Rate my SuperCoach team 2010

[thomas_m18]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Hey, just putting my supercoach team out there, all tips helpful, I performed alright last year, hope this year is no exception.

DEF: Enright, Fisher, Hodge, Kennelly, Hunt, Ladson, Sheppard
RES: Maguire, Davis

MID: Ablett, Pendelbury, Vince, Gram, Burgoyne, Martin
RES: Lucas, Winmar (Saints fan bias, however not many saints on this team)

RUCK: Clark, Tippett
RES: Charman, Jackson Trengrove

FWD: O'Keefe, Pavlich, Fevola, Waite, Murphy, Henderson, Polak
RES: Dennis-Lane, Tapscott (Sorta crummy FWD line, I know. Risky, but you gotta take risks in SC.

I think this team looks alright, but I ain't exactly an expert.

By the way, $0 LEFT. I'm proud of that

 

[jd2006]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Very good back-mid-ruck, forward line the cash may have been starting to run thin but the other 3 areas would carry them to a good score

 

[thomas_m18]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Very good back-mid-ruck, forward line the cash may have been starting to run thin but the other 3 areas would carry them to a good score

If you are talking to me, I understand my forward line is sorta, well, risky. But I think Lachie, Robert and Polak could pay off, and Waite was a big pointscorer last year (until his injury)

More tips for my team from anyone would be awesome

 

[jd2006]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

If you are talking to me, I understand my forward line is sorta, well, risky. But I think Lachie, Robert and Polak could pay off, and Waite was a big pointscorer last year (until his injury)

More tips for my team from anyone would be awesome

Yeah forgot to quote. Like I said you first 3 positions is very strong Henderson and Polak huge risks, if Waite plays rd 1 he is a good value pick up same with Murphy

 

[Borrus]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Hey guys I'm new to bigfoty, although I have been posting on fanfooty for the last couple of years so I have a pretty decent idea of what I'm saying, lets get into it.
Looks like a pretty good team thomas maybe you could put Tipett up forward up forward and get rid of polak then put maybe hill or white as your second ruck. If you get Matty Lobbe in your ruck reserve then if hille backfires you can swap lobbe and tippett and put hill on the pine until you can trade him. That way you won't have polak who is to big a risk for me

 

[mds00]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Bit of a rough effort considering NAB Cup hasn't started but anyway my side:

BACKS - Drummond, Hodge, J.Kelly, Waite, Suban, Ladson, Greenwood, Davis, Shepheard

MIDS - Selwood, Gibbs, Vince, Kerr, Dalziell, Trengrove, Sheuy, Bastinac

RUCK - Tippet, Kruezer, Warnock, J.Trengrove

FWDS - Goodes, Riewoldt, Franklin, Gia, Monfries, R.Murphy, Rohan, Gumbleton, Podsiadly

Really struggled late with Murphy and Rohan. Also not sure on all the kids til after the NAB Cup but any feedback would be great

Your keepers look fine how they are but perhaps downgrading the likes of Suban and Dalziell and using them to upgrade Greenwood/Ladson and Kerr. Also personally I wouldn't have both Gia and Murphy in the same side as they're a bit up and down.


My side currently:

BACK- Goddard, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Kennelly, Ladson, Sheppard (Davis, Davies)

MID- Swan, Sewell, Selwood, Vince, Trengove, Martin (Bastinac, Banner)

RUCK- Tippett, Hille (Gawn, McNamara)

FWD- Roo, Harvey, ROK, Franklin, Dangerfield, Gumbleton, Rohan (Lobbe, Podsiadly)

 

[jd2006]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Your keepers look fine how they are but perhaps downgrading the likes of Suban and Dalziell and using them to upgrade Greenwood/Ladson and Kerr. Also personally I wouldn't have both Gia and Murphy in the same side as they're a bit up and down.


