Post Your Team Here

[Parasite]

Oh man... I sure hopes it's one of my three!

Laycock?
Ballchambers?
...

um...

Hislop?

I may have told a porky, just checked my team and there are two bombers I've picked...and I know who your other one is.

There seems to be a theme to your players you mentioned...pity Sidebottom didn't go to you guys.

 

[rocklovelive]

Back: C.Newman, A.Mackie, G.Birchall, X.Ellis, N.Malceski, C.Dempsey, R.Petterd (M.Hurley, S.McKernan)

Mid: J.Bartel, S.Mitchell, D.Kerr, S.Dew, M.Coughlan, D.Rich (P.Dangerfield, A.Arrowsmith)

Ruck: D.Hille, H.McIntosh (T.Bellchambers, J.Trengrove)

Fwd: B.Harvey, M.Pavlich, L.Franklin, J.Porplyzia, R.Houlihan, D.Headland, S.Gumbleton (S.Sidebottom, R.Shoenmakers)

With the spare cash, I'd upgrade Dempsey or Petterd.
Stuart Dew is a poor option IMO, Hasleby, Tambling or N Jones all better options.
Harvey is too expensive, get rid of him and upgrade Deadland.

 

[Walesy]

I may have told a porky, just checked my team and there are two bombers I've picked...and I know who your other one is.

There seems to be a theme to your players you mentioned...pity Sidebottom didn't go to you guys.

mwahahaha... then my plan worked...

Me, I think it's a pity we didn't pick up Rich.

 

[The Stomp]

Any thought or recommendations

MCPHEE, Adam HURN, Shannon MALCESKI, Nick
JONES, Brett (Unsure) RAINES, Andrew HODGE, Luke
CORNES, Chad
Emerg: Rance & Suban

BARTEL, Jimmy COTCHIN, Trent JUDD, Chris
KERR, Daniel VAN BERLO, Nathan (Unsure) RICH, Daniel
Emerge: Sidebottem & Davenport

COX, Dean HAMPSON, Shaun
Emerg: Currie & Bailey


HIGGINS, Shaun HENTSCHEL, Trent DELEDIO, Brett
PAVLICH, Matthew LUCAS, Scott (Unsure) DIDAK, Alan
FEVOLA, Brendan
Emerge: M. Brown & Yarran

 

[Mick_15]

First Post for the new year, very glad supercoach is back!!

Backs:
Fisher, Goddard, Cornes, Waite, Malceski, Waters, Hill
Emg: Suban, Rance

Mid:
Judd, Kerr, Burgoyne, Dal Santo, Rich, Dangerfield*
*(or one of the other emg's: Beams/Davenport)

Rucks:
Cox, Ottens
Emg: Sellar, Trengrove

Fwds:
Harvey, Delidio, Lynch (walesy inspired), Lucas, Higgins, Yarren
Emg: Ziebell, Gumbelton

Waters in the backline is a concern for me, i think he can play but last year was woefull for him. Also two rookie in the midfield is a bit of a risk.

What do you guys think?

cheers

 

[jazz]

I've seen Ellis, Hodge and Reiwoldt in a few teams.

I wouldn't start with them - all coming off injuries and will start slowly. They will drop in value early on before coming good.

 

[PAFCsince1870]

This is my starting point before the pre-season with a couple undecided;

B: Hodge, Goddard, Cornes, Adcock, Malceski, JW Smith, Waters/Houlihan
(Petterd, Suban)

M: Dal Santo, Judd/S Burgoyne, Cooney, Coughlan, Mackay, Rich
(Davenport, Dangerfield)

R: Cox, Jolly
(White/Currie, Meesen)

F: Pavlich, O'Keefe/Deledio, Mcphee, Lucas, A Hansen, Rusling, Higgins
(Yarran, Walker)

 

[Walesy]

First Post for the new year, very glad supercoach is back!!

