can't go wrong with either. Gray for me as Dahlhaus is more likely to get tagged (e.g Essendon game)
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X v Player Y - 2014 Edition
- Thread starter Colin D'Cops
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Sep 12, 2013
- 1,985
- 2,576
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Hard to see him getting tagged ahead of Griffen and Libba. He was only tagged in the Essendon game after he had 20 touches in the first half. I'd still choose Gray ahead of him though.
doona
SMFC
depends if you have the cash spare?? I need my extra cash for upgrading rather then using on another mid pricer.
I don't need the extra cash really. No. Walker should score 70 odd? I would think. May get a red vest though.
i would go taylor walker. hes been in great form in the SANFL and should get a decent 75+ average. as for bock he hasnt really shown much DT form in the past 2 years when he's played. reckon he's a vest candiate and no more than a 60 average player.( i would downgrade to bock after 2 weeks after the byes cause i dont trust him to be on my field (even in fantasy).)
probably wont get a red vest now that tom lynch is injured. also hes not rushed into the team so i think less likely
yep, Gray has Boak, Ebert, Hartlett, Wingard .etc before him so he shouldn't get a tag, midfield or defensive forward
doona
SMFC
Then walker easily!!!! He has a low break even and I think you can trust him (especially in the bye rounds).......
SJ v Ablett
Will eventually have both...but who to bring in first?
EDIT: May hold off on the trade...both shaping to be tagged hard this week.
Will eventually have both...but who to bring in first?
EDIT: May hold off on the trade...both shaping to be tagged hard this week.
Last edited:
Ablett vs Curren or SJ vs Crowley. If you don't have Pendles I would pick him up if you're chasing a score otherwise GAJ for me. SJ is more likely to miss games.
Ablett gets tagged hard every week.
but still pumps out big numbers
And Crowley goes to Selwood every time. It would be departing from Lyon's normal tactics for him to go to SJ.
Not saying that Johnson won't get tagged by Crowley this time, but more that he hasn't been in the past. I think De Boer (if anyone) may get him.
Not saying that Johnson won't get tagged by Crowley this time, but more that he hasn't been in the past. I think De Boer (if anyone) may get him.
Yellow Feathers
Norm Smith Medallist
Not always. Some teams don't even bother anymore... Pretty much unstoppable.
In the qualifying final last year, Crowley tagged SJ for 3qtrs after spending the first qtr on Selwood IIRC. Freo were down by 2 goals at qtr time and went on to win the game, so I think there is a fair chance Lyon will try it again.
Lloyd v Ambrose?
Lloyd
SO VERY happy I took my own advice and didn't bring in Stevie J. Not only did he have a mare, but he has got himself rubbed out.
However, I didn't bring in Ablett as I decided to conserve my trades (RDT). Should be able to squeeze him in this week, though.
However, I didn't bring in Ablett as I decided to conserve my trades (RDT). Should be able to squeeze him in this week, though.
Gray or Danger?
Dangerfield is cheaper but looks a bit sore, might need a rest soon.
Dangerfield is cheaper but looks a bit sore, might need a rest soon.
Gray, he's more consistent
i would go Shaw because it would seem that Walker is playing a bit more forward where history shows he gets less points. However Shaw might miss this week
Bert Man
Premiership Player
- Jul 22, 2012
- 3,591
- 1,343
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- PSG, ARSENAL
I agree but Walker seems to be more consistent. He scores 80+ 4 out of 5 weeks whilst Shaw can go from 50-110 in any given week.
Similar threads
- Locked