My side currently:

BACK- Goddard, Newman, Enright, Hodge, Kennelly, Ladson, Sheppard (Davis, Davies)

MID- Swan, Sewell, Selwood, Vince, Trengove, Martin (Bastinac, Banner)

RUCK- Tippett, Hille (Gawn, McNamara)

FWD- Roo, Harvey, ROK, Franklin, Dangerfield, Gumbleton, Rohan (Lobbe, Podsiadly)

Good side still a great unknown if all those kids will play rd1. I swapped Rohan with Wonemerri (sp?) and R.Murhpy for Buchanan and swapped Shuey for Lucas. At this stage I've been keeping the young guys on the bench but once the sides are named rd 1 I'll bring in some more and then look to upgrade some of the mid-tier players.

And for the 3rd year running I'm going to make the call that this is Kerr's year haha

 

[Borrus]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Just quikly mds I have seen a fair bit of podsialdy in the vfl the last few years and he looks like a good enough player just I hitnk he may have trouble breaking into the geelong side, or atleast not enough to be considered in your team

 

[Borrus]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

my first crack here boys let me know what you think, I know the backs and ruck are weak but That can Be helped

DEF- Goddard, Hodge, Drummond, S.Fisher(stk), HUnt, Ladson, Sheppard. EMG M.Maguire, J. Trengrove

MIDS- Ablett, Hayes, Vince, Cooney, Dangerfield, Scully. EMG L.Shuey, R. Bastinac

RUC- Hille, White EMG Warnock, Lobbe

FWD- Roo, Harvey, Franklin, Tippett, Rioli, Henderson, Butcher EMG Talia, Gumbleton

 

[Yoda_]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

OK, just done a rough team; here goes:

BACKS:

Brendon Goddard
Greg Broughton
Shannon Hurn
Michael Hurley
Nick Suban
Levi Greenwood
Brad Sheppard
---------------
Phil Davis
Ashley Smith

MIDS:

Gary Ablett
Leigh Montagna
Jobe Watson
Callan Ward
Chris Masten
Jack Trengove
---------------
Dustin Martin
Luke Shuey

RUCKS:

David Hille
Todd Goldstein
--------------
Robert Warnock
Wayde Skipper

FORWARDS:

Nick Riewoldt
Shaun Higgins
Lance Franklin
Jarrad Waite
Josh Kennedy
Robert Murphy
James Polkinghorne
------------------
Scott Gumbleton
Trent Dennis-Lane

Have got a feeling that (Wayde) Skipper will play due to Bailey out and the underdevelopment of the other young Hawks.

Levi Greenwood in the backs is interesting, played as a tagger last year and did a reasonable job, however looking for him to become a bit more proactive this year.

Feel like I am a star short in the forwards, however feel like I got some steals with Franklin ($466,700) and Waite ($407,500). Hopefully Kennedy comes on too.

Alot of talk coming out of Brisbane that Polkinghorne is going to be a player, and with that in mind, am going to give him a go.

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated, thanks guys

 

[Yoda_]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

my first crack here boys let me know what you think, I know the backs and ruck are weak but That can Be helped

DEF- Goddard, Hodge, Drummond, S.Fisher(stk), HUnt, Ladson, Sheppard. EMG M.Maguire, J. Trengrove

MIDS- Ablett, Hayes, Vince, Cooney, Dangerfield, Scully. EMG L.Shuey, R. Bastinac

RUC- Hille, White EMG Warnock, Lobbe

FWD- Roo, Harvey, Franklin, Tippett, Rioli, Henderson, Butcher EMG Talia, Gumbleton

Ok, bit tall up front in the forwards. Rookie talls always take time (unlessthey are exceptional circa Michael Hurley 2009 ). So tip to drop Talia, Henderson and Butcher for some more smaller types that may play, I think Tapscott may surprise a few this year, he would be my best bet.

Mids seem good same as rucks. backs are solid also.

 

[thomas_m18]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

I am just thinking, is Lachie Henderson a player worth keeping on my team? Will he get the gametime and the goals to warrant his price tag? He looks like a risk worth taking to me, same with Polak, but I wanna back it up with other opinions.

