Rate my SuperCoach team 2012 (Part III)

[Daniels]

Any advice would be appreciated

Take the Richmond goggles off.

Inject way more rookies on the field for starters mate

 

[Cotchin17]

What do you guys think? I need some advice.. moved some players around. Particularly advice on the choice of rookies.

 

[Puntroad]

Take the Richmond goggles off.

Inject way more rookies on the field for starters mate

Would Riewoldt be the first player you take out of that side? I see alot of other people with Deledio, Ellis and Martin or Cotchin.

 

[TheProwler]

Would Riewoldt be the first player you take out of that side? I see alot of other people with Deledio, Ellis and Martin or Cotchin.

Probably the last, he was injured last year so I see him as good value.

Get rid of many of those mid priced players as they will return you low scores and not rise much in price. Better to have one gun and one cash cow than be stuck with too many mid pricers.

 

[Cotchin17]

Hmmmm couldnt get the picture to show up.

My team as it stands.

B: B.Deledio, G.Broughton, S.Hurn, S.McMahon, B.Stratton, M.Clarke, P.Bower (T.Bugg, S.Morris)
M: M.Boyd, J.Redden, T.Cotchin, P.Dangerfield, R.Palmer, J.McCarthy (J.Magner, H.Cunningham)
R: M.Leunberger, D.Hale (J.Giles, J.Redden)
F: L.Franklin, B.Harvey, D.Zaharakis, N.Riewoldt, C.Pearce, J.Porplyzia, A.Saad (S.Kerridge, T.Dickson)

What do you guys think? I need some advice.. moved some players around. Particularly advice on the choice of rookies.

 

[[ToTTi]]

Interested in some feedback on the below:

Backs
Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Adcocck, T.Hunt, B.Ellis, Bugg
(Tomlinson, Spurr)

Mids
Swan, Murphy, Bartel, Hayes, Caddy, Coniglio
(Magner, Kerridge)

Rucks
Cox, Giles
(Redden, Stephenson)

Forwards
Franklin, Pavlich, Martin, Cloke, J.Riewoldt, D.Smith, A.Kennedy
(Smedts, Cameron)

Cheers

 

[IDIG]

I'll post some comments fellas

Think im finished, but any suggestions/ feedback would be greatly appreciated thanks
BACK: B.Deledio, A. Carrazzo, G. Broughton, B. Lake, R. Hargrave, M. Golby, B. Ellis (B, Smedts, T. Bugg)
MIDFIELD: G. Ablett, M. Boyd, T. Cotchin, J. Selwood, J. Caddy, D.Sheil (K. Stevens, J. Magner)
RUCK: D. Cox, I. Maric (J. Giles, J. Redden)
FORWARD: L. Franklin, D.Martin, N. Fyfe, P. Dangerfield, J. Porplyzia, D. Pfeiffer, D. Smith (A. Kennedy, D. Zorko)

Carrots is an interesting one. Not especially proven or durable but I can see why he's been chosen. I'd much prefer him at B4 though because his role is always a worry. Unless there's been a change in role he'll be frustrating as hell for you.
Cotchin fits the mould as the next superpremium. Going into his second full season could explode. I'm a big fan of him actually. Stevens instead of McDonald it looks like, could work out but i think McDonald is a must just at his price and experience.
Maric could work out to be a masterstroke or not a great deal gained over Miles. Not my personal preference but could end up being a keeper.
Zorko injured? You'd have to check that unless you're happy to carry him.

Hey guys, this is my final team, any opinions are greatly appreciated.
Goddard-Scotland-Deledio-Shaw-Lake-Ellis-Bugg (Spurr, Wilkes)
Ablett-Murphy-Boyd-Selwood-C. Smith-McDonald (Magner, Pfeiffer)
Mumford-Giles (Redden, Stephenson)
Franklin-Goodes-Pavlich-Martin-Porplyzia-D. Smith-Saad (Kennedy, Hall)
I have $14,000 left, i would seriously like some advice on my rookies. Thanks in advance

I dont think Spurr and Wilkes will work out to be great cover tbh. JS and/or scoring potential are a worry. No Fyfe is interesting as well, appears to be the first fwd picked this year.

