Rate my Super Coach team part II

[Mr Mosquito]

another team to be picked apart by you guys..
love to hear your thoughts..
cheers

B: Enright, Shaw, Hodge, Adcock, Malceski, Ladson, Greenwood
(Roberton & Webberley)

M: Ablett, Dal Santo, Mitchell, Armitage/Burgoyne, Martin, Barlow
(Jetta & Banner)

R: Sandilands, Charman
(Lobbe & Trengove)

F: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, J.Brown, Franklin, Medhurst, Dennis-Lane
(Rockliff & Hitchcock)

I like your team but like all it has weaker areas.

I believe there is better priced players than Adcock for equal output. Unsure about Greenwoods scoring potential.

Charman is a risk as is not a guarentee to play each week.

Dennis-lane i a risk.....Andrew Moore is a good rookie option in the fwd line.

Here is my team........

I know that I am weaker in my backline....but i saw some great valued players in the backline and have selected them there and then loaded up in the fwd line to compensate......after all it doesnt matter where you score the points...as long as they are scored.

Backs: Goddard Drummond Hodge Maceski Ladson Nash Sheppard (Trengove, Davis)

Mids: Ablett Montagna Pendlebury Burgoyne Martin Trengove (Jetta, Shuey)

Rucks: Hille Tippett (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Goodes Riewoldt Brown Silvia Franklin Dangerfield Moore (Sumner, Dennis-Lane)

 

[murphy2bedabest]

The last 3 players starting in your backline would be lucky to make 70 a week.

Moles needs to be upgraded before he plays

Leuenberger too exey for the bench.

Dennis-Lane and Pods may struggle for consistent games, if at all.

With respect, your team stinks.

Martin > Cunnington and arguably Scully too.

just Moles Howard may be put on the LTI list, so you'd think he'd be promoted, but im just waiting to round 1 and im sure like many others their team will change.

I down graded Leuenberger for Skipper so i can add $$$ to my backline Adding Everitt and Greenwood


Ok i have or at other times had players like Goodes Pav Champman Ablett Goddard Riewoldt Buddy Hodge, now i ask should i be going for these players who have done it all before but may not move points wise that much, or go for players that may just take that next step and has more room to move.

plus what kinda break down should i have for Backs Mids Rucks and Forwards? should i try and spend a little less on my backline for an extra 1-2 players in the forward line and Mid?

 

[Absolute Gun]

Can you guys please tell me about this team.

Backs:
Drummond, Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Kennelly, Hunt, B. Waters
EMG: Maguire, Davis

Mids:
Selwood, Mitchell, Vince, Cooney, Armitage, Martin
EMG: Jetta, Bastinac

Rucks:
Sandilands, Tippett
EMG: Trengove, McNamara

Forwards:
Riewoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Medhurst, Rohan
EMG: Rockliff, Podsiadly


What you all think???

 

[HELLA BONG RIPS]

Backs: A bit sketchy in my opinion, is Mackie worthy of a third back position? Could be very up and down score wise. Also question marks over Maguire, although there really isn't many back rookies to choose from this year. Perhaps Webberly from Richmond?

Midfield: Very very solid, can't say a bad word about this part of your team.

Rucks: Not sure wether Charman will hold down a spot at Bris with Clark and Leuenburger but its a risk that might be worth taking.

Forwards: Not too sure bout Hall or Walker, and also will Brown score as well with Fev there? not too sure.

Alright then, what about this team...

DEF: Enright, Hodge, Cornes, Suban, Hunt, Ladson, Waters
EMG: Webberly, Silvagni

MID: Ablett, Swan, Goddard, Mitchell, Cooney, Martin
EMG: Cunnington, Shuey

RUCK: McIntosh, Charman
EMG: Warnock, Lobbe

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell, Medhurst, Gumbleton
EMG: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

Hunt/Ladson/Waters is a concern, I'm thinking about Malceski who looked pretty good vs Carlton. He's been pretty ordinary since his injury though.

On Charman, I reckon Brisbane may take it slow with lueunberger because of injury concerns and such, and charman will line up as 2nd ruck come round 1.

I rejigged my forward line around, but I'm not really too sure about it with Higgins and Gumbleton injury concerns, Franklin inconsistent and Ziebell coming off a broken leg.

