Post Your Team Here

[Anthemy]

Ummmm......... Have a look at some of the other SC teams in this forum and start again......

You took the backline right out of my mouth!

 

[atcocc]

ok guys heres my team feel free to tear it peices cause any feedback is appreciated

Backs: Goddard, Mattner, Cornes, Adcock, Malceski, T Williams, M Hurley (Suban Gallman/Kite)

Mids: Judd, Cross, J Selwood, Boak, Mackay, Rich (Beams Davenport)

Rucks: Cox, Ottens (Vickery, Currie)

Fowards: Pav, Franklin, Porps, Q Lynch, D Thomas, Higgins, Walker (Gumby Sidebottom)

. Im toying with a couple of ideas such as dropping boak and picking up griffen or even cotchin. and possibly moving higgins to the middle dropping mackay and picking up veszpremi in the fwd line. the only problem is it gives me 3 dogs in the middle. Also considering downgrading franklin to lids or rok

Thoughts?

 

[Flawed Genius]

Since post #48

BACKS Newman (RICH) Fisher (STK) Guerra (HAW) Adcock (BL) Smith (KANG) Petterd (MELB) Hill (FREM)
Rance (RICH) Hurley (ESS)

MIDS Judd (CARL) Cross (WBD) Kerr (WCE) Foley (RICH) Haselby (FREM) Rich (BL)
Anthony (KANG) Robinson (CARL)

RUCKS Cox (WCE) Ottens (GEEL)
Vickery (RICH) Trengove (PTA)

FWDS Harvey (KANG) Pavlich (FREM) Franklin (HAW) Hale (KANG) Veszpremi (SYD) Higgins (WBD) Sidebottom (COLL)
Ziebell (KANG) Gumbleton (ESS)

All the editing I'll do for now, but I think it looks fairly solid.

 

[hawker21]

Backs: S Fisher, Newman, Bock, Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, Petterd (Suban, Trengrove)
Mids: Judd, Cross, Mitchell, M Murphy, Higgins, Rich (Dangerfield , D Beams)
Rucks: D Cox, Ottens (Vickery, White - syd)
Fwds: Pavlich, Franklin, Didak, Lucas, Veszpremi, Hentshel, Yarran (Sidebottom, Gumbleton)

Forward line maybe a little weak?

 

[Flawed Genius]

Backs: S Fisher, Newman, Bock, Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, Petterd (Suban, Trengrove)
Mids: Judd, Cross, Mitchell, M Murphy, Higgins, Rich (Dangerfield , D Beams)
Rucks: D Cox, Ottens (Vickery, White - syd)
Fwds: Pavlich, Franklin, Didak, Lucas, Veszpremi, Hentshel, Yarran (Sidebottom, Gumbleton)

Forward line maybe a little weak?

Fairly solid, but Hentschel maybe a bit of a risk.

 

[Anthemy]

First Draft Team:

B: Hodge -- Cornes -- Adcock -- Malceski -- Myers -- J.Smith (Kang) -- Petterd (Em: Hurley & Rance)
M: Judd -- SBlack -- Cross -- Cousins -- Hasleby -- Rich (Em: Ziebell & Dangerfield)
R: Hille -- Warnock (EM: Mumford & Sellar)
F: Pavlich -- Franklin -- Deledio -- Walker -- Lucas -- Neagle -- Watts (Em: Sidebottom & Gumbleton)

I like it.
Other rookies to add/change could include maybe mitch thorp or dowler [no Croad] and trengrove
Love that midfield, as you said ??? over cousins.

Here's mine.

B:Malceski, Burgoyne, Adcock, Houlihan, Ellis, Myers , Pettard. EMG:Hurley, Rance

M: Judd, Selwood, Cooney, Cotchin, Haselby, Rich
EMG: Swift, Dangerfield

R: Cox, Hille
EMG: Trengrove, Vickery

F: Franklin, Pavlich, Riewoldt, Walker, Higgins, Veszpremi, Neagle
EMG: Thorp, Sidebottom

Advice to change?

 

[Anthemy]

Since post #48

BACKS Newman (RICH) Fisher (STK) Guerra (HAW) Adcock (BL) Smith (KANG) Petterd (MELB) Hill (FREM)
Rance (RICH) Hurley (ESS)

MIDS Judd (CARL) Cross (WBD) Kerr (WCE) Foley (RICH) Haselby (FREM) Rich (BL)
Anthony (KANG) Robinson (CARL)

RUCKS Cox (WCE) Ottens (GEEL)
Vickery (RICH) Trengove (PTA)

FWDS Harvey (KANG) Pavlich (FREM) Franklin (HAW) Hale (KANG) Veszpremi (SYD) Higgins (WBD) Sidebottom (COLL)
Ziebell (KANG) Gumbleton (ESS)

All the editing I'll do for now, but I think it looks fairly solid.

