Rate my Super Coach team part II

[russea]

A lot of cash left over, I would upgrade Goodwin (getting on a bit)-Goddard, and upgrade Armitage-Vince/Cooney, Dont know if Armitage will be the goods straight away, I wouldn't touch your forward line, its pretty similar to mine thats why i like it.

My Side ATM:

BACKS: Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Kennely, Malceski, Ladson, Waters
EMER: Davies, Silvagni

MIDS: Ablett, Pendlebury, Selwood, Cooney, Dalziell, Martin
EMER: Bastinac, Shuey

RUCKS: Cox, Ottens
EMER: Skipper, Bass

FORWARDS: Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Giansiracusa, Hall, Medhurst, Gumbleton
EMER: Stewart, Podsiadly

BOLD are the keepers!

Any ideas let me know!

Backs are a little weak but still good, not sur if kennellys a keeper but a good pick
Like the mids but im not sure on dalziell was a SC gun few years ago but havnt heard much since then
Rucks alright but dont no about cox a little to risky for me
Fwds ur missing one gun between roo and boomer but still like it

 

[larrikan]

Backs are all good pretty much standard
Mids are good but u have to i repeat HAVE TO HAVE MARTIN he is all ready in richmonds top 10 players without playing a game.

Rucks are ok not confident on Cox i much prefer sandi

Fwds not bad Higgins injury prone, Gia i like, gray i like, Danger is good, like medhurst a lot my one of my bargin picks of 2010 looks ready to fire

so not a bad side but please get martin for the good of ur side

Goddard, Enright, H.Shaw, Hodge, Malceski, Ladson, Greenwood (B. Waters, Macguire)
Ablett(C), Pendlebury, Vince, Ball, MARTIN, Jetta (Barlow, Bastinac)
TIPPETT, Naitanui (Warnock, Skipper)
Reiwoldt, O'KEEFE, Giansiracusa, Gray, Dangerfield, Medhurst, Rohan (Rockliff, Podsiadly)
thanks for that...here is an alternative team...comments?

 

[russea]

Goddard, Enright, H.Shaw, Hodge, Malceski, Ladson, Greenwood (B. Waters, Macguire)
Ablett(C), Pendlebury, Vince, Ball, MARTIN, Jetta (Barlow, Bastinac)
TIPPETT, Naitanui (Warnock, Skipper)
Reiwoldt, O'KEEFE, Giansiracusa, Gray, Dangerfield, Medhurst, Rohan (Rockliff, Podsiadly)
thanks for that...here is an alternative team...comments?

Thats looking a lot better now

 

[Satan]

i have downgraded my foward line:

DEF Enright Fisher Hodge Adcock Malceski Nash Waters (Carlisle Silvagni)
MID Ablett Pendlebury Mithcell Boyd Trengrove Martin (Banner Moles)
RUCK Sandilands Hille (Lobbe Mcnamara)
FWD Riewoldt Pavlich Harvey Higgins Porplyzia? Medhurst Rockliff (Tapscott Podsiadly)
not sure about porpylzia though

tapscott is a LTI and you can add Jurrah, Cale morton, Bell to ltis

 

[boban00]

DEF: Enright, Hodge, Gilbert, Doughty, Malceski, Hunt, Waters
Maguire, Shepperd

MID: Ablett, Vince, Santo, Boyd, Martin, Morabito
Banner, Moles

RUCK: Sandilands, Clark
Warnock, Charman

FWD: Riewoldt, Brown, Franklin, Hall, Warren, Rohan, Rockliff
Hitchcock, Tarrant

Out of 10?

 

[Purrfect Pussies]

Stuff it! I just threw a side together under my wifes name for my 4th league. No Ablett. I nearly like it better than mine.


Backs; Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Gilbee, Malceksi, Hunt, Waters, (Goose, Webberley)

Mids: Swan, Selwood, Mitchell, Cooney, Martin, Barlow (Trengrove, Sheuy)

Rucks: Sandi, Tippett (Skipper, Lobbe)

Fwds: Roo, ROK, Sylvia, Hall, Ziebell, Coonhat, Rohan (PODS, Rockliff)

God this game gives me the shits. Just when you think your happy.

