- Thread starter
- #76
he'd make a good jackolantern ol pumpkin head.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 7 - Pride Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rate A Player: Rhyce Shaw
- Thread starter NoelMugavin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #78
Deadset hack one of the worst and softest players in the AFL and just brings shame to Collingwoods famous No 22 gurnsey 
There isn't a ranking low enough for me to accurately rate him.
At about round 9 in 2003 We were 4 and five and looking very slow with little run from the back half and it was rhyce shaw who started to give us some run and pace from defence, when givin the opportunity that is, and out wide that quickened us up and the side started to play with more dash and flair in general as well and we went on to win every game bar 2 looses to brisbane after that.
Im not saying rhyce was resposible for the complete turnaround but he gave us something we desperately needed at the time and when mick gave him more game time he duly responded and his confidence grew.
I reckon mick doesnt instill confidence but coaches from what i have heard on intimidation and fear and i think rhyce has lost a fair bit of confidence because of that coaching style.
He played two goodish games last year on aker in the wet and on judd so if given a defensive job to do he will stick to his task.
Get him on the weights get him fit and give him some decent game time and maybe he will regain some confidence and play like he did in mid 2003.
Im not saying rhyce was resposible for the complete turnaround but he gave us something we desperately needed at the time and when mick gave him more game time he duly responded and his confidence grew.
I reckon mick doesnt instill confidence but coaches from what i have heard on intimidation and fear and i think rhyce has lost a fair bit of confidence because of that coaching style.
He played two goodish games last year on aker in the wet and on judd so if given a defensive job to do he will stick to his task.
Get him on the weights get him fit and give him some decent game time and maybe he will regain some confidence and play like he did in mid 2003.
the words rate, rating , rated etc... should not be used in the same sentence or paragraph or anything as rhyc... ooops i nearly did it.
JunctionOval
Debutant
Collingwood are saying he is rock solid during the pre-season. Cant wait to get him on the bench.
Bwahahahahahahahah!!
Where is the poll option "I'm going to be original and post an anti-Collingwood thread but I'll hide it by asking people to rate a bloke who has close family ties to Collingwood and had a very obvious mistake in a grand final."
Like alot of players going around when he is good he is pretty good but when he is bad he is awful. Because of his family ties he will always come under the microscope, more so than other players of similar inconsistency.
Some of his performances in 2003 were top class. Those saying he is useless need to be more objective when assessing players from clubs that they hate. Of course these are generally the same people who object to (or ignore) the fact that despite having a list of supposedly complete soft duds with poor delivery and no ticker, Collingwood somehow managed to make two grand finals in a row, coming close to snaring one in 2002.
Regards
S. Pete
Like alot of players going around when he is good he is pretty good but when he is bad he is awful. Because of his family ties he will always come under the microscope, more so than other players of similar inconsistency.
Some of his performances in 2003 were top class. Those saying he is useless need to be more objective when assessing players from clubs that they hate. Of course these are generally the same people who object to (or ignore) the fact that despite having a list of supposedly complete soft duds with poor delivery and no ticker, Collingwood somehow managed to make two grand finals in a row, coming close to snaring one in 2002.
Regards
S. Pete
Plays Fabio Football.
"So soft I can't believe it's not butter"
"So soft I can't believe it's not butter"
- Banned
- #87
Amazing how this thread gets bumped back on to the front page every other day.
Keep it up lads, cant get enough black and white myself.
Keep it up lads, cant get enough black and white myself.
- Thread starter
- #88
would make a great butternut pumpkin soup.
Similar threads