DEF: B Goddard, B Deledio, G Broughton, G Birchall, R Hargrave, M Clarke, B Ellis (T Bugg, S Morris)
MID: G Ablett, M Murphy, M Boyd, P Dangerfield, C Wingard, D Sheil (C Smith, J Magner)
RUCK: S Mumford, I Maric (J Giles, O Stephensen)
FWD: L Franklin, N Fyfe, D Martin, D Zaharakis, J Porplyzia, D Smith, A Hall (T Dickson, A Kennedy)
$59,100 in the bank, thoughts?

Solid
I think Lake has better scoring potential than Hargrave but you'd probably have a better idea about where they're at than me.
I'm assuming you'll eventually move Danger into the fwds as you fill your midfield up.
See above comments on Maric.
With the 59k i actually dont know where you'd spend it haha

Goddard,Scottland,Deledio,H Shaw,Hargrave,B Ellis,Bugg (Mohr,Spurr)
Ablett,Swan,Mitchell,Pavlich,Mcdonald,Magner (C Smith, Hampton)
Cox,Giles (Stephenson,Redden)
Franklin,Martin,Cloke,Harvey,D Smith,Pfeiffer, Saad, (Kerridge,Sexton)
Cash: $176,500. Please leave your thoughts much needed thanks in advanc

Swan is an interesting one this year, not really mentioned in a lot of teams. Quietish preseason, has made a couple of comments about retiring in a couple of years and asked to be taken out of the leadership group concerns me. Underpriced for mine if he's firing due to his injury last year but i'm off him.
Kennedy instead of Hampton looks like an obvious one. Tough to say what to do with that 170k because i can't see it turning anyone into a premium.

After some last minute feedback on my team:
Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Lake, Dempsey, Mohr, Bugg (Ellis, Darley)
Mids: Ablett, Pendlebury, Dal Santo, Watson, Murphy, McDonald (Shiel, Magner)
Rucks: Mumford, Giles (Rowe, Stephenson)
Fwds: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Zaharakis, Smith, Cameron, Hampton (Kerridge, Dell'Olio)
Cash: $14,400. I'm thinking three GWS rookies in the starting forward line up(will the ball even get down their end?) is too many but who to replace them with?

Dempsey could work out to be a great pick but at the same time I don't see him moving into keeper territory at any stage this year. I dont mind Hargrave as at least he at least could become a keeper. 5 gun mid is a nice touch, could work out nicely for you as long as you get your rookies right. Redden looks like he could be decent ruck cover/cow this year so i'd prefer him over both Rowe and Stephenson. Cameron stands out as the one that probably won't be great as a KPF in a bottom side. Kennedy over Hampton for me as well.

Remaining Cap: $1,700

DEF: B Goddard, B Deledio, H Shaw, S Fisher, C Newman, G Broughton, B Lake, (T Mohr, T Bugg)
MID: G Ablett, S Coniglio, C Wingard, K Stevens, J McDonald, J Magner, (D Pfeiffer, D Shiel)
RUCK: M Leuenberger, J Giles, (J Redden, O Stephenson)
FWD: L Franklin, S Johnson, P Chapman, D Martin, T Cloke, D Petrie, D Smith, (A Saad, T Dickson)

Same set up as me so i know the up and down side of what you're doing. Good luck i've got a few different players here and there but for the most part our teams are identical LOL

 

[Sir Grenvold]

Interested in some feedback on the below:

Backs
Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Adcocck, T.Hunt, B.Ellis, Bugg
(Tomlinson, Spurr)

Mids
Swan, Murphy, Bartel, Hayes, Caddy, Coniglio
(Magner, Kerridge)

Rucks
Cox, Giles
(Redden, Stephenson)

Forwards
Franklin, Pavlich, Martin, Cloke, J.Riewoldt, D.Smith, A.Kennedy
(Smedts, Cameron)

Cheers

Decent looking team mate! You've got bigger balls than me going in with only one tried & true ruck but the POD could well work dividends. Was this why you've opted against having either Pendles or GAJ as well?