 

[Hawks92]

A lot of cash left over, I would upgrade Goodwin (getting on a bit)-Goddard, and upgrade Armitage-Vince/Cooney, Dont know if Armitage will be the goods straight away, I wouldn't touch your forward line, its pretty similar to mine thats why i like it.

My Side ATM:

BACKS: Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Kennely, Malceski, Ladson, Waters
EMER: Davies, Silvagni

MIDS: Ablett, Pendlebury, Selwood, Cooney, Dalziell, Martin
EMER: Bastinac, Shuey

RUCKS: Cox, Ottens
EMER: Skipper, Bass

FORWARDS: Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Giansiracusa, Hall, Medhurst, Gumbleton
EMER: Stewart, Podsiadly

$81,700 left over

BOLD are the keepers!

Any ideas let me know!

Thanks a lot for your thoughts

I like your team, it is similar to mine lol

Your backline is good, but i'm not sure about starting Waters, could pay off i guess. Kennelly also, can't see him averaging over 65 - maybe get Josh Hunt?

Dalziell is going to be used as a tagger for WCE, so stay away. Apart from that midfield is good

Cox is a gun, but i can't see him playing 22 games this year, maybe downgrade him to Sandi? Ottens was in my team at one stage as well, but again injury puts me off

Solid team though

 

[Hot Tiges]

DEF: Enright, Hodge, Gilbert, Doughty, Malceski, Hunt, Waters
Maguire, Shepperd

MID: Ablett, Vince, Santo, Boyd, Martin, Morabito
Banner, Moles

RUCK: Sandilands, Clark
Warnock, Charman

FWD: Riewoldt, Brown, Franklin, Hall, Warren, Rohan, Rockliff
Hitchcock, Tarrant

Out of 10?

7/10
Not sure on Rohan and Rockliff both starting in the fwd line. Doughty is an interesting pick.Will get 80-110 usually if he is not tagging.Nice midfield, could downgrade one of them to upgrade Rohan. Morabito looks a bit overrawed at the moment.. Either Barlow or Jetta look better so far.

 

[FalcoX]

This is an awesome Super Coach team...right?

 

[Staffy_Dog]

Would be interested in the thoughts on what I've put together so far. Haven't had a chance to study form as much as I'd like and not quite up to speed on injuries.

DEF
Goddard (vc), S. Fisher, Hodge, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson, Greenwood
(Maguire (emerg), Silvagni)

MID
Ablett (c), Pendlebury, Cooney, Griffen, Burgoyne, A. Walker
(Martin (emerg), Moles)

RUCK
Sandilands, Hille
(Warnock, Skipper)

FWD
Riewoldt, Franklin, J. Kennedy, Hall, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Veszpremi
(Rockliff (emerg), Dennis-Lane)

 

[marshie_blues]

Would be interested in the thoughts on what I've put together so far. Haven't had a chance to study form as much as I'd like and not quite up to speed on injuries.

DEF
Goddard (vc), S. Fisher, Hodge, Malceski, Hunt, Ladson, Greenwood
(Maguire (emerg), Silvagni)

MID
Ablett, Pendlebury, Cooney, Griffen, Burgoyne, A. Walker
(Martin (emerg), Moles)

RUCK
Sandilands, Hille
(Warnock, Skipper)

FWD
Riewoldt, Franklin, J. Kennedy, Hall, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Veszpremi
(Rockliff (emerg), Dennis-Lane)

Backline is a bit short for me Malceski could be a good pick up but is a worry also starting all 3 of ladson hunt and greenwood is a risk

Mids are good but in my opinion you need to get more of the rookies that are available in there, Martin should be starting. In my opinion you should probably start 2 midfield rookies this season. Moles is also a risk considering he is in a team dominated by midfielders, trengrove, banner, shuey, bastinac, jetta, barlow are all good options as rookie midfields.

