Pick 18 (22) players from Hawks, Cats and saints

[Pessimistic]

I am asking this because in my dreamteam, the fwd line is filling with hawks, the midfield with cats and the defence saints.

 

[In And Under Tiger]

B: Gilbert, Scarlett, Enright
HB: Hodge, S.Fisher, Goddard
C: Selwood, Mitchell, Montagna
HF: Rioli, Riewoldt, S.Johnson
F: Roughead, Franklin, Milne
R: Ottens, Dal Santo, Ablett
I: Corey, Kosi, Sewell, Bartel

 

[qldbluesman_43]

B: Gilbert, Scarlett, Enright
HB: Hodge, S.Fisher, Goddard
C: Selwood, Mitchell, Montagna
HF: Rioli, Riewoldt, S.Johnson
F: Roughead, Franklin, Milne
R: Ottens, Dal Santo, Ablett
I: Corey, Kosi, Sewell, Bartel

Milne, Gilbert and Kosi out and to replace them Chapman, Hudghton and back up ruckman .... Taylor I suppose.


Otherwise that would be about it for me.

 

[tim_saints]

i think this is a good thread i reckon i can make a best 22 and a reserves side it may be right may be wrong but im going on current form and overall form

FB: Enright (Geel) Scarlett (Geel) Croad (Haw)

HB: Goddard (Stk) Fisher (Stk) Hodge (Haw)

C: Dal Santo ( Stk) Ablett (Geel) Mitchell (Haw)

HF: Johnson (Geel) Riewoldt (Stk) Chapman (Geel)

FF: Roughead (Haw) Franklin (Haw) Rioli (Haw)

R: Ottens (Geel) Bartel (Geel) Selwood (Geel)

Int: Sewell (Haw) Hayes (Stk) Corey (Geel) Montanga (Stk)

EMG: Milburn (Stk) Ling (Stk) Lewis (Haw)


Reserves Side

FB: Gilbert (Stk) Hudgton (Stk) Gilham (Haw)

HB: Mackie (Geel) Harley (Geel) Birchall (Haw)

C: Kelly (Geel) Ball (Stk) Young (Haw)

HF: Williams (Haw) Hawkins (Geel) Scneider (Stk)

FF: Mooney (Geel) Koschitzke (Stk) Osbourne (Haw)

R: Gardiner (Stk) Wodjinski (Geel) Ray (Stk)

Int: Campbell (Haw) Gram (Stk) Brown (Haw) Hunt (Geel)

Emg: Varcoe (Geel) Milne (Stk) Ellis (Haw)

 

[Puddy]

that reserves side above would be a decent Top 8 side.

 

[DannyJ]

Campbell Brown would be in any side made up by these three sides. He brings an element of fear to the opposition.

 

[DanA]

FB: Enright (Geel) Scarlett (Geel) Fisher (Stk)
HB: Sewell (Haw) Roughead (Haw) (Stk) Hodge (Haw)
C: Montanga (Stk) Ablett (Geel) Dal Santo ( Stk)
HF: Chapman (Geel) Riewoldt (Stk) Goddard (Stk)
FF: Johnson (Geel) Franklin (Haw) Rioli (Haw)
R: Ottens (Haw) (Geel) Bartel (Geel) Selwood (Geel)
Int: Campbell (Haw) Ling (Stk) Mitchell (Haw) Bateman (Haw)

Bold are the unquestionable picks and apart from Ottens are probably 10 of the top 20 players in the AFL at the minute.


Reserves Side

FB: Gilbert (Stk) Hudgton (Stk) Milburn (Stk)
HB: Harley (Geel) Croad (Haw) Brown (Haw)
C: Mackie (Geel) Lewis (Haw) Ball (Stk)
HF: Stokes (Geelong) Mooney (Geel) Schneider (Stk)
FF: Milne (Stk) Koschitzke (Stk) Williams (Haw)
R: Blake (Geel) Hayes (St Kilda) Corey (Geel)
Int Gardiner (Stk) Kelly (Geel) Birchall (Haw) Osborne (Haw)

If I'm not mistaken over half this reserve team have been AA. I'd back them to be premiers despite the absence of a superstar.

 

[tim_saints]

Hayes very unlucky to not be in the best 22 i think he is very underated amongst the leagues players

 

[Falchoon]

Gilbert's in the AA team at present so he'd be a good show here.

 

[AFLOnline]

FB: Gilbert, Scarlett, Enright
HB: Hodge, Fisher, Goddard
C: Montagna, Mitchell, Dal Santo
HF: Rioli, Riewoldt, Johnson
FF: Bartel, Franklin, Milne
R: Ottens, Ablett, Hayes

INT: Sewell, Selwood, Roughead, Gardiner.

Meh, best I could do.

 

[rainman06]

Campbell Brown would be in any side made up by these three sides. He brings an element of fear to the opposition.

No, he doesnt. This is just a Hawthorn myth.

He is hard at it, but so are most players in the AFL, and opposition players would be far too concerned with their own application at the contest to worry about Campbell Brown being around rather than any other Hawthorn player.