 

[Bada Bing!]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

my first crack here boys let me know what you think, I know the backs and ruck are weak but That can Be helped

DEF- Goddard, Hodge, Drummond, S.Fisher(stk), HUnt, Ladson, Sheppard. EMG M.Maguire, J. Trengrove

MIDS- Ablett, Hayes, Vince, Cooney, Dangerfield, Scully. EMG L.Shuey, R. Bastinac

RUC- Hille, White EMG Warnock, Lobbe

FWD- Roo, Harvey, Franklin, Tippett, Rioli, Henderson, Butcher EMG Talia, Gumbleton

Not a bad first up shot!

Backs aren't weak, although they are kinda injury prone. For instance, last year was the first time Drummond played over 14 games in a season in his career, while Hunt and Ladson are both coming back from LTI's. It will be interesting to see how Goose is used at his new home, however he isnt too far off the other two as was out for the best part of the last 3 seasons with injury.

Mids - sexy.

Rucks will be interesting. Hille apparently played well yesterday in the intra-club, however since Ryders emergence as a star, it will be interesting to see how much time he spends on the ball. With Essendons young KPF's coming through, his scoring may be limited by being rested on the bench as opposed to down forward. Your other 3 rucks are all chances of playing the majority of the season, however doubt any will be consistently high enough to start in your 22. This could the difference in a close game.

Forwards are probably one elite short. Boomer Im not convinced on. You have to keep in mind that Buddy is out for Round 1 too. Plus will Butcher come straight in to Ports first 18? Wouldnt be surprised of he spends some time in the SANFL to start with.

Anyhoo, feel free to disregard anything Ive written above if you dont agree with it. Hope it helps in some way.


My first draft (of 12,679 more to come before lockout):

Backs: Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Waite, Kennelly, Hunt, Sheppard (P.Davis, J.Trengove)

Mids: S.Pendlebury, J.Selwood, B.Gibbs, B.Deledio, C.Masten, D.Martin (J.Trengove, R.Bastinac)

Rucks: A.Sandilands, M.Kruezer (J.Lobbe, D.Currie)

Forwards: N.Riewoldt, M.Pavlich, L.Franklin, P.Dangerfield, L.Henderson, J.Polkinghorne, S.Gumbleton (R.Tarrant, L.Tapscott)

Any thoughts appreciated.

 

[Bada Bing!]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

I am just thinking, is Lachie Henderson a player worth keeping on my team? Will he get the gametime and the goals to warrant his price tag? He looks like a risk worth taking to me, same with Polak, but I wanna back it up with other opinions.

Im going to take the punt on Henderson (pre-season form withstanding). As much as it pains me to say it, he has a classy midfield sending the ball his way which is what you want. And I know some people are saying that Waite may be used at CHF occasionally which may lessen his scoring potential, but I think that you wont find many better options at his price that are seemingly locked into their teams best 22 and have the potential to become focal points of such a midfield and mature another $100-150k.

Polak I wouldnt bother with. He is looking good early on, however he is also on the rookie list so that may come back to bite you in some form. Plus I dont know how Hardwick sees a 27y.o rookie fitting into our next premiership team, so opportunities may be only as a secondary option to Riewoldt Mk II.

 

[Big Bad Buddy]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Just wondering if i should keep Ziebell in my midfield or put Martin on starting so i can free up money to boost up other parts in my team

 

[Unknown Identity]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Thanks for the comments , your ideas were similar to what i was thinking may be the issues I will show u changes I've made and see what you think : -


Now it looks like this: -

Backs -
Enright
Hurn
Hodge
Kennelly
J. Hunt
Sheppard
Davis
(Lisle)
(Robertson)

Mids -
Ablett
Swan
DelSanto
J Selwood
S Burgoyne
J Trengrove
(Blease)
(Bastinac)

Rucks -
Clark
Hill
(Skipper)
(Lobbe)

