Pick 23 - Trade for Picks

[sharpie]

Hey Bomber fans,

Should WC get pick 26 from Richmond for Seaby, and it is looking quite likely we'll get pick 32 from WB for Hansen (Ray Swap)

Would you think pick 26 and 32 would be a fair swap for pick 23???

Would give you guys an extra pick in the 2nd round - and push us above Freo's eventual pick 24 in the draft that they'll get from Carlton

 

[loopy_cam]

I'd do it.

 

[daffo]

I would.

 

[Smyth94]

Hey Bomber fans,

Should WC get pick 26 from Richmond for Seaby, and it is looking quite likely we'll get pick 32 from WB for Hansen (Ray Swap)

Would you think pick 26 and 32 would be a fair swap for pick 23???

Would give you guys an extra pick in the 2nd round - and push us above Freo's eventual pick 24 in the draft that they'll get from Carlton

It probably is fair - I'm not an expert at all but I really don't see the point of it.

I don't think Essendon would be interested in giving WCE an early 2nd rounder when they already have a priority pick

 

[Daytripper]

Hey Bomber fans,

Should WC get pick 26 from Richmond for Seaby, and it is looking quite likely we'll get pick 32 from WB for Hansen (Ray Swap)

Would you think pick 26 and 32 would be a fair swap for pick 23???

Would give you guys an extra pick in the 2nd round - and push us above Freo's eventual pick 24 in the draft that they'll get from Carlton

So basically you want to swap Hansen and Seaby for pick 23.

I think the List Manager's job at the Eagles is safe for the time being.

 

[McLovin_Man]

Hey Bomber fans,

Should WC get pick 26 from Richmond for Seaby, and it is looking quite likely we'll get pick 32 from WB for Hansen (Ray Swap)

Would you think pick 26 and 32 would be a fair swap for pick 23???

Would give you guys an extra pick in the 2nd round - and push us above Freo's eventual pick 24 in the draft that they'll get from Carlton

no chance

 

[The Donners]

Hey Bomber fans,

Should WC get pick 26 from Richmond for Seaby, and it is looking quite likely we'll get pick 32 from WB for Hansen (Ray Swap)

Would you think pick 26 and 32 would be a fair swap for pick 23???

Would give you guys an extra pick in the 2nd round - and push us above Freo's eventual pick 24 in the draft that they'll get from Carlton

If you get pick 26 for Seaby WCE should be jailed for raping the Richmond Football Club, Seaby = Dud.

 

[sharpie]

So basically you want to swap Hansen and Seaby for pick 23.

I think the List Manager's job at the Eagles is safe for the time being.

Hansen for us is not going to be part of our next premiership squad.

Seaby has a desire to leave - I'd rather keep him.

Ultimately, draft picks are being held very close to the chest - I think that is the best deal we'd get.

Plus we'd get Ray plus 23 for Hansen and Seaby.

Pick 36 we'd give up to the bullies - but we wouldn't use that anyway

 

[sharpie]

It probably is fair - I'm not an expert at all but I really don't see the point of it.

I don't think Essendon would be interested in giving WCE an early 2nd rounder when they already have a priority pick

If the bombers can get a win out of it - why would they not do it just to stop WCE getting a win

 

[warney7]

It won't happen but I wouldn't hesitate to swap pick 23 for 26 and 32 if the offer was made.

Then we'd have 26, 32 and 39.

EDIT: And then pick 32 or 39 could be used for Prismall if the club wants him.

 

[saladin]

If the bombers can get a win out of it - why would they not do it just to stop WCE getting a win

because the kid we are looking at at #23 may well be the same one you are desperate to beat freo to. i am hoping we can upgrade #23 to somewhere in the mid teens and snaffle a Trengove or Swift, not downgrade it to pick 30-ish. Essendon don't need to boost the number of its kids. outright quality is the key.

 

[sharpie]

because the kid we are looking at at #23 may well be the same one you are desperate to beat freo to. i am hoping we can upgrade #23 to somewhere in the mid teens and snaffle a Trengove or Swift, not downgrade it to pick 30-ish. Essendon don't need to boost the number of its kids. outright quality is the key.

well the argument that Essendon wouldn't win out of it is fair enough - but to state that they wouldn't do it because WCE would win out of it would be petulent i would have thought.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

No thanks, the only way I want to change pick 23 is up to a late teens pick if possible

 

[saladin]

well the argument that Essendon wouldn't win out of it is fair enough - but to state that they wouldn't do it because WCE would win out of it would be petulent i would have thought.

but by definition, if essendon aren't winning out of it, west coast are. this isn't one of those times where both clubs win, because both clubs are in similar list positions.

 

[efcboy]

26 and 32 for pick 23 is definitely a good deal for essendon.

i can see why WC would want to jump freo as they will be fighting over the local talent.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

How is it a good deal- we go DOWN in the order

 

[loopy_cam]

How is it a good deal- we go DOWN in the order

We go down by three and also get an extra second roud pick.

Basically it's a downgrade of 23 to 26, 3 picks.

And an upgrade from our final pick used to this one, at least 20 picks.

 

[Tambu]

Would you think pick 26 and 32 would be a fair swap for pick 23???

Would give you guys an extra pick in the 2nd round - and push us above Freo's eventual pick 24 in the draft that they'll get from Carlton

Yep, sounds good to me.

 

[bomberz08]

good deal

 

[BacharHouli_43]

If you get pick 26 for Seaby WCE should be jailed for raping the Richmond Football Club, Seaby = Dud.

Seaby is a dud, and whatever WCE get for him, they should take it and run. the only reason they were playing him was to boost his trade value. The tigers are the biggest muppets when it comes to trade week, they have got no clue what opposition players are actually worth.

 

[B-Bomber]

That would be a great deal for us! We need to take quite a few picks in this draft due to the amount of delistments and retirements. It has been one of my issues with everyone wanting to trade pick 23 and lovett for something better -- the more players/picks we lose the more picks we need to take in 5th, or 6th rounds...

At the moment we have the second most removals from our list (behind freo) so we will need to top up quite a bit.