Yeah its a good rule imo. Stops the robbing peter to pay paul scenario that often occurs in club footy.I’m coaching Sandgate womens, we have moved from Div 2 to Div 1. One clear rule was we couldn’t recruit more than 3 players from another Div 1 club. You’d hope start up clubs would have to have 30 or their own new players with a couple from other clubs at the most.