Forwards -
Goodes
Didak
Harvey
Fevola
LeCras
Wonaeamirri
J Watts
(Gumbleton)
(Podsiadly)


do you think there are too many risks in the mix there? perhaps I should downgrade a few players and upgrade some rookies... but given that last year the 200-300K range players let me down and I had luck with Grima, Broughton, Beams, etc. from the start I'm hoping somethinglike that happens again! Any feedback appreciated

I like the risk's in the backline as both Sheppard and Davis are being talked up this year as definet starters. Alot of guys are taking the 2 rookies in the midfield approach, no reason why you can't do it with your backline, and considering most of your points come from the midfield i like the approach.
By Far the best midfield that i have seen, without impacting too heavily on another area. Burgoyne and Trengove would be both upgraded throughout the season.

Great balance in the forward line, especially if Wona gets fit. Fingers crosssed.

One of the better teams i've seen. You'll be right amongst it..!
Good luck bro.

 

[thomas_m18]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Im going to take the punt on Henderson (pre-season form withstanding). As much as it pains me to say it, he has a classy midfield sending the ball his way which is what you want. And I know some people are saying that Waite may be used at CHF occasionally which may lessen his scoring potential, but I think that you wont find many better options at his price that are seemingly locked into their teams best 22 and have the potential to become focal points of such a midfield and mature another $100-150k.

Polak I wouldnt bother with. He is looking good early on, however he is also on the rookie list so that may come back to bite you in some form. Plus I dont know how Hardwick sees a 27y.o rookie fitting into our next premiership team, so opportunities may be only as a secondary option to Riewoldt Mk II.

Yeah, Waite was a cheap option, considering potential compared to others his price, and I am prepared to switch him out right before the comp, if need be.

With Polak, I have heard good things about his preseason, and at his price, I thought he was a steal. I'm not sure if that means much, but I'll go with him for a couple of weeks before the head-to-head start. At under 250 grand, his experience and what I have heard from his preseason, I'll take a risk with him. If he plays, as long as he gets a respectible point score, his value should go up, making a sale attractive if need be.

http://www.watoday.com.au/afl/afl-news/cousins-is-the-leader-of-a-new-tiger-pack-20100128-n0rw.html

There is an article there saying good things about Polak, but whether that will be a factor or not is yet to been.

 

[Yoda_]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Ok, tinkered with the team a little bit.

A bit stronger now.

Goddard
Broughton or Goodwin
Hurn
Hurley
Suban
Ladson
Sheppard
P.Davis*
A.Smith*

Ablett
Montagna
Watson
Masten
Jack Redden
Jack Trengove
Martin*
Shuey*

Hille
Goldstein
Skipper*
Warnock*

Riewoldt
L.Davis
Higgins
Rioli
Waite
Robert Murphy
Gumbleton
Dennis-Lane*
Tapscott*

what do people think??

 

[Big Bad Buddy]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Alright, after stuffing around a bit i have got my team that i am thinking about going into with:

Backs:
Luke Hodge
Jed Adcock
Lindsey Gilbee
Andrew Mackie
Harry Taylor
Jarrad Waite
Michael Hurley
Matthew Maguire
Jeromey Webberley


Midfield:
Adam Cooney
Shaun Higgins
Daniel Rich
David Mackay
Shaun Burgoyne
Jack Trengrove
Dustin Martin
Daniel McNeil

Rucks:
Aaron Sandilands
Kurt Tippett
Wayde Skipper
Matthew Lobbe

Forward:
Johno Brown
Brendan Fevola
Lance Franklin
Cyril Rioli
Robert Murphy
Paul Medhurst
Gary Rohan
Scott Gumbleton
Trent Dennis Lane

Any advice on my team, i think it's alright.

 

[theCATSfromHELL]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Ok, tinkered with the team a little bit.

A bit stronger now.

Goddard
Broughton or Goodwin
Hurn
Hurley
Suban
Ladson
Sheppard
P.Davis*
A.Smith*

Ablett
Montagna
Watson
Masten
Jack Redden
Jack Trengove
Martin*
Shuey*

Hille
Goldstein
Skipper*
Warnock*

Riewoldt
L.Davis
Higgins
Rioli
Waite
Robert Murphy
Gumbleton
Dennis-Lane*
Tapscott*

what do people think??