Rucks i like, Hille could be a worry im deciding between him and nic nat

Forwards i think you are one premium short. other than that looks good

heres my team

Backs: Goddard, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Kennelly, Hunt (Maguire, Waters)

Mids: Ablett, Dal Santo, Vince, Martin, Barlow, Jetta (Shuey, Banner)

Rucks: Sandilands, Naitanui (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Reiwoldt, Pav, Buddy, Tippet, Hall, Dangerfield, Rockliff (Gumbleton, Podsiadly)

48k left in the bank
let me know what you guys think

 

[esorhali]

heres my team

Backs: Goddard, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Kennelly, Hunt (Maguire, Waters)

Mids: Ablett, Dal Santo, Vince, Martin, Barlow, Jetta (Shuey, Banner)

Rucks: Sandilands, Naitanui (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Reiwoldt, Pav, Buddy, Tippet, Hall, Dangerfield, Rockliff (Gumbleton, Podsiadly)

48k left in the bank
let me know what you guys think[/quote]

Back: very good. Risk with Waite but could pay off.
Mids: Cannot fault however check Vince..possible hamstring injury??
Standard good ruck combo
Forwards: Great fwd line...like it. Especially if Hall fires.


Here is mine..please comment. have been looking at coverage for MPP's.

Backs: Goddard, Kelly, Enright, Hurn, Malceski, ladson, Waters
(webberley, maguire)

Mids: ablett, Goodes, Didak, Hodge, barlow, Martin (Shuey, Banner)

Ruck: Clarke, Naitinui (warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Harvey, S.Johnson, Tippett, Higgins, Dangerfield, Rockcliff ( Posiadly, Hitchcock)

Concerned that I have loaded up too much in mid with Didak & Goodes and have risks in forward line with Harvey (old) and Johnson (injury).

responses will be appreciated

 

[FalcoX]

heres my team

Backs: Goddard, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Kennelly, Hunt (Maguire, Waters)

Mids: Ablett, Dal Santo, Vince, Martin, Barlow, Jetta (Shuey, Banner)

Rucks: Sandilands, Naitanui (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Reiwoldt, Pav, Buddy, Tippet, Hall, Dangerfield, Rockliff (Gumbleton, Podsiadly)

48k left in the bank
let me know what you guys think

Backs: First 4 are solid but not sure about Waite and Kennelly. Waite in particular is too big a risk imo.

Mid: 1 premium short and starting with three rookies is a little risky but if that's how you wanna go about it, I would start Shuey on the ground in place of Jetta.

Rucks: Same as mine except I have Skipper as 4th ruck since with Taylor down for a fair few months, his chances of being picked have increased. You might wanna look into him..

Fwd: Hall could go either way, let's hope for your sake he keeps up his NAB cup form and doesn't have another one of his brain snaps. Like the Podsiadly selection as he is likely to pay a few games this season. Not sure about starting Rockliff on the ground though...maybe trade Gumbleton for Rohan and have him start on field?

Overall, your team's looking pretty good

Here is mine:

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Ok so i have tweaked my team quite a bit:
In: Podsaidly, Krakouer, McPharlin, Watson, Lobbe
Out: Rockliff, Baker, Ballantyne, Vince, McEvoy

Im thinking of trading Chris Masten for Dalziel but i herd he will be playing the tagging role(and will he be a 22 game player?) or McViegh (has heaps to prove could be improver). Although Masten has been great in pre-season is this the year he blossoms?

Vince is not worth the risk although i will monitor his progress b4 rnd1, Watson will undoubtedly be the dons best player this seasonand he is a true leader with great blood.

McPharlin should improve on what was an off 2009. In years previous he has averaged 80+ in SC on 3 of 4 occasions including an 85+ season in '08 and will surely lift this season. I wanted franklin but cant fit him in.

Im sick of ppl pestering me about McEvoy on the bench and telling me to switch him to lobbe to you use the MPP rule, but for now i will keep him ther and i will see when the teams are released for rnd1 if he is selected and decide then.

BACKLINE
Drummond | Hodge | Kennelly | Krakouer | Malceski | Hunt | Ladson | Jamison | Waters
MIDFIELD
Selwood | Watson | Cooney | Ball | Masten | Trengove | Martin | Morabito
RUCKS
Jolly | Hille | Lobbe | Warnock
FOWARDS
Riewoldt | Brown | Tippett | Hall | Medhurst | Westhoff | McPharlin | Reid | Podsaidly

Riewoldt Captain and Selwood VC.