Again, Any comments, suggestions or advice appreciated.

EDIT: How about this forward line?

FWD: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Tippett, Medhurst, Burton, Gumbleton
EMG: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

 

[TheGoatBaron]

Defenders:
Rhyce Shaw, Luke Hodge, Martin Mattner, Jacob Surjan, Tadhg Kennelly, Nic Suban, Nick Malceski. Res: Andrew Moore, Dylan Grimes

Midfield:
Gary Ablett, Shaun Higgins, Dayne Beams, Chris Masten, Clinton Young, Dustin Martin. Res: Anthony Morabito, Lewis Jetta.

Ruck:
Dean Cox, Jesse White. Res: Robert Warnock, Wayde Skipper

Forwards:
Adam Goodes, Ryan O'Keefe, Matthew Pavlich, Lance Franklin, Liam Jurrah, Ben Warren, Patrick Veszpremi. Res: Austin Wonaeamirri, Trent Dennis-Lane.

Want do you guys think?

 

[September 27 2008]

I think it's just a little too Sydney dominated.

4 sydney backs
1 mid
1 ruck
4 forwards

10 sydney players. A little over the top in my honest opinion.

Start again!!!

Edit: Or just add a few more. Why no Brett Kirk, Mark Seaby or Shane Mumford. There's always Ben McGlynn and Josh Kennedy

 

[murphy2bedabest]

Alright then, what about this team...

DEF: Enright, Hodge, Cornes, Suban, Hunt, Ladson, Waters
EMG: Webberly, Silvagni

MID: Ablett, Swan, Goddard, Mitchell, Cooney, Martin
EMG: Cunnington, Shuey

RUCK: McIntosh, Charman
EMG: Warnock, Lobbe

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell, Medhurst, Gumbleton
EMG: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

Hunt/Ladson/Waters is a concern, I'm thinking about Malceski who looked pretty good vs Carlton. He's been pretty ordinary since his injury though.

On Charman, I reckon Brisbane may take it slow with lueunberger because of injury concerns and such, and charman will line up as 2nd ruck come round 1.

I rejigged my forward line around, but I'm not really too sure about it with Higgins and Gumbleton injury concerns, Franklin inconsistent and Ziebell coming off a broken leg.

Again, Any comments, suggestions or advice appreciated.

EDIT: How about this forward line?

FWD: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Tippett, Medhurst, Burton, Gumbleton
EMG: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

what injury concerns? he is fit and firing, and shouold have a great 2010 a keeper

 

[Texy]

What do you think? First Draft.

DEF: B Goddard, L Hodge, G Urquhart, T Kennelly, R Hayden, M Nicoski, A Everitt
RES: M Maguire, J Lisle

MID: G Ablett, J Bartel, M Boyd, B Vince, A Cooney, A Morabito
RES: L Jetta, R Bastinac

RUCK: D Jolly, N Natanui
RES: R Stanley, M Lobbe

FWD: A Goodes, N Riewoldt, L Franklin, K Tippett, P Medhurst, G Rohan, T Rockliff
RES: R Tarrant, Dennis-Lane

Do you think the Geelong double in the midfield and the Dogs double will work? Is Urqhuart injured again and if so for how long? Opinions please.

Thanks.

 

[Hot Tiges]

Alright then, what about this team...

DEF: Enright, Hodge, Cornes, Suban, Hunt, Ladson, Waters
EMG: Webberly, Silvagni

MID: Ablett, Swan, Goddard, Mitchell, Cooney, Martin
EMG: Cunnington, Shuey

RUCK: McIntosh, Charman
EMG: Warnock, Lobbe

FWD: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Ziebell, Medhurst, Gumbleton
EMG: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

Hunt/Ladson/Waters is a concern, I'm thinking about Malceski who looked pretty good vs Carlton. He's been pretty ordinary since his injury though.

On Charman, I reckon Brisbane may take it slow with lueunberger because of injury concerns and such, and charman will line up as 2nd ruck come round 1.

I rejigged my forward line around, but I'm not really too sure about it with Higgins and Gumbleton injury concerns, Franklin inconsistent and Ziebell coming off a broken leg.

Again, Any comments, suggestions or advice appreciated.

