Player X v Player Y - 2014 Edition

[Torz]

Keep Suckling or sideways to NDS?

 

[doona]

Keep Suckling or sideways to NDS?

If Mitchell is named this week, that would be the upgrade target next week for Suckling. Thats what ill be doing anyway.

 

[VSTone]

Bartel & Dangerfield
vs
Simpson & K Jack ?

 

[kierez4ever]

Bartel & Dangerfield
vs
Simpson & K Jack ?

Simpson and Jack for me (assuming u are picking Jack as a FWD for fantasy)

 

[Bert Man]

Libba or Greenwood on my field this week? Libba is playing Geelong, Greenwood Hawthorn.

 

[doona]

Libba or Greenwood on my field this week? Libba is playing Geelong, Greenwood Hawthorn.

How do you have the cash on the pine not to field both of them???

 

[Bert Man]

How do you have the cash on the pine not to field both of them???

I'm in an elite league.

 

[Clint Beastwood]

Libba or Greenwood on my field this week? Libba is playing Geelong, Greenwood Hawthorn.

I'd be going Greenwood.

 

[Bert Man]

I'd be going Greenwood.

Why?

 

[Clint Beastwood]

Why?

Because I have more faith in him. Even though Griffen is back I'd be happier with Greenwood on the field, mainly because of Libba last week. That's just me.

 

[doona]

Libba or Greenwood on my field this week? Libba is playing Geelong, Greenwood Hawthorn.

I have both in my Fantasy, I would choose greenwood for 2 reasons:
1. I was thinking about trading out Libba (Not Greenwood)
2. I like friday night players

 

[I Like This]

Libba everyday of the week.

 

[LordHaart]

Libba or Greenwood on my field this week? Libba is playing Geelong, Greenwood Hawthorn.

Hope you went Greenwood... 78 and it's not even half time yet.

 

[I Like This]

Hope you went Greenwood... 78 and it's not even half time yet.

Didn't really matter in the end. 12 more points than Libba.

 

[Bert Man]

Glad I chose Greenwood.

Miles VS Omeara as a bench mid in elite?

 

[kierez4ever]

Glad I chose Greenwood.

Miles VS Omeara as a bench mid in elite?

JOM on the bench, Miles is in good form

 

[Quazza]

ok, I'm torn atm

Cotchin V JPK

and why......

 

[kierez4ever]

ok, I'm torn atm

Cotchin V JPK

and why......

JPK, higher average and more reliable

 

[StoneX]

James Kelly v Malceski v Hanley v Mitchell? Jaensch has to become someone else!

 

[PIGSTi]

Ben Brown or Cameron Wood?

 

[Butler]

I have basically already made my mind up on this one but thought I might as well just post it in here and see what other peoples thoughts are.

RDT:
KK-> McStay
Swan-> Rockliff

2 trades left.
B7: McStay
M9: Wingard/Honeychurch
R3: S.Martin/B.Brown
F7: Wingward/Kerston

Strengthen mids with the best DT mid in the game atm. Weaken backline backup and only 2 trades left.

or

Swan-> Mitchell
KK-> Birchall

2 trades left.
B7: Birchall
M9: Wingard/Honeychurch
R3: S.Martin/B.Brown
F7: Wingard/Kersten

Strengthen backline backups to avoid late out zeros but Rockliff is a better DTer than Mitchell.

or

Swan-> Mitchell

3 trades left.
B7: KK once he returns
M9: Wingard/Honeychurch
R3: S.Martin/B.Brown
F7: Wingard/Kersten

Saves extra trade and banks some $$. No backline emergency until KK returns (or Bews is named again) and no Rockliff.

 

[Bert Man]

I can have two of the following 5 in my elite league: Deledio, Stokes, Vince, Ellis and O'meara. Which two should I keep for my bench? I'm leaning toward Stokes and Ellis.

Thoughts?

 

[Bert Man]

Malceski or Enright on my field?