Tips will be much appreciated.

 

[Satan]

Backs: First 4 are solid but not sure about Waite and Kennelly. Waite in particular is too big a risk imo.

Mid: 1 premium short and starting with three rookies is a little risky but if that's how you wanna go about it, I would start Shuey on the ground in place of Jetta.

Rucks: Same as mine except I have Skipper as 4th ruck since with Taylor down for a fair few months, his chances of being picked have increased. You might wanna look into him..

Fwd: Hall could go either way, let's hope for your sake he keeps up his NAB cup form and doesn't have another one of his brain snaps. Like the Podsiadly selection as he is likely to pay a few games this season. Not sure about starting Rockliff on the ground though...maybe trade Gumbleton for Rohan and have him start on field?

Overall, your team's looking pretty good

Here is mine:

17 players the same as mine

Nic Nat as second ruck , depends on how much time cox stays on the ground and nic is either resting in the forward line or sitting on the bench.

buddy is suspended first week so you need one of your reserves to play, so make sure they are picked

maybe swap enright for josh hunt frees up 270000 and up grade dangerfield to a Goodes, Rok or J Brown

 

[Unknown Identity]

Very unique team. Nothing wrong with that.

My two cents:
Not a fan of Carrazzo but perhaps he could be a smokey. Pearce?? Isn't he on the rookie list??? Will he get promoted?? Will he score/get picked? Webberley won't be promoted I'm told.

You think Hill is up for a big year??? Could be but you'd want your 4th mid to score pretty heavily. Isn't robinson more of a negating player???

Rucks are OK.

Your 2 premium fwds are over priced. Better value with less risk out there for that sort of money IMO. Think Higgins will keep going this year?? Is Wright going to get a regular game?

Whoever told you that doesn't know much about Football.
Webberley is not a rookie, he was selection 67 in the national draft, not rookie draft. Will play games this year..

 

[Unknown Identity]

Ok so i have tweaked my team quite a bit:
In: Podsaidly, Krakouer, McPharlin, Watson, Lobbe
Out: Rockliff, Baker, Ballantyne, Vince, McEvoy

Im thinking of trading Chris Masten for Dalziel but i herd he will be playing the tagging role(and will he be a 22 game player?) or McViegh (has heaps to prove could be improver). Although Masten has been great in pre-season is this the year he blossoms?

Vince is not worth the risk although i will monitor his progress b4 rnd1, Watson will undoubtedly be the dons best player this seasonand he is a true leader with great blood.

McPharlin should improve on what was an off 2009. In years previous he has averaged 80+ in SC on 3 of 4 occasions including an 85+ season in '08 and will surely lift this season. I wanted franklin but cant fit him in.

Im sick of ppl pestering me about McEvoy on the bench and telling me to switch him to lobbe to you use the MPP rule, but for now i will keep him ther and i will see when the teams are released for rnd1 if he is selected and decide then.

BACKLINE
Drummond | Hodge | Kennelly | Krakouer | Malceski | Hunt | Ladson | Jamison | Waters
MIDFIELD
Selwood | Watson | Cooney | Ball | Masten | Trengove | Martin | Morabito
RUCKS
Jolly | Hille | Lobbe | Warnock
FOWARDS
Riewoldt | Brown | Tippett | Hall | Medhurst | Westhoff | McPharlin | Reid | Podsaidly

Riewoldt Captain and Selwood VC.

Tips will be much appreciated.

If your sick of people pestering you about a certain player, stop posting your team, or alternatively, if you have alot of people saying the exact same thing, maybe you should listen..????

Still, you have Jamison on your bench..? Why..? Can you shed some light on something the rest of us are incapable of seeing..? As far as most people can see, he is a supercoach spud. He scored a 2 and a 10 last season, played 13 odd games and still only averaged 36..? Maguire could easily average 36 and is ALOT less money, and by all reports training very well and scored 73 SC points in the NAB game against Carlton.

Swap Morabito for Barlow, you will save yourself 50K and Barlow will average 20-30 points more than him, yes he is a rookie, but he will be promoted prior to round 1.

I'll leave the McEvoy situation alone, obviously you are quite fond of him.