Backs:
Fisher, Goddard, Cornes, Waite, Malceski, Waters, Hill
Emg: Suban, Rance

Mid:
Judd, Kerr, Burgoyne, Dal Santo, Rich, Dangerfield*
*(or one of the other emg's: Beams/Davenport)

Rucks:
Cox, Ottens
Emg: Sellar, Trengrove

Fwds:
Harvey, Delidio, Lynch (walesy inspired), Lucas, Higgins, Yarren
Emg: Ziebell, Gumbelton

Waters in the backline is a concern for me, i think he can play but last year was woefull for him. Also two rookie in the midfield is a bit of a risk.

What do you guys think?

cheers

Hill - Watch in preseason, good chance of being undercooked.
Waters - has damaged his elbow. goooooooooorne.
Lynch - Ha! He's my weakness! I love the bloke! How could you not want to pick him!

So yeah, a little more cash in the backline needed...

 

[Griff19]

Ok my second crack (with a little help form you boys!!)

Backline

Ellis, Hodge, McLeod, C.Cornes, Houlihan, Grimes, Malceski (D.Okeefe & A Rance)

Midfield

Cooney, Cotchin, Selwood, Judd, Rich, Cousins (Beams & Davenport)

Ruck

Cox, Minson (Seller & Trengrove)

Forward

Franklin, B.Harvey, Deledio, Headland, Veszpremi, Watts, Higgins (Yarran & M.Brown)


Am I getting there???!!

 

[Sergio]

Ok, here's my team at the moment, please criticise to your heart's content, i'm a first time Supercoach.

Backs

Houlihan Sam Fisher S. Hill
Birchall Bock Malceski X. Ellis
(emg. Suban Hurley)

Mids

Judd Bartel Kerr
Rich J. Selwood Hasleby
(emg. Robinson Dangerfield)

Rucks

Cox Ottens
(emg. Trengrove Meesen)

Forwards

Higgins A. Walker Deledio Chapman
Yarran Pavlich Veszpremi
(emg. Gumbleton T. Walker)​

right now, i'm fairly satisfied, although i'm sure it'll change rouns soon. I think at first glance the forward line looks a bit weak, but Chapman, Deledio, Pavlich and this year A Walker are all elite. any feedback would be awesome.

also, quick question, does anyone know why waite costs significantly more than bock? don't get me wrong, i rate waite, but bock gets more possesions and is usually more effective, plus he plays forward and kicks a goal on occasion. i'm just not sure why waite is worth so much?

cheers.

 

[jonoman89]

Figure out a way to turn Hill into ... not hill, and you're onto something.

NAB Cup always changes things around

Defensive rookies are a problem this year....

 

[deadoralive]

First Post for the new year, very glad supercoach is back!!

Backs:
Fisher, Goddard, Cornes, Waite, Malceski, Waters, Hill
Emg: Suban, Rance

Mid:
Judd, Kerr, Burgoyne, Dal Santo, Rich, Dangerfield*
*(or one of the other emg's: Beams/Davenport)

Rucks:
Cox, Ottens
Emg: Sellar, Trengrove

Fwds:
Harvey, Delidio, Lynch (walesy inspired), Lucas, Higgins, Yarren
Emg: Ziebell, Gumbelton

Waters in the backline is a concern for me, i think he can play but last year was woefull for him. Also two rookie in the midfield is a bit of a risk.

What do you guys think?

cheers

waters has done his elbow, check out the details. might have to choose someone else

 

[Mick_15]

Hill - Watch in preseason, good chance of being undercooked.
Waters - has damaged his elbow. goooooooooorne.
Lynch - Ha! He's my weakness! I love the bloke! How could you not want to pick him!

So yeah, a little more cash in the backline needed...

Changes i made:

Waters --> Adcock

Dal Santo --> Mitchell

Hill --> Pretenko


If Lynch can start the year like he finished last years we'll be laughing!

*Cheers DOA

 

[jonoman89]

Changes i made:

Waters --> Adcock

Dal Santo --> Mitchell

Hill --> Pretenko


If Lynch can start the year like he finished last years we'll be laughing!

*Cheers DOA

i'd rather a better disposer of the ball than Mitchell. I'd prefer Dal personally.