 

[magic_johnson!]

i think this is a good thread i reckon i can make a best 22 and a reserves side it may be right may be wrong but im going on current form and overall form

FB: Enright (Geel) Scarlett (Geel) Croad (Haw)

HB: Goddard (Stk) Fisher (Stk) Hodge (Haw)

C: Dal Santo ( Stk) Ablett (Geel) Mitchell (Haw)

HF: Johnson (Geel) Riewoldt (Stk) Chapman (Geel)

FF: Roughead (Haw) Franklin (Haw) Rioli (Haw)

R: Ottens (Geel) Bartel (Geel) Selwood (Geel)

Int: Sewell (Haw) Hayes (Stk) Corey (Geel) Montanga (Stk)

EMG: Milburn (Stk) Ling (Stk) Lewis (Haw)

didn't realise milburn and ling don the black, red and white stripes?

 

[Pessimistic]

Can anyone justify why Chapman has Dews spot ?

PS I like Chapman bu fairs fair

 

[adii_7]

i think this is a good thread i reckon i can make a best 22 and a reserves side it may be right may be wrong but im going on current form and overall form

FB: Enright (Geel) Scarlett (Geel) Croad (Haw)

HB: Goddard (Stk) Fisher (Stk) Hodge (Haw)

C: Dal Santo ( Stk) Ablett (Geel) Mitchell (Haw)

HF: Johnson (Geel) Riewoldt (Stk) Chapman (Geel)

FF: Roughead (Haw) Franklin (Haw) Rioli (Haw)

R: Ottens (Geel) Bartel (Geel) Selwood (Geel)

Int: Sewell (Haw) Hayes (Stk) Corey (Geel) Montanga (Stk)

EMG: Milburn (Stk) Ling (Stk) Lewis (Haw)


Reserves Side

FB: Gilbert (Stk) Hudgton (Stk) Gilham (Haw)

HB: Mackie (Geel) Harley (Geel) Birchall (Haw)

C: Kelly (Geel) Ball (Stk) Young (Haw)

HF: Williams (Haw) Hawkins (Geel) Scneider (Stk)

FF: Mooney (Geel) Koschitzke (Stk) Osbourne (Haw)

R: Gardiner (Stk) Wodjinski (Geel) Ray (Stk)

Int: Campbell (Haw) Gram (Stk) Brown (Haw) Hunt (Geel)

Emg: Varcoe (Geel) Milne (Stk) Ellis (Haw)

swap the highlighted ones and ud be fairly close

 

[Whispers]

Can anyone justify why Chapman has Dews spot ?

PS I like Chapman bu fairs fair

Your kidding aren't you? Take the blinkers off!

 

[adii_7]

Your kidding aren't you? Take the blinkers off!

anyone who doesnt have gilbert in there team is smoking teh bong..

anyone who has hodge is just pure stupid

 

[lamaros]

that reserves side above would be a decent Top 8 side.

You're picking from three sides who one their own are top 8 sides. Of course this is going to be the case.

 

[walhawk]

Too hard.

Elite Hawks are Franklin. Roughead, Rioli, Sewell, Bateman, Hodge & Mitchell.

Haven't seen enough of the other sides

 

[Pessimistic]

Your kidding aren't you? Take the blinkers off!

Before the GF I would have agreed with you. Experienced opportunist impact players - often injured but lethal on song.

 

[Marklar_33]

You're picking from three sides who one their own are top 8 sides. Of course this is going to be the case.

Yeah, but you are of course taking the cream from each... you take the top 6-8 players from any team and they are nowhere near the same

Of course, you are probably left with an unbelievably talented group of "2nd tier" players, as is the case here

 

[Lord_Travis]

Can anyone justify why Chapman has Dews spot ?

PS I like Chapman bu fairs fair

Was that a joke? Chapmans a better player, and has also been better this year.

 

[Undecide]

Where's Zac?

 

[mad-saint-guy]

B: Hudghton (Stk) Scarlett (Geel) Gilbert (Stk)
HB: Hodge (Haw) S.Fisher (Stk) Goddard (Stk)
C: Dal Santo (Stk) Bartel (Geel) Bateman (Haw)
HF: S.Johnson (Geel) Riewoldt (Stk) Chapman (Geel)
F: Roughead (Haw) Franklin (Haw) Rioli (Haw)

Foll: Ottens (Geel) Ablett (Geel) Hayes (Stk)
Int: Gardiner (Stk) Sewell (Haw) Selwood (Geel) Montagna (Stk)

Emg: Mitchell (Haw) Enright (Geel) Koschitzke (Stk)

 

[jackmac7]

B: Gilbert, Scarlett, Enright
HB: Hodge, S.Fisher, Goddard
C: Selwood, Mitchell, Montagna
HF: Rioli, Riewoldt, S.Johnson
F: Roughead, Franklin, Milne
R: Ottens, Dal Santo, Ablett
I: Corey, Kosi, Sewell, Bartel

DELICIOUS!

 

[Skelter]

My effort, based on a combination of 2009 form and proven ability:

B- Sam Gilbert -- Matthew Scarlett -- Tom Harley
HB- Brendan Goddard -- Sam Fisher -- Luke Hodge
C- Joel Selwood-- Sam Mitchell -- Nick Dal Santo
HF- Cyril Rioli -- Nick Reiwoldt -- Jarryd Roughead
F- Steve Johnson -- Lance Franklin -- Stephen Milne
Fol- Brad Ottens -- Jimmy Bartel -- Gary Ablett
IC- Joel Corey -- Lenny Hayes -- Brad Sewell -- Robert Campbell