List Mgmt. Pick #5 - Welcome Adam Cerra [Traded to Carlton for 6 & F3]

[ignoramus]

Anyone else use hpnfooty for the trade value calc thing. It’s just an algorithm gents but I thought it was interesting.


View attachment 1215635
View attachment 1215636
One was for pick 8 and SPP and the other pick 8 and Fisher.

Odd that Wilson seems the be part of the trade — more than one of him, in fact, but we end up with one less, so maybe not all bad?

 

[Joao]

Do draft vids count?

Asking for a friend.

As long as it was at least 2 minutes long. You can easily tell everything about a player in their 2 minute highlight video.

 

[Big Flappy]

Tell Carlton to satisfy Geelong for Clark and take their first and Clark

 

[GingerDocker]

Tell Carlton to satisfy Geelong for Clark and take their first and Clark

 

[MadEyeEmmy]

Pick 6, 25 and Fisher

Hand it over

 

[BringFevBack2021]

This years 1st, next years 2nd or This years 1st, and a player of actual value to Fremantle. Not SPS, he is a 3rd rounder at best.

 

[Joao]

Pick 6, 25 and Fisher

Hand it over

They can keep Fisher. MOAR picks.

 

[Wilksyy]

Pick 6, 25 and Fisher

Hand it over

 

[BringFevBack2021]

Pick 6, 25 and Fisher

Hand it over

I think most Blues supporters could live with Pick 6, a 3rd and Fisher for Cerra. I don't know about 6, 25 and Fisher though.

Whatever the case, don't listen to nuffies spouting fantasy trades that heavily favour the Blues. It'll have to be fair, with us probably slightly losing the trade.

 

[muzzington]

I think most Blues supporters could live with Pick 6, a 3rd and Fisher for Cerra. I don't know about 6, 25 and Fisher though.

Whatever the case, don't listen to nuffies spouting fantasy trades that heavily favour the Blues. It'll have to be fair, with us probably slightly losing the trade.

I dunno, your first suggestion might be best case scenario for us if Carlton are the only destination.

 

[rgauci]

This years 1st, next years 2nd or This years 1st, and a player of actual value to Fremantle. Not SPS, he is a 3rd rounder at best.

What about

pick 6 and 24, and next years 2nd rounder

For Cerra and pick 27.

I’ve got a weird optimism about taking McGovern (no value as a salary dump). Everything about his career to date is mediocre, but our list is so devoid of medium forwards I’d take him.

 

[Cesoir]

So I guess Blakely came up short with his mission?

Apparently, but it was close...

 

[BringFevBack2021]

I dunno, your first suggestion might be best case scenario for us if Carlton are the only destination.

It's overs, but - it's also whatever. Fish is fringe for us, shown flashes but nothing amazing; it's not like he's an established player right? Should be treated as steak knives.

What about

pick 6 and 24, and next years 2nd rounder

For Cerra and pick 27.

I’ve got a weird optimism about taking McGovern (no value as a salary dump). Everything about his career to date is mediocre, but our list is so devoid of medium forwards I’d take him.

I think that's fine, effectively an early first, a three pick downgrade in this years draft and a hopefully later 2nd rounder.

I feel the same about Gov, would be spewin' to let him go given his body is finally right. He has been mediocre though, so I tend to agree that we are being oddly optimistic.

 

[dropbear101]

 

[dropbear101]

mark mcgowan has just called a press conference.

he has closed down the airport and placed triple g's at the border.

try leaving now cerra

 

[Dirty_banchez]

I had such high hopes for SPS in his draft year, and now look at him. Carlton has ruined him...

 

[TheLastCall]

Sorry for the intrusion guys. I come in peace.
Just wondering what you guys think of a possible trade deal of... (ins and outs from a Carlton perspective obviously)

Out: Pick 6 might drop to #8 with a couple of f/son and academy bids), SPS (seems his papers are stamped after not playing the last 3-4 weeks)
In: Cerra, Freo's 2nd rounder (currently #27, but could drift to low-mid 30's)

I loath to lose SPS, especially if we have a new coach coming in. I also would hate to lose Fisher, but he would be my preference if I had a choice. I used SPS simply because his papers seemed to be stamped for whatever reason. Still think he will go on to be a great player if given the chance to play as a midfielder or high HFF.
Reckon you guys will possibly think it's slight unders and most Blues fans probably think it's slight overs, which usually means it's a pretty good deal for both sides if both feel ripped off.

We rate Cerra highly. He’s worth pick 6 plus Carl 2022 1st.
A gun pick 5 with 78 games under his belt at his age it worth a lot.
You don’t get skills like his very often and proven ability.
SPS is only worth a 3rd currently and that would be next years third.

 

[tonygeeks]

I think we should do a poll of people here who have actually seen Carroll play.

I haven't. Now its your turn.

Nah , I’ve talked to someone who’s seen a bit of him though


Sent from my iPad using BigFooty.com

 

[Radstar]

Tell Carlton to satisfy Geelong for Clark and take their first and Clark

He hasn't actually nominated any club, although Carlton might be his preference but nothing stopping the Roos who have a strong hand making a play! a side bid will keep Carlton honest or a three way deal.

 

[88mph]

IF we wanted SPS, we could probably get him in the PSD for free.

 

[rgauci]

Would any Fremantle supporter do our first pick (pick 8) and Cerra for pick 1 to North? Then the question is raised, would North? Personally I’d prefer not.

 

[dropbear101]

Would any Fremantle supporter do our first pick (pick 8) and Cerra for pick 1 to North? Then the question is raised, would North? Personally I’d prefer not.

for a second back. yeah i'd consider it.

 

[Purple Jesus]

Would any Fremantle supporter do our first pick (pick 8) and Cerra for pick 1 to North? Then the question is raised, would North? Personally I’d prefer not.

Not with the F/S going on.

 

[Sweetback]

I don’t want Fisher. We don’t need another short arse

 

[wild side]

SPS is delist material