Here's mine:

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Malceski, Suban, Lake, Ellis, Bugg (Spurr, M. Talia)

Mids: Pendles, GAJ, S. Thompson, Chapman, Parker, Coniglio (Ledger, Magner)

Rucks: Cox, McIntosh (Giles, Redden)

Fwd: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Sidebottom, Porplyzia, D. Smith, Pfeiffer (Smedts, Kerridge)

 

[liam_13]

Set with this except non GWS and Syd rookies. Round 12 $1000

B: Goddard, Bock, Houli, Gilbert, Conca, Ellis, Bugg (Yagmoor, Blee)

C: Ablett, Swallow, Hodge, Cotchin, C.Smith, Shiel (McDonald, Cunningham)

R: Cox, Leuenberger (Giles, Stephenson)

F: Franklin, Harvey, Martin, Petrie, Jones, D.Smith, Kerridge (Hampton, Panos)

Concentrated on Hawks (round 12 vs Bris), Rich (vs GWS), WB (vs Port) and North (vs GC).

My upgrade targets are Birchall, Deledio, Mitchell, Boyd, JRiewoldt or Nahas, and Giansiracusa.

If all goes to plan, in round 12 my spread will be (teams played)
Vs GWS: Conca, Houli, Deledio, Cotchin, Martin, JRiewoldt
Vs GC: Swallow, Harvey, Petrie
Vs Bris: Birchall, Hodge, Mitchell, Franklin
Vs Port: Boyd, Giansiracusa, Jones
Vs North: Ablett, Bock
Vs Adel: Goddard, Gilbert
Vs Carl: Cox
Vs Haw: Leuenberger

Putting all my eggs in one basket but here's hoping it comes off

 

[!_Bazinga_!]

Thanks, IDIG.

just wondering if you know who i should replace Wilkes and Spurr with?

 

[SoupAStars]

What are you guys thoughts on this team:
DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Heppell, Clarke, Ellis, Bugg (Mohr, Spurr)
MID: Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Watson, Ledger, Magner (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC: Mumford, Redden (Giles, Stephenson)
FWD: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Martin, Sidebottom, Smith, Pfeiffer (Hall, Dickson)
CASH: $10,200

Few questions in my mind:

• Is Clarke worth $170K or should I get another rookie? If the latter, what do I do with the money?
• Or, should I go with Davis/Hargrave on the backline?
• Is Pendlebury with the $...downgrade to Swan/Rockliff/Boyd/Mitchell/Thompson?
• Goodes vs Chapman vs Pavlich vs rookie + upgrade DEF rookie to premium

 

[m!nt]

STRESSING OUT

Left it to the last day, haven't touched the team since before NAB cup. Any suggestions to make this an actual decent team?

Click for larger image.

 

[UpTheGuts]

STRESSING OUT

Left it to the last day, haven't touched the team since before NAB cup. Any suggestions to make this an actual decent team?

Click for larger image.

Lots and lots of changes to make. Rookies, Barlow etc.

Good luck

 

[Giansiracusa]

Think i'm settled on this side. Any noticeable changes i should make??

B: goddard, scotland, lake, golby, dempsey, ellis, bugg, hombsch, morris
C: pendlebury, ablett, boyd, selwood, parker, coniglio, shiel, magner
R: cox, giles, redden, stephenson
F: franklin, goodes, fyfe, martin, dangerfield, smith, pfeiffer, wilson, dickson

Thoughts ??

 

[Puntroad]

Thought Barlow was likely to return for R1? Still not worth it?

 

[squashface]

Cox + Gaff
or
Naitanui + Bartel
?????????????

 

[WeSt CoAsT EaGLeS]

Question for you all regarding tonight's game...

Which of these GWS players (forwards) would give me the best value for money?

-Hampton ($113,200)
-Cameron ($113,200)
-Folau ($124,700)
-Tomlinson ($156,600)

Cheers.