I like.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Alright, after stuffing around a bit i have got my team that i am thinking about going into with:

Backs:
Luke Hodge
Jed Adcock
Lindsey Gilbee
Andrew Mackie
Harry Taylor
Jarrad Waite
Michael Hurley
Matthew Maguire
Jeromey Webberley


Midfield:
Adam Cooney
Shaun Higgins
Daniel Rich
David Mackay
Shaun Burgoyne
Jack Trengrove
Dustin Martin
Daniel McNeil

Rucks:
Aaron Sandilands
Kurt Tippett
Wayde Skipper
Matthew Lobbe

Forward:
Johno Brown
Brendan Fevola
Lance Franklin
Cyril Rioli
Robert Murphy
Paul Medhurst
Gary Rohan
Scott Gumbleton
Trent Dennis Lane

Any advice on my team, i think it's alright.

I wouldn't say i'm an expert but it's a very even team across the board. You've certainly shopped pretty well.

What you have is a few premiums, a few underperformed premiums from last year and quite a number of mid-ranged players. What it lacks are a few more players that can consistently score 100 points per week with the occasional huge scores. Unfortunately you need to bite the bullet and pay a premium for those types but they can at least provide you a solid captain score every week with minimal risk. Looking at your team, picking a captain would be nearly a nightmare for me each week.

I feel it could go two ways. Your underperformed premiums from last year will return to their best with a number of your mid ranged players having break out season which will make the team quite strong. That would be best case scenario. On the other hand, if your mid-ranged players don't step up and continue to score between 70 - 90 then you will be left will some pretty tough trade decisions.

Not sure how much you have left in the bank, but have you thought about a trades strategy? You only have 20 of them and they need to give you bang for buck!

My team (early draft)

DEFENDERS: H.Shaw, S.Fisher, L.Hodge, L.Gilbee, L.Hansen, T.Kennelly, R.Ladson, (P.Davis, J.Trengove)

MIDFIELDERS: J.Bartel, M.Boyd, J.Lewis, A.Cooney, J.Trengove, D.Martin, (R.Bastinac, K.Stevens)

RUCKS: P.Ryder, K.Tippett, (R.Warnock, M.Lobbe)

FORWARDS: A.Goodes, B.Harvey, J.Brennan, L.Franklin, P.Dangerfield, J.Ziebell, B.Warren, (T.Dennis-Lane, L.Tapscott)

74k in the bank.

Thoughts?

 

[tim_saints]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Heres the team I'm sticking with for a while.

Backs- Goddard, Enright, Lake, Hodge, Ladson, Maguire, Sheppard.

EMG: A.Moore and A.Silvagni

Mids- Hayes, Corey, Vince, Pavlich, Cooney, Cunnington.

EMG: L.Jetta, J.Dyson

Rucks- Ottens, Hille

EMG: W.Skipper, S.Mcnamarra

Forwards- N.Riewoldt, J.Brown, A.Goodes, Knights, Rioli, Medhurst, Gumbleton

EMG: Dennis-Lane, T.Walsh

To me I think that's a side that could go a long way the only weak point is Maguire in my mind but at 114,000 if he snags 70 a week with the odd 90 I would be a happy man.

Sheppard, Cunnington are both supposed to be young stars that are really setting the pace. Gumby is fit and firing at the moment and that can't be ignored at $100,000.

Tell me what you guys think of the side?

 

[inter09]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

I wouldn't say i'm an expert but it's a very even team across the board. You've certainly shopped pretty well.


My team (early draft)

DEFENDERS: H.Shaw, S.Fisher, L.Hodge, L.Gilbee, L.Hansen, T.Kennelly, R.Ladson, (P.Davis, J.Trengove)

MIDFIELDERS: J.Bartel, M.Boyd, J.Lewis, A.Cooney, J.Trengove, D.Martin, (R.Bastinac, K.Stevens)

RUCKS: P.Ryder, K.Tippett, (R.Warnock, M.Lobbe)

FORWARDS: A.Goodes, B.Harvey, J.Brennan, L.Franklin, P.Dangerfield, J.Ziebell, B.Warren, (T.Dennis-Lane, L.Tapscott)

74k in the bank.