EDIT: How about this forward line?

FWD: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Tippett, Medhurst, Burton, Gumbleton
EMG: Dennis-Lane, Podsiadly

For the last 2 seasons, Cornes has stuffed me so I ain't going near him this year.Suban is a big call, 2nd year player who looked ok last year but was overshadowed by Hill.

Plenty of cash in the midfield, one of Swan or Goddard will fall in cash I would suspect..

Rucks ok, although the usual write up on Charman etc.. HMac not a bad pick either..

Good forward line, though Higgins who was great value last year may just be a little pricey..I could be wrong. Gumbleton?? No way, it's like picking Rusling..

My line-up partII

Goddard, Enright, Shaw, Hodge, Kennelly, Greenwood, Maguire(Lisle,Silvagni)

Ablett, Mitchell, Gibbs, Cooney, Martin, Barlow (Jetta, Banner)

Sandilands, Hille (Lobbe, 83k)

Riewoldt, ROK, Pavlich, Le Cras, Dangerfield, Ziebell, Rockcliff (TDL, Podsa)

Still fiddling away. Thinking about Kennelly's output with Sydney's other running backs, Greenwood VS Ladson/Hunt.. Midfield of either Mitchell/Dal Santo or Gibbs/ Pendlebury. Rucks either Hille/Seaby and fwds Le Cras /Tippett.. Obviously going to look at Rockcliff's next couple of games too..

Penny for your thoughts guys??

 

[Hot Tiges]

What do you think? First Draft.

DEF: B Goddard, L Hodge, G Urquhart, T Kennelly, R Hayden, M Nicoski, A Everitt
RES: M Maguire, J Lisle

MID: G Ablett, J Bartel, M Boyd, B Vince, A Cooney, A Morabito
RES: L Jetta, R Bastinac

RUCK: D Jolly, N Natanui
RES: R Stanley, M Lobbe

FWD: A Goodes, N Riewoldt, L Franklin, K Tippett, P Medhurst, G Rohan, T Rockliff
RES: R Tarrant, Dennis-Lane

Do you think the Geelong double in the midfield and the Dogs double will work? Is Urqhuart injured again and if so for how long? Opinions please.

Thanks.

Huge risk in the backline.. First of all, Nicoski?? I think he has peaked and that was a while back! I like the selection of Hayden though, looks like he was pretty fit on Sunday. I personally like mixing up the teams in the midfield.. just a quirk of mine but you have a nice midfield. People have gone off Vince after 1 NAB cup game.. Maybe get a Warnock/Skipper for backup for Natinui, although I do see you have Tippett in the fwds. Rohan and Rockliff both starting?? hmm, not too sure.. find some extra cash and get Benny Warren in there..Possibly Vince > Burgoyne to allow the Warren purchase..

 

[wintercookes]

what do you think

defence: enright shaw fisher hodge mackie malceski ladson sheppard webberly

midfield: pendlebury watson cooney boak martain barlow jetta sheuy

rucks: sandilands tippet warnock trengove

foward: riewoldt pavlich johnson franklin murphy medhurt rockliff gumb lobbe

like some advise....

 

[turbo_mixer]

Hey guys,
im new to this so was just wondering if u can give me ur thoughts on my team.

Backs – C.Enright, S.Gilbert, H.Shaw, M.Drum, L.Greenwood, B.Shepperd. emergencies – r.henderson, m.maguire.
Mids – L.Montagna, L.Hayes, J.Selwood, L.Ball, S.Burgoune, J.Trengrove, emergencies - L.Shuey, D.Martin
Rucks – A.Sandilands, D. Hille, emergencies - J.Charman, M.Lobbe
Fwds – M.Pavlich, J.Brown, C.Rioli, J.Koschitske, R.Murphy P.Dangerfield, B.Birton, emergencies – C.Hitchcock, L. Markovic
Cheers

 

[abakus]

backs: goddard, h swaw, hodge, o'brian, kennelly, m mcguire, shepheard. ints: p davis, m davies

mids: ablett, murphy, pendlebury, vince, cooney, trengrove. ints: d martin, l schuey

rucks: tippett, hille. ints: trengrove, fitzpatrick

forwds: riewoldt, o'keefe, franklin, dangerfield. ziebell. medhurst, g rohan. ints: gumbleton, tapscott

Thoughts? Advice?