I'm thinking Ellis for Guerra.
Everything else looks good.

Seen mine?

 

[JasRulz63]

Defenders: Goddard, Fisher, C.Cornes, Adcock, McPhee, Malceski, Hill (Suban, O'Keefe)
Midfielders: Judd, J.Selwood, Kerr, Griffen, Coughlan, Rich (Sidebottom, Dangerfield)
Rucks: Cox, McIntosh (Sellar, Trengrove)
Forwards: Pavlich, Franklin, Chapman, Porplyzia, Davey, Yarran, Ballantyne (Gumbleton, Walker)

 

[Flawed Genius]

I'm thinking Ellis for Guerra.
Everything else looks good.

Seen mine?

I have, and it looks fairly good..

Houlihan & Walker would be my only concerns. The rest is strong.

Also, Ellis for Guerra is a fair downgrade in price, but not really in talent - Ellis set for a big year?

With the extra, what, $100K-odd, easily able to trade Kerr for a bigger name.. ie, Mitchell..

Fair point.

 

[Griff19]

My team. It will probably change 100 times but its a start! May be a bit light up forward! May be too much of an even spread. Please Help!!!

Backs
Birchall, Harley, Hodge, McLeod, Morris, Milburn, Armfield (Grima & Shoenmakers)

Midfield
Selwood, McLean, C.Young, Cousins, Masten, Bateman (Bail & Rich)

Ruck
Hill, Koschitzke (Cordy & Meesen)

Forward

Fevola, M.Williams, R.Murphy, Higgins, Skipworth, Didak, Watts (Yarran & Sidebottom)

 

[Flawed Genius]

My team. It will probably change 100 times but its a start! May be a bit light up forward! May be too much of an even spread. Please Help!!!

Backs
Birchall, Harley, Hodge, McLeod, Morris, Milburn, Armfield (Grima & Shoenmakers)

Midfield
Selwood, McLean, C.Young, Cousins, Masten, Bateman (Bail & Rich)

Ruck
Hill, Koschitzke (Cordy & Meesen)

Forward

Fevola, M.Williams, R.Murphy, Higgins, Skipworth, Didak, Watts (Yarran & Sidebottom)

How much money do you have left!?

 

[Griff19]

How much money do you have left!?

$26,300, why, good or bad???

 

[Anthemy]

Houlihan & Walker would be my only concerns. The rest is strong.

Also, Ellis for Guerra is a fair downgrade in price, but not really in talent - Ellis set for a big year?

With the extra, what, $100K-odd, easily able to trade Kerr for a bigger name.. ie, Mitchell..

Fair point. [/quote]

Ellis will push into the mid more this year with crawf gone. As you said, you can spend that cash well.

Walker is a gamble.
Huouli was cheap.

Instead of walker then who?

 

[Flawed Genius]

$26,300, why, good or bad???

It's .. a little short on the bigger name players..

I personally would change a few things.

 

[Griff19]

It's .. a little short on the bigger name players..

I personally would change a few things.

Yeah thought that might be the case!!! Back to the drawing board!!
Cheers

 

[Flawed Genius]

Ellis will push into the mid more this year with crawf gone. As you said, you can spend that cash well.

Walker is a gamble.
Huouli was cheap.

Instead of walker then who?

Not sure. Who else is in that price range..

Davey? Dale Thomas, Corey Jones?

 

[Anthemy]

Backs
Birchall, Harley, Hodge, McLeod, Morris, Milburn, Armfield (Grima & Shoenmakers)

Midfield
Selwood, McLean, C.Young, Cousins, Masten, Bateman (Bail & Rich)

Ruck
Hill, Koschitzke (Cordy & Meesen)

Forward

Fevola, M.Williams, R.Murphy, Higgins, Skipworth, Didak, Watts (Yarran & Sidebottom)

Change birchall to ellis.

Upgrade/Change Mclean/Bateman to include Gibbs, Judd, Black or Cross.
Young is maybe not worth that much. Could also be Hasebly, Cotchin, Rosa.

Forward line needs more guns, such as Franklin, Pavlich, Riewoldt, JBrown, or Harvey

Get rid of Kozi for Cox [when cheaper], Ottens, or Simmonds,

 

[Kerrby04]

First up quick team:

BACKS Newman (RICH) Fisher (STK) Cornes (PTA) Malceski (SYD) Adcock (BL) Guerra (HAW) Trengove (PTA) [Post (RICH) Grima (KANG)]

MIDS Harvey (KANG) Selwood (GEEL) Foley (RICH) Griffen (WBD) Cotchin (RICH) Rich (BL) [Ziebell (KANG) Robinson (CARL)]

RUCKS Petrie (KANG) Ottens (GEEL) [Cordy (WBD) Vickery (RICH)]

FWDS Pavlich (FREM) Brown (BL) Hale (KANG) Rioli (HAW) Campbell (KANG) Ebert (PTA) Sidebottom (COLL) [Grant (WBD) Gourdis (RICH)]

Feedback appreciated

Im not entirely convinced on your rookie/emergency selection.