Thoughts?

Def; i like your star backs, couple similar to mine, shaw scares me off a bit with his inabililty to break a tag? not sure about hansen? perhaps you could keep kennelly and ladson, trade hansen down to shepard or Moore from port and start them, use that extra cash in midfield?

Mids; i like to have ablett to start..just my opinion..lewis and cooney could be bargains after both having great preseasons...im also starting two rookies so i like that move and the ones you've chosen...still maybe you could do like i said and downgrade hansen to rookie in backline and bring in ablett for bartel? not sure about boyd, i dont know just not a big fan, tho he scores so well and is unique!

rucks: tippet good pickup, i like warnock and lobbe off the bench surely one of them will play each week...ryder..not sure how well he'll score with hille back?

fwds; hard to say how goodes will go up at chf? maybe worth not having from start, seeyin how he goes, then maybe get him? rooey has had great preseason so maybe him instead? brennan..not a fan...i just dont like him haha but could be good...like the pickups of franklin and boomer, both should have stronger season than last year and are well undervalued i think..dangerfield and ziebell could be good, maybe a birdman? chris mayne or staker? hard to say...ben warren..not sure how good he'll be...maybe a ziebell or dangerfield to burton, mayne or staker then upgrade the other one to waite? or downgrade warren to gumby or Moore from port who also plays back, the use that cash elsewhere?
hope that helps....

my teams
backs; hodge, enright, hurn, gilbee, waite, ladson sheppard
(emg: moore, davis)

Mids: ablett, del santo, selwood, burgoyne, martin, moribito
(emg: trengove, shuey)
**NAB form will decide which rooks will actually start

rucks: kreuzer, hille
emg (lobbe, trengove

fwds: riewoldt, pav, franklin, higgins, sylvia, staker, gumby
emg (tapscott, dennis-lane)
**again NAB form will decide which out of 3 cheap fwds will get the nod

thoughts?

 

[drongo_dilla]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

ok, change the 2934th

def
Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Kennelly, Hunt, Waite, Sheppard
(Maguire, Trengove)

mid
Selwood, Pendlbury, Vince, Boak, Burgoyne, Trengove
(Martin, Bastinac)

ruck
Tippett, Hille
(Warnock, Lobbe)

fwd
Riewoldt, Pav, Franklin, Gray, Dangerfield, Polkingthorne, Gumbleton
(Moore, Tapscott)

still 108k in the bank... thinking i can trade a few around (still not sold on Waite or Gray/Boak for their $$$) and try and get Ablett in the mid.

any thoughts?

 

[reimersyoubeauty]

Re: Rate my SuperCoach team

Heres the team I'm sticking with for a while.

Backs- Goddard, Enright, Lake, Hodge, Ladson, Maguire, Sheppard.

EMG: A.Moore and A.Silvagni

Mids- Hayes, Corey, Vince, Pavlich, Cooney, Cunnington.

EMG: L.Jetta, J.Dyson

Rucks- Ottens, Hille

EMG: W.Skipper, S.Mcnamarra

Forwards- N.Riewoldt, J.Brown, A.Goodes, Knights, Rioli, Medhurst, Gumbleton

EMG: Dennis-Lane, T.Walsh

To me I think that's a side that could go a long way the only weak point is Maguire in my mind but at 114,000 if he snags 70 a week with the odd 90 I would be a happy man.

Sheppard, Cunnington are both supposed to be young stars that are really setting the pace. Gumby is fit and firing at the moment and that can't be ignored at $100,000.

Tell me what you guys think of the side?

I have no idea why you would pick Pavlich as a mid.

Medhurst is also not one that looks to be a good pick, but he could end up being your unique pick who does some damage so if you're keen go on him.

Solid team overall.