Ben Reid..???? Still..? really..?
Bring back Tom Rockliff for Ben Reid, he didn't score a 142 and a 94 for people to just ignore him, as a bench player, will play 10+ games and make you money, plus the 68K you save from that swap.

All up you should have approximately, $220K to use on upgrading players without even weakening your team to get it..? and you get to keep McEvoy..!

i heard Brent Harvey is training very well

 

[Baxter23]

Backs: First 4 are solid but not sure about Waite and Kennelly. Waite in particular is too big a risk imo.

Mid: 1 premium short and starting with three rookies is a little risky but if that's how you wanna go about it, I would start Shuey on the ground in place of Jetta.

Rucks: Same as mine except I have Skipper as 4th ruck since with Taylor down for a fair few months, his chances of being picked have increased. You might wanna look into him..

Fwd: Hall could go either way, let's hope for your sake he keeps up his NAB cup form and doesn't have another one of his brain snaps. Like the Podsiadly selection as he is likely to pay a few games this season. Not sure about starting Rockliff on the ground though...maybe trade Gumbleton for Rohan and have him start on field?

Overall, your team's looking pretty good

Here is mine:

This team is one of the better teams I have seen!

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Whoever told you that doesn't know much about Football.
Webberley is not a rookie, he was selection 67 in the national draft, not rookie draft. Will play games this year..

Hope you're right.

He certainly comes back into my team if he gets named rd 1.

 

[zan5hin]

Team version 4000
Posted on Bigfooty version 4

BACKS

• Yes Goodwin is old but I can't afford Goddard and he scores well. Coach says he is still super fit and impressive.
• O'Brien is a unique smokie who I think will improve 10-15 ppg this year.
• Malceski's poor form last year was not physical, but psychological so expect a bounce.
• Greenwood taking a tagging role in the midfield and with Lower's injury, should expect some good scores.
• Maguire hopefully starts round 1 and Silvagni looks like being elevated and playing 6 games at leasy.

MIDS

• Can't afford Ablett but Swan is consistent enough as Captain, with Selwood and Mitchell as backups.
• Luke Ball should improve his score with more TOG and prefer spending a bit more cash on proven ability rather than Armitage who has potential for similar price.
• Barlow, Banner and Shuey are the rookies I believe have shown decent sized bodies and the most hunger to play AFL this year after displays in the NAB.

RUCK

• Sandilands in there to balance the risk of NitNat. That risk is according to others, I think NicNat is a lock since that first NAB game, even with Cox on the ground (until he is injured) NicNat will still have heaps of TOG and will easily go up 125k just by his ability to get first hands on the ball let alone his crumbing and 1 percenters.

FWDS

• I would prefer Harvey over Franklin but I am short $200. I originally had Higgins there but changed it because of concerns about injuries. Still deciding.
• Dangerfield and Ziebell are both risks as only second year and not third year. Danger had an injury in the pre-season but up until then he didn't miss a training session, which is a lot better than his last pre-season. I expect him to play midfield and improve on his price. Ziebell has shown great in and under work in the NAB, and with Harvey and Anthony getting the tag, should score well.
• Walker I only put in recently after an article saying he will be playing more up the ground, that he has put on 10kg yet still maintained "mid-field like" time trials. Due to some shockers last year, hopefully he is underpriced.
• Rockliff and Hitchcock have shown the most of the forward rookies, of course I could replace Walker with Podsiadly however I am ambivalent about his NAB form.

 

[MR ESNDEN]

I think I have finalised till team news come closer... Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated!!!

 

[Hoosy]

Hi guys, some great feedback on the new MPP option but im still not sold on its value.

Hoping to get some feedback on my below team.

I have $154K in the bank and could have more $$$ (Morabito > Barlow) and wondering if upgrading Reid to Hall would be money best spent?