 

[Unknown Identity]

backs: goddard, h swaw, hodge, o'brian, kennelly, m mcguire, shepheard. ints: p davis, m davies

mids: ablett, murphy, pendlebury, vince, cooney, trengrove. ints: d martin, l schuey

rucks: tippett, hille. ints: trengrove, fitzpatrick

forwds: riewoldt, o'keefe, franklin, dangerfield. ziebell. medhurst, g rohan. ints: gumbleton, tapscott

Thoughts? Advice?

Backs - Starting both Maguire and Sheppard is a huge risk, a risk not many would be willing to take. Chances of both not being selected in a round could leave you in trouble, especially considering your bench players are no certainty to get games. I'd rethink this strategy.

Midfield - Where you've spent less money in the backs, its obvious its gone into your midfield. This midfield looks fantastic, but have you created too many deficiencies elsewhere..?

Rucks - good combo i've seen alot of teams use.

Forwards - Riewoldt and O'Keefe are SC guns, Franklin is set for a big year, after round 1 of course. 3 Cash cows in danger, Ziebell and Medders, just watch if Rohan lines up round 1, and if your keen on him, make sure your bench players look like getting games.

Overall, its not a bad team, but some alterations should be made to minimise scoring 0's..!

Good luck..

 

[Unknown Identity]

well this is the cheap ruck strategy..
not sure how well it would work, but let me know your thoughts on this team.
Thanks guys..

B: Newman, Enright, Shaw, Hodge, Bower, Malceski, Davis
(Roberton & Webberley)

M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Mitchell, Burgoyne, Martin, Barlow
(Jetta & Banner)

R: Hille, Charman
(Trengove & Lobbe)

F: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Brown, Higgins, Franklin, Dennis-Lane
(Rockliff & Hitchcock)

 

[echelon]

Hey guys,

This is my first SuperCoach so I would really appreciate some feedback on this team:

BACKS
Goddard, Hodge, Shaw, Kennelly, Waite, Hunt, Ladson (P Davis, Maguire)

MIDS
Abblett, Selwood, Martin, Murphy, Masten, Barlow (Jetta, Trengrove)

RUCKS
Tippett, Kreuzer (Charman, Lobbe)

FORWARDS
Riewoldt, Franklin, LeCras, Ziebell, Higgins, Dangerfield, Podsiadly (Rohan, Gumbleton)

Cash left over - $20,500

Thanks!!

 

[Unknown Identity]

Echelon

Well there are previous posters who would also appreciate some comments on their team, try contributing to the thread before just randomly posting your team and expecting people to give you advice..?

Two Thumbs down..

 

[echelon]

Echelon

Well there are previous posters who would also appreciate some comments on their team, try contributing to the thread before just randomly posting your team and expecting people to give you advice..?

Two Thumbs down..

Given this is my first time at Supercoach and my general lack of knowledge about AFL I don't feel i'm qualified to opine on other people's teams...

 

[Hondo]

I think we can give first timers a break from rating other's teams.

Do you want your team rated by a first timer ideally?

 

[Hondo]

Hey guys,

This is my first SuperCoach so I would really appreciate some feedback on this team:

BACKS
Goddard, Hodge, Shaw, Kennelly, Waite, Hunt, Ladson (P Davis, Maguire)

MIDS
Abblett, Selwood, Martin, Murphy, Masten, Barlow (Jetta, Trengrove)

RUCKS
Tippett, Kreuzer (Charman, Lobbe)

FORWARDS
Riewoldt, Franklin, LeCras, Ziebell, Higgins, Dangerfield, Podsiadly (Rohan, Gumbleton)

Cash left over - $20,500

Thanks!!

That's a pretty good team actually

Murphy has injury issues and I think is missing some early games so leave him as an upgrade target. There's other good options at his price.

You could consider Harvey or Pavlich instead of LeCras or Higgins but that's up to you.

