H Shaw V J Gram?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X or Player Y (Part 3)
- Thread starter Lakey91
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Pav or ROK?
Gilbee or Carrazzo?
Gilbee or Carrazzo?
i think you are overstating things here.
Kennelly is a 60 average player...A. Selwood is far way off proving he can hit 100's constantly..
I think it's more likely to be Kennelly 60 vs a.selwood (anywhere between 80 - 90)
goddard 105 vs trengove (anywhere between 60 and 70)
i would take option 2 in a heartbeat.
Thoughts on Boomer harvey vs any other forward priced between 300 - 400k??
ty for that response weninrome.. I'm not confident in Kennelly, but I would love to get Selwood into my team! But I do agree with you.. But also, will Trengove play 22?? I don't know....
For forwards between 300-400k; I have my eye on three mainly; Gia, Tippett (for dual position) and Gray. Harvey has been durable except for last year, but who knows how age will effect him. Higgins and Murphy look good too imo, but I think I would have too many dogs in my forward line if I included them..
I think Harvey will outscore Tippett and Gray, but if you need the money for some other upgrade I'd go them first..
For forwards between 300-400k; I have my eye on three mainly; Gia, Tippett (for dual position) and Gray. Harvey has been durable except for last year, but who knows how age will effect him. Higgins and Murphy look good too imo, but I think I would have too many dogs in my forward line if I included them..
I think Harvey will outscore Tippett and Gray, but if you need the money for some other upgrade I'd go them first..
You don't need trengove for 22 games though and his job security is pretty much better than any other mid rookie
More like
Kennelly (65) + Selwood (90) = 155 + two player needing upgrading
vs
Goddard (105) + Trengove (70) = 175 + only 1 upgrade needed
Yeh agree if Trengove can average 70 and play 15 games, thats more than enough.
Rockliff vs Gumbelton last choice. Even if Rockliff is named im scared he might play 1 game and be dropped. Cant say the same thing with gumby however as every1 knows, massive risk
Gumby just cause he is in the best 22...Surely Karma is due? he won't get injured for at least the first two months??
Jobe Watson vs Luke Ball
Id have to say Rockliff, Gumbelton is too much of a risk and even if he is playing is less likely to score as highly as Rockliff.. I think Rockliff is likely to play enough games to atleast make you a bit of money!!
Mine is:
Option 1
4th Defender: Grimes/Bock/Broughton 5th: Harbrow
7th Forward: Rockliff
Option 2
4th Defender: Harbrow 5th: Malceski
7th Forward: Dangerfield
Which option would u pick and which player would u pick if you choose option 1?
number 2 purely becasue rockliff won't play.. or play enough to make you money
Silky
Team Captain
I'll add one more to that:
Watson, Ball or Selwood (WCE)
Watson's DT game wont get affected by a tagger IMO as he scores a lot of points through getting the hard ball and tackling. Where i see his improvement is his kick:h/ball ratio as he has apparantly improved his kicking over the summer.
In that case, Watson > Ball > Selwood
Kreuzer + Higgins + Dangerfield
or
Clark + S. Johnson + Rookie
Thoughts ?
Kreuzer playing ruck now throws a whole new dimension into this thing. he will average 85 a game if he plays that position.
according to ratten he is.
Carrazzo + 20K VS Goodwin/boughton
Definetly the Goodwin/Broughton option. Simply because 2 premiums are better than 1, if your're only worried about the loss of 20K then go for it.
- Feb 15, 2010
- 292
- 1
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Banned
- #195
who's better?
Cox and sidebottom or hooker and dick?
Cox and sidebottom or hooker and dick?
- Feb 15, 2010
- 292
- 1
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Banned
- #196
I have not once responded in this thread but surely this one is a joke.
Their values do not even match up.
Cox fits well next to the side of bottoms.
Hookers fancy dicks.
D.Cox has had no pre-season and may have issues with his foot again.
S.Sidebottom is over-priced and is no guarantee to play week in, week out, let alone Round 1.
C.Hooker is just a "meh" for me.
B.Dick has a shoulder injury and is out indefinitely.
Now stop messing around and keep the comparisons legit.
Papa Juggs
Hall of Famer
- Banned
- #198
- Status