Do you see Trengove doing a similar role as Taylor?
If he doesnt get consistent games, do you see a replaceable emergency?

I find that rookie def are harder to cement their spot in the team then a floating crumber or a bench mid.

Being super ano, i dont see many games coming from Cordy.

Your selection of Gourdis suggests your short on $. Try to muster up another $10k and pickup someone wholl get to play some games and return dividends. ie. mitchbrown(wce), walker(adel), even ballantyne.

I hope i didnt sound to harsh. But selection of rookies is important if you want to go premiums later.

 

[Anthemy]

Not sure. Who else is in that price range..

Davey? Dale Thomas, Corey Jones?

Could get Porpz, Roughhead, Aker, Thomas, A Lovett, Cyril, nearly Brad Johnson

 

[Flawed Genius]

Im not entirely convinced on your rookie/emergency selection.

Do you see Trengove doing a similar role as Taylor?
If he doesnt get consistent games, do you see a replaceable emergency?

I find that rookie def are harder to cement their spot in the team then a floating crumber or a bench mid.

Being super ano, i dont see many games coming from Cordy.

Your selection of Gourdis suggests your short on $. Try to muster up another $10k and pickup someone wholl get to play some games and return dividends. ie. mitchbrown(wce), walker(adel), even ballantyne.

I hope i didnt sound to harsh. But selection of rookies is important if you want to go premiums later.

Have changed it since then

 

[Anthemy]

DEF: GILBEE, CHAD, BOCK, PBURGOYNE, ADCOCK, MALCESKI, PETTERD (OKEEFE, SUBAN)

MIDS: JUDDY(C), CROSS, JSELWOOD, KERR, HASLEBY, RICH (BEAMS, DANGERFIELD)

RUCK: COX, OTTENS (JWHITE, TRENGOVE)

FWD: PAV(VC), DELEDIO, LUCAS, BRETTEBERT, VESZPREMI, HIGGINS, HENTSCHEL (SIDEBOTTOM, BALLANTYNE)
.

Looks a very strong team.


Awesome top four mids!

Agree about you bottom five fwds, ive got two and thought about henschell also.

 

[Kerrby04]

Looks a very strong team.


Awesome top four mids!

Agree about you bottom five fwds, ive got two and thought about henschell also.

Well its make or break for my forwards.
Hopefull of the last 3 could return $300-350k.

Else i could drop Selwood for Cogs and upgrade one of the forwards.
Then ill be relying on a mid who hasnt stepped on the park for 2 years.

The beauty of the salary cap.

 

[mouseman99]

Ok guys - here is my team

I'm pretty new to all this so your thoughts would be much appreciated



Backs
Drummond, Houli, S Hill, J Adcock, Malceski, Petterd, S Browne
emg: Trengrove & Hurley

Midfield
Judd, Pendlebury, Cousins, C Cornes, Kerr, Selwood
emg Rich & Dangerfield

Rucks
Hille, Kreuzer
emg: Naitanui & N/A yet

Forwards
J Brown, Deledio, Lucas, M Clark, Jetta, Headland, McKinley
emg: Yarran & Gumbleton



Thoughts anyone?

 

[Kerrby04]

Ok guys - here is my team

I'm pretty new to all this so your thoughts would be much appreciated



Backs
Drummond, Houli, S Hill, J Adcock, Malceski, Petterd, S Browne
emg: Trengrove & Hurley

Midfield
Judd, Pendlebury, Cousins, C Cornes, Kerr, Selwood
emg Rich & Dangerfield

Rucks
Hille, Kreuzer
emg: Naitanui & N/A yet

Forwards
J Brown, Deledio, Lucas, M Clark, Jetta, Headland, McKinley
emg: Yarran & Gumbleton



Thoughts anyone?

Midfield may be too top heavy?

Id go over the bolded ones. Tiller, Dempsey, Rains, Houlihan, Surjan are value for money.

 

[IDIG]

Here's mine as it stands. I have about 5 others saved and have worried too much about rookies until i see what happens during the nab.

Backs - Newman, Fisher, Gilbee, Cornes, Malceski, Adcock, Petterd (Suban, O'Keefe.

Mids - Bartel, Judd, Kerr, Hasleby, Coughlan, Rich (Sidebottom, Beams)

Rucks - Petrie, Ottens (Trengove, Currie)

Fwds - Boomer, Lids, ROK, Brown, Houlihan, Gumbleton, Zeibell (Ballantyne, Walker)

My concern is maybe too many risks in each position. Thoughts?

Can someone comment on the price structure of mine? Am i taking too big a risk?