 

[Mick_15]

i'd rather a better disposer of the ball than Mitchell. I'd prefer Dal personally.

True i agree, i completely forgot about my boi LennY!!

Hardly anyone has mentioned him, up the top in takles every year.

Swapped mitchell for Lenny Hayes....although Luke Ball..is tasty for the same reasons....

 

[Rancid_Beasties]

Thoughts?

 

[jonoman89]

True i agree, i completely forgot about my boi LennY!!

Hardly anyone has mentioned him, up the top in takles every year.

Swapped mitchell for Lenny Hayes....although Luke Ball..is tasty for the same reasons....

Was just about to say you could grab Hayes for $5k less

 

[sens]

Thoughts?

Bit of a risky team with guys like Cousins, Haselby, Hentschel, Higgins, Lucas, Meesen ect. If I were you I'd sell off Haselby for a lower priced player for your bench and start Rich and upgrade Hansen to a gun.

 

[jonoman89]

Thoughts?

Corey is too expensive - will drop in price. Ditto Cousins and Porplyzia.

Hansen wont score much.

 

[jonoman89]

Marc Murphy or Luke Ball? I'm leaning towards Murphy because he has greater room for improvement.

 

[sens]

Marc Murphy or Luke Ball? I'm leaning towards Murphy because he has greater room for improvement.

Also less of an injury risk. I'd do that too.

 

[fatfootybrain]

This is my second year in SC. Last year's team was an absolute shocker.

Anyway, feedback appreciated!

Backs - Goddard, C.Cornes, Birchall, Adcock, Ellis, Hurley, Petterd (Rance, Suban)
Mids - Hayes, M.Murphy, Palmer, Cousins, Higgins (Rich, Dangerfield)
Rucks - Cox, Ottens (Naitanui, Trengove)
Forwards - Pavlich, Franklin, Richardson, R.Murphy, Lucas, Hentschel, Gumbleton (Ballantyne, Sidebottom)

Got about 100k left.

 

[Flawed Genius]

More than likely the team I'll go into the season with, barring any injuries or major brainwaves:

BACKS
S Fisher C Newman J Adcock R Petterd N Malceski J Smith S Hill
M Hurley S McKernan

MIDS
C Judd D Cross J Corey P Hasleby D Rich N Foley
L Anthony M Robinson

FORWARDS
M Pavlich L Franklin B Harvey D Hale P Veszpremi S Higgins S Sidebottom
J Ziebell S Gumbleton

RUCKS
D Cox B Ottens
T Vickery J Trengove​

Any feedback at all would be appreciated.

 

[Gouloff]

Backs: P.Davis, S.Hill, N.Suban, J.Frawley, B.Ross, JW.Smith, N.Brown (A.Donohue, R.Sloane)
Mids: B.Cousins, D.Rich, B.Harvey, L.Hodge, D.Swan, G.Ablett (J.Zeibell, D.Beams)
Rucks: M.Leuenberger, D.Cox (T.Vickery, J.Roughead)
Fwds: J.Brown, S.Lucas, M.Richardson, N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, A.Didak, L.Franklin (D.Stewart, S.Rusling)

Backs I've taken a few risks but other than that

 

[johno_1989]

Backs: A. Walker, S. Fisher, C.Cornes, P. Burgoyne, N Malceski, D. Milburn, T. Croad.
EMG: M. Egan, Z. Dawson

Center: B. Harvey, C. Judd, D. Rich, K. Cornes, J. Zeibell, D. Kerr
EMG: P. Dangerfield, T. Swift

Ruck: Ottens, Simmonds
EMG: A. Graham, J. Tippet

Forwards: M. Pavlich, B. Fevola, B. Johnson, R. Robertson, C. Yarren, L. Franklin, S. Lucas
EMG: S. Gumbleton, J. Sellar

Atm still thinking about trading a few players.

Roberston for Houlahan or Ebert
B. Johnson for S. Johnson
And one of my backs, Atm leaning towards Walker, Milburn or Fisher