Any other feedback will be well received.
B- Goddard, H Shaw, Hodge, MacDonald, Kennelly, Malceski, Ladson (Maguire, J Trengrove)
C- Ablett, Mitchell, Cooney, McVeigh, Walker, Trengrove (Martin Morabito)
R- Jolly, Seaby (Warnock, Skipper)
F- Riewoldt, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell, Medhurst, Mayne, B Reid (Rockliff, Podsiadly)

Cheers

Pretty please, just 1 lil bit of feedback from anyone.........or even tear it to shreds? either or

 

[BlueGibbs2011]

Pretty please, just 1 lil bit of feedback from anyone.........or even tear it to shreds? either or

Mcviegh is on the nose for mine. Has fired up once only in the past couple of years for good scores. And even when he got these good scores, he got injured every second week. But if he is your top secret value pick, go for it, I have Andrew Walker from Carlton...could be accused of worse!

Think you have spent slightly too much money in the fwd line and mids to the detriment of your backs. You should keep only two of Mayne/Medhurst and Reid at best. Downgrade one and upgrade one of MacDonald, Kennelly, Malceski, Ladson. Upgrading Ladson, Kennelly or Maleceski will reduce your injury risk exposure which is quite high .

Martin and Morabito is too much money on the mid bench when there are other equal cash cows that cost less, e.g. Schuey from WCE. At least trade one down and help upgrade your weak defence.

Aside from that, rest looks good. Seaby may be good value this year, but I just couldnt have him in my team period! Guy is a crab!

 

[Hoosy]

Mcviegh is on the nose for mine. Has fired up once only in the past couple of years for good scores. And even when he got these good scores, he got injured every second week. But if he is your top secret value pick, go for it, I have Andrew Walker from Carlton...could be accused of worse!

Think you have spent slightly too much money in the fwd line and mids to the detriment of your backs. You should keep only two of Mayne/Medhurst and Reid at best. Downgrade one and upgrade one of MacDonald, Kennelly, Malceski, Ladson. Upgrading Ladson, Kennelly or Maleceski will reduce your injury risk exposure which is quite high .

Martin and Morabito is too much money on the mid bench when there are other equal cash cows that cost less, e.g. Schuey from WCE. At least trade one down and help upgrade your weak defence.

Aside from that, rest looks good. Seaby may be good value this year, but I just couldnt have him in my team period! Guy is a crab!

Cheers BG2011........Carlton/Collingwood coming together....... wow

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Team version 4000
Posted on Bigfooty version 4

BACKS

• Yes Goodwin is old but I can't afford Goddard and he scores well. Coach says he is still super fit and impressive.
• O'Brien is a unique smokie who I think will improve 10-15 ppg this year.
• Malceski's poor form last year was not physical, but psychological so expect a bounce.
• Greenwood taking a tagging role in the midfield and with Lower's injury, should expect some good scores.
• Maguire hopefully starts round 1 and Silvagni looks like being elevated and playing 6 games at leasy.

MIDS

• Can't afford Ablett but Swan is consistent enough as Captain, with Selwood and Mitchell as backups.
• Luke Ball should improve his score with more TOG and prefer spending a bit more cash on proven ability rather than Armitage who has potential for similar price.
• Barlow, Banner and Shuey are the rookies I believe have shown decent sized bodies and the most hunger to play AFL this year after displays in the NAB.

RUCK

• Sandilands in there to balance the risk of NitNat. That risk is according to others, I think NicNat is a lock since that first NAB game, even with Cox on the ground (until he is injured) NicNat will still have heaps of TOG and will easily go up 125k just by his ability to get first hands on the ball let alone his crumbing and 1 percenters.

FWDS

• I would prefer Harvey over Franklin but I am short $200. I originally had Higgins there but changed it because of concerns about injuries. Still deciding.
• Dangerfield and Ziebell are both risks as only second year and not third year. Danger had an injury in the pre-season but up until then he didn't miss a training session, which is a lot better than his last pre-season. I expect him to play midfield and improve on his price. Ziebell has shown great in and under work in the NAB, and with Harvey and Anthony getting the tag, should score well.
• Walker I only put in recently after an article saying he will be playing more up the ground, that he has put on 10kg yet still maintained "mid-field like" time trials. Due to some shockers last year, hopefully he is underpriced.
• Rockliff and Hitchcock have shown the most of the forward rookies, of course I could replace Walker with Podsiadly however I am ambivalent about his NAB form.

Try Clark over Sandi. That will give you some extra coin. Maybe McEvoy over NicNat too if you want Ablett....