I'd swap Charman on the bench for a rookie if you can find one you like. Save yourself $70K.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Hey guys,

This is my first SuperCoach so I would really appreciate some feedback on this team:

BACKS
Goddard, Hodge, Shaw, Kennelly, Waite, Hunt, Ladson (P Davis, Maguire)

MIDS
Abblett, Selwood, Martin, Murphy, Masten, Barlow (Jetta, Trengrove)

RUCKS
Tippett, Kreuzer (Charman, Lobbe)

FORWARDS
Riewoldt, Franklin, LeCras, Ziebell, Higgins, Dangerfield, Podsiadly (Rohan, Gumbleton)

Cash left over - $20,500

Thanks!!

Good backline... Maybe a starting Rookie for one of waite, kennelly, Ladson, Hunt??

Use that cash to upgrade one of your mids. I probably wouldn't be starting two rookies.

Interesting rucks. probably some value in them both as they'll probably play nearly every game and injury isn't a huge concern for these two.


Solid mids combination. I like Higgins a lot but will he do much improving?? Probably not and he's sure to get a lot more attention this year. If you think he's going to go through the roof keep him but i don't see it.

 

[Hondo]

well this is the cheap ruck strategy..
not sure how well it would work, but let me know your thoughts on this team.
Thanks guys..

B: Newman, Enright, Shaw, Hodge, Bower, Malceski, Davis
(Roberton & Webberley)

M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Mitchell, Burgoyne, Martin, Barlow
(Jetta & Banner)

R: Hille, Charman
(Trengove & Lobbe)

F: Riewoldt, O'Keefe, Pavlich, Brown, Higgins, Franklin, Dennis-Lane
(Rockliff & Hitchcock)

I think you've spent up too big in your forwards to the detriment of your rucks. I'd definitely find a value pick up forward instread of a premium and fix your rucks. I think you'll be cursing those 2 rucks by round 4.

Starting a rookie in defence this season is a very risky move IMO.

You've got some big names in there but the team is unbalanced I think.

 

[full on the fence]

Your thoughts ???

B: Enright, Duffield, Maxwell, Adcock, Raines, Mcguire (J Allen-StK, J Blight-Coll)
M: Ablett, J Selwood, Boyd, McVeigh, Trengrove, D Martin (Morabito, L Jetta)
Rucks: Petrie, Ottens - Warnock, Skipper
F: Riewoldt, O'keefe, Pav, Lecras, Ziebell, Medhurst, Talia - Rockliff, Macaffer

 

[Unknown Identity]

I think you've spent up too big in your forwards to the detriment of your rucks. I'd definitely find a value pick up forward instread of a premium and fix your rucks. I think you'll be cursing those 2 rucks by round 4.

Starting a rookie in defence this season is a very risky move IMO.

You've got some big names in there but the team is unbalanced I think.

Thats why it was called the "cheap ruck strategy"
And if it would work..?
Anyways, thanks for your thoughts..

 

[Unknown Identity]

Your thoughts ???

B: Enright, Duffield, Maxwell, Adcock, Raines, Mcguire (J Allen-StK, J Blight-Coll)
M: Ablett, J Selwood, Boyd, McVeigh, Trengrove, D Martin (Morabito, L Jetta)
Rucks: Petrie, Ottens - Warnock, Skipper
F: Riewoldt, O'keefe, Pav, Lecras, Ziebell, Medhurst, Talia - Rockliff, Macaffer

Backs - Duffield and Maxwell are unique choices as most teams posted here don't have either in. Duffield is a great SC player, not sure about the selection of maxwell, especially when you have Fisher at the same price..? Raines and Maguire both on the field is a huge risk, both not guaranteed to play and same again with your emergencies, neither look like getting games early..?

Midfield - Ablett, Selwood and Boyd all a good selections.. Which Mcveigh, not that it really matters because i wouldn't go with either, if its jarrad, maybe go with Bernie Vince instead, if its Mark, Maybe look at Masten..?
Trengove does not look ready at all, and forget Morabito, if Barlow gets promoted off the rookie list, swap those two and use the money elsewhere.

Rucks are risky - petrie is out round 1 and ottens is very very injury prone..!

Forwards - Like your forwards alot, not sure about Talia getting a game, don't think he was even selected for the practice match in Alice springs..? Look at players like Dennis-Lane, Hitchcock, Tarrant etc.. or who plays well for the rest of the pre season comp.

Not too shabby, but you can definately improve..