embley
2 Shuey
1 Cox

Carlton vs Gold Coast
3 Judd
2 Gibbs
1 Murphy

Geelong vs Fremantle
3 Enright
2 Mundy
1 Ling

Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane
3 Griffen
2 Boyd
1 Higgins

Sydney vs Essendon
3 Bolton
2 Goodes
1 Watson

Hawthorn vs Melbourne
3 Suckilng
2 Mitchell
1 Rioli

 

[melbournemartin]

I recently looked back at the votes for the drawn Queens Birthday game last year. Moloney's best on ground 38 touches, 7 tackles and general midfield dominance wasn't enough to land him a single vote. I'm now skeptical about his ability to poll well at all, even though he has been BoG 3 times this year IMO.

 

[Danog]

Nahas could be on 7

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Isn't it bad enough we have to endure this farcical award at the end of the minor round? Do we have to read this crap in May as well?

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Watson and Embley will poll good at the start of the year, Pendles may suffer from the best team in the league syndrome where his team mates will take votes off him

 

[whats_at_stake]

After Watson criticised the substitute rule I doubt he will get many votes. Remember Hird's game after he criticised the umpires? 0 votes for the below effort.

[YOUTUBE]yx7898r_5j8[/YOUTUBE]

 

[melbournemartin]

After Watson criticised the substitute rule I doubt he will get many votes. Remember Hird's game after he criticised the umpires? 0 votes for the below effort.

[YOUTUBE]yx7898r_5j8[/YOUTUBE]

I had forgotten how good his game was.

 

[GameOver]

After Watson criticised the substitute rule I doubt he will get many votes. Remember Hird's game after he criticised the umpires? 0 votes for the below effort.

[YOUTUBE]yx7898r_5j8[/YOUTUBE]

Hird criticised the umpire's directly. Watson criticised the rule. Different creatures.

 

[Fevola99]

umpires probably hate the rule changes more than anybody

 

[Blue and Silver]

umpires probably hate the rule changes more than anybody

Got to agree with this. Despite popular belief you'd think the umpires would like less rules, especially ones not concerned with direct play. It makes their job harder

 

[Thermo]

After Watson criticised the substitute rule I doubt he will get many votes.

Why would the umpires give a shit if Watson doesn't like the sub rule? Take the tin foil hat off.

 

[Lewie_8]

I'll post up the rest of the votes, up until round 6 now. I think this could be a good source for who look to pick the leading poller from each team! Could be tough with teams like Gold Coast, Brisbane and Port which is why i will put a few tips in to help choose those.

Round 3
Collingwood vs Carlton
3 H Shaw
2 Swan
1 Judd

Western Bulldogs vs Gold Coast
3 Higgins
2 Cross
1 Boyd

Fremantle vs Adelaide
3 Fyfe
2 Thompson
1 Mundy

Hawthorn vs Richmond
3 Franklin
2 Lewis
1 Shiels

Sydney vs West Coast
3 Goodes
2 Everitt
1 Cox

Melbourne vs Brisbane
3 Moloney
2 Rockliff
1 Jurrah

Geelong vs Port
3 Selwood
2 Bartel
1 Kelly

Essendon vs St Kilda
3 Watson
2 Crameri
1 Ryder

 

[Lewie_8]

Round 4
Collingwood vs Richmond
3 Thomas
2 Swan
1 Pendlebury

Hawthorn vs West Coast
3 Mitchell
2 Franklin
1 Priddis

Essendon vs Carlton
3 Watson
2 Carrazzo
1 Stanton

Geelong vs Sydney
3 Chapman
2 Kennedy
1 Wojinscki

Port Adelaide vs Adelaide
3 Westhoff
2 Thompson
1 Boak

Melbourne vs Gold Coast
3 Trengove
2 Moloney
1 Sylvia

Fremantle vs North Melbourne
3 Fyfe
2 Ballantyne
1 A Swallow

 

[Lewie_8]

Round 5
St Kilda vs Brisbane
3 Schneider
2 Adcock
1 Montagna

Gold Coast vs Port Adelaide
3 Rischitelli
2 Matera
1 D Swallow

Carlton vs Adelaide
3 Murphy
2 Judd
1 Walker

Richmond vs North Melbourne
3 Martin
2 J Riewoldt
1 A Swallow

Collingwood vs Essendon
3 Pendlebury
2 Davis
1 Cloke

Fremantle vs Western Bulldogs
3 Mundy
2 Boyd
1 Sandilands

Geelong vs Hawthorn
3 Bartel
2 Chapman
1 Selwood

 

[Lewie_8]

Round 6
West Coast vs Melbourne
3 Priddis
2 Cox
1 Ebert

Carlton vs Sydney
3 Judd
2 Murphy
1 Mcglynn

North Melbourne vs Port Adelaide
3 Goldstein
2 Harvey
1 Wright

Richmond vs Brisbane
3 Nahas
2 Foley
1 Martin

Adelaide vs St Kilda
3 Tippett
2 Thompson
1 Dal Santo

Essendon vs Gold Coast
3 Reimers
2 Howlett
1 Watson

Collingwood vs Western Bulldogs
3 Sidebottom
2 Krakeour
1 Shaw

 

[Power King]

Hird criticised the umpire's directly. Watson criticised the rule. Different creatures.

Shouldn't make a difference.

Best on ground is best on ground.

Still have no idea why people give a **** about the Brownlow. It is a midfielder's award based on umpire's opinion. One of the most shameful things about the big footy public is the riding of umpire **** when it comes to an opinion on best and fairest.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Round 4
Essendon vs Carlton
3 Watson
2 Carrazzo
1 Stanton

Mate, you and I were watching completely different games that day.

 

[Lewie_8]

Mate, you and I were watching completely different games that day.

Yeah i have had another look at this game, new votes i have come up with are

3 Watson
2 Murphy
1 Judd

Let me know what you think though mate

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Head to the Stats board and the Brownlow thread. You will get much better discussion and more opinion there.

 

[DonMania#5]

Another 3 votes for Jobe today

 

[Sam The Doc]

Yeah i have had another look at this game, new votes i have come up with are

3 Watson
2 Murphy
1 Judd

Let me know what you think though mate

Yarran

 

[dont bowl there]

No chance Cox has even half the number of votes you have him on. Never polls well even in his AA years.

 

[Lewie_8]

No chance Cox has even half the number of votes you have him on. Never polls well even in his AA years.

I know what your saying, but in his dominant games this year, it's hard to pick anyone else to get votes, whereas in the years your talking about, your looking at names like Cousins, Judd, Fletcher and also Kerr being dominant