 

[mighty]

Can someone pls give me some suggestions on my team thanks

Backs: B.Goddard, B.Deledio, H.Shaw, G.Broughton, J.Grimes, B.Lake, T.Bugg (T.Mohr, B.Smedits)
Mids: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Selwood, S.Comogilo, C.Wingard, J.Mcdonald (D.Shiel, J.Magner)
Rucks: M.Leunenburger, J.Giles, (J.Rudden, O.Stephenson)
Forwards: L.Franklin, N.Fyfe, S.Johnson, D.Martin, P.Dangerfield, D.Smith, A.Kennedy (A.Hall, T.Dickson)

 

[PP34]

Not sure if this will be my final team. Supercoach Gold only projects 1,700 something. Is this something to listen to or ignore?

Anyway here's the team.

B: B.Goddard, H.Scotland, B.Deledio, G.Broughton , B.Lake, B.Ellis, T.Bugg, T.Mohr, L.Spurr
M: G.Ablett, D.Swan, M.Murphy, A.Goodes, J.Caddy, D.Shiel, S.Kerridge, J.Magner
R: S.Mumford, J.Giles, J.Redden, O.Stephenson
F: L.Franklin, N.Fyfe, P.Chapman, J.Lewis, J.Porplyzia, D.Smith, B.Smedts, D.Zorko, A.Hall

Comments?

 

[Ducky Tie]

What are you guys thoughts on this team:
DEF: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Heppell, Clarke, Ellis, Bugg (Mohr, Spurr)
MID: Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Watson, Ledger, Magner (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC: Mumford, Redden (Giles, Stephenson)
FWD: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Martin, Sidebottom, Smith, Pfeiffer (Hall, Dickson)
CASH: $10,200

Few questions in my mind:

• Is Clarke worth $170K or should I get another rookie? If the latter, what do I do with the money?
• Or, should I go with Davis/Hargrave on the backline?
• Is Pendlebury with the $...downgrade to Swan/Rockliff/Boyd/Mitchell/Thompson?
• Goodes vs Chapman vs Pavlich vs rookie + upgrade DEF rookie to premium

I originally had Clarke but traded him out recently. His js isn't great with the players they have to come back and only averaged .6 roughly points per min where as Bouhman aveaged .7 and has good js. I'd then upgrade Heppell to either Broughton or Birchall.

 

[W4RLOCK]

pls rate

guys pls give some feedbacks

 

[Clements]

DEF: Deledio, Shaw, Birchall, Broughton, Hargrave, Golby, Ellis (Bugg, Morris)
MID: Pendlebury, Ablett, Boyd, Watson, Ledger, McDonald (Magner, Shiel)
RUC: Cox, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)
FWD: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Zaharakis, Porplyzia, Smith, Kennedy (Hall, Dickson)
CASH: $30,000

By the time someone replies I might have already changed this

 

[The80s]

Almost finalised my squad. Posted a few pages back. Any feedback will be greatly appreciated.

BACKS: Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Suckling, Hargrave, Ellis, Bugg (Mohr, Smedts)
MIDS: Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Selwood, C Smith, D Smith, (Shiel, Magner)
RUCKS: Mumford, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)
FORWARDS: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Pfeifer, Hall (Kerridge, Dickson)

$30,300 Salary cap remaining

 

[TheProwler]

guys pls give some feedbacks

Looks okay to me. You are taking a risk&reward approach with Lake, Porps and so many rookies starting in your 22 but then it's YOUR team.

 

[viking12]

would love some feedback. final edit of my team

BACKS: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Broughton, Golby, Bugg, Ellis -(Clarke, Morris)

MIDFIELD: Pendlebury, Ablett, Murphy, Boyd, Shiel, Magner - (C.Smith, MacDonald)

RUCK: Mumford, Giles - (Redden, Stephenson)

FORWARD: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, D.Smith, Pfeiffer - (A.Kennedy, T.Dickson)

$37,000 in the bank

dont know which to start in defence
clarke and ellis or bugg and ellis or bugg and clarke