RDFL Thread 2007

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
RDFL Interleague side...

B - N.Hole (SK) W.Kairns (Rom) W.Else (WH)
HB - R.Johnson (SK) J.Allen (Rid) L.Kemp (Kil)
C - J.Bellville (Rid) M.Robertson (Kil) L.McInerney (SK)
HF - D.Salpietro (WH) G.Ploog (SK) B.Morgan (Rom)
F - M.Allen (Rid) D.Cornish(Kil) S.Sims (DR)
R - S.James (SK) M.McInerney (SK) D.Bonnici (SK)
I - J.Jose (DR), C.Laurie (DR), B.Wheelahan (MC), S.Choate (L), C.Collins (L), J.Climas (Rid), R.Dowling (WH), L.Coles (Rid), K.Bullen (MC), D.Helmers (SK)

My opinion, may have forgotten someone, These are the guys from the games I have seen (Except Riddell, picked on rep).
 
Itsmyshow said:
In my view I think it was pretty clear who provided the more valued and fact based opinions in this "Debate" and it certainly wasn't you BB.. But its all irrelevant...
I think that it has been made pretty clear that most on here have no issues with the players, coaches etc of Gissy KA, more the general attitude of the "Club" as a whole.. Remember that there are several other clubs in your district that time and time again have been overlooked for club improvements etc while the power club received the benefit's... I think that is the issue that cuts deeper with alot of people in the "Gissy" area. :thumbsu:
Click to expand...
Yes i feel im going round in circles here, regarding us poaching players you guys came up with one name (Eamon).Regarding these so called benefits, "Time and time again " you say, back this up with some instances, tell me what have we had that others havent.

You keep on about Gisborne getting and taking "everything" its time you put some facts up or stop talking rubbish.

Hey Mongrel, the stuff you were talking about happened 10 years ago, we are a completely different club now, new players, new commitee (same as Kangaroos) things change, i reckon you blokes should give us a bit of a break !
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Itsmyshow said:
RDFL Interleague side...

B - N.Hole (SK) W.Kairns (Rom) W.Else (WH)
HB - R.Johnson (SK) J.Allen (Rid) L.Kemp (Kil)
C - J.Bellville (Rid) M.Robertson (Kil) L.McInerney (SK)
HF - D.Salpietro (WH) G.Ploog (SK) B.Morgan (Rom)
F - M.Allen (Rid) D.Cornish(Kil) S.Sims (DR)
R - S.James (SK) M.McInerney (SK) D.Bonnici (SK)
I - J.Jose (DR), C.Laurie (DR), B.Wheelahan (MC), S.Choate (L), C.Collins (L), J.Climas (Rid), R.Dowling (WH), L.Coles (Rid), K.Bullen (MC), D.Helmers (SK)

My opinion, may have forgotten someone, These are the guys from the games I have seen (Except Riddell, picked on rep).
Click to expand...
How do you reckon they'd go against Gissy ?
 
do any of you blokes actually work for a living. i jumped on for a quick update on what's going on and had to read through 8 pages of posts to realise that everyone hates gisborne (unless you're from gisborne), pickles is now a maggot and bourbon rules.

i reckon i knew all that before i started.

two days!!!!!
 
bearsboy said:
How do you reckon they'd go against Gissy ?
Click to expand...

Competitive... Couldn't say either way, haven't seen much of Gissy this year but on field they are a super side the Doggies....
 
Itsmyshow said:
Very good call Van
Click to expand...

Ill Make an even better call and Say Mongrel for coach and IMS his assistant! If You can't fit Deano in, i couldn't think of a better bloke to coach!

Dean Helmers is your Gary Lyon of the coaching world! Knows a motherload but waits for the right time to put his hand up!

Just a couple of beers will do Deano!;)
 
Trueblueroo said:
Ill Make an even better call and Say Mongrel for coach and IMS his assistant! If You can't fit Deano in, i couldn't think of a better bloke to coach!

Dean Helmers is your Gary Lyon of the coaching world! Knows a motherload but waits for the right time to put his hand up!

Just a couple of beers will do Deano!;)
Click to expand...


Ssshhhh, it was part of my master plan to sneak Deano in right on the bell to scare the crap out of opposition sides and then tear them apart with footballing ability.. And you have just destroyed it...
 
Trueblueroo said:
Ill Make an even better call and Say Mongrel for coach and IMS his assistant! If You can't fit Deano in, i couldn't think of a better bloke to coach!

Dean Helmers is your Gary Lyon of the coaching world! Knows a motherload but waits for the right time to put his hand up!

Just a couple of beers will do Deano!;)
Click to expand...

I'll umpire, plus take the photos and write the preview/review :D
 
Itsmyshow said:
RDFL Interleague side...

B - N.Hole (SK) W.Kairns (Rom) W.Else (WH)
HB - R.Johnson (SK) J.Allen (Rid) L.Kemp (Kil)
C - J.Bellville (Rid) M.Robertson (Kil) L.McInerney (SK)
HF - D.Salpietro (WH) G.Ploog (SK) B.Morgan (Rom)
F - M.Allen (Rid) D.Cornish(Kil) S.Sims (DR)
R - S.James (SK) M.McInerney (SK) D.Bonnici (SK)
I - J.Jose (DR), C.Laurie (DR), B.Wheelahan (MC), S.Choate (L), C.Collins (L), J.Climas (Rid), R.Dowling (WH), L.Coles (Rid), K.Bullen (MC), D.Helmers (SK)

My opinion, may have forgotten someone, These are the guys from the games I have seen (Except Riddell, picked on rep).
Click to expand...

8 Sunbury Players,
5 Riddell,
3 Woodend,
3 Kilmore,
3 Diggers Rest,
2 Romsey,
2 Melton,
2 Lancefield.

Little bit biased?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Cobber21 said:
8 Sunbury Players,
5 Riddell,
3 Woodend,
3 Kilmore,
3 Diggers Rest,
2 Romsey,
2 Melton,
2 Lancefield.

Little bit biased?
Click to expand...

Undefeated and on top mate.. So far the best players I have seen in games, call it biased, call it whatever you like, but I think you could ask most on here and they would agree that with teams etc I try my best not to be biased.. This is what I believe to be the best side.

Last year I wouldn't have had Hole, James, L.McInerney, Helmers, Bonnici (3 not in the league last year) in the side.. This year I would... Easily...
 
matt_nicholls said:
The Roos are on top for a reason. I would add McLellan and take out Sims. Put S. Choate in the forward pocket.
Click to expand...
Macca is just finding his feet now in this competition and is getting better every game he plays, by the end of the year I will probably have him in, still has a little more to do.. Sims is still one of the premier players in the comp.. No way he could be left out and would even have a case for skipper....
 
Cobber21 said:
8 Sunbury Players,
5 Riddell,
3 Woodend,
3 Kilmore,
3 Diggers Rest,
2 Romsey,
2 Melton,
2 Lancefield.

Little bit biased?
Click to expand...

Oh.. And feel free to have a go yourself Cobber :thumbsu::cool:
 
This would be my side.

Not necessarily the best 22 players in the league, but a side put together as if they were to play a game.

B: W. Else (W), W. Kairns (Rom), N. Hole (SK).
HB: B. Johnson (SK), J. Allen (Rid), L. Kemp (K).
C: J. Belleville (Rid), M. McInerney (SK), L. McInerney (SK).
HF: G. Ploog (SK), B. Morgan (Rom), S. Choate (L).
F: D. Salpietro (WH), R. Connellan (Rom), D. Cornish (K).
R: S. James (SK), M. Robertson (K), M. McLellan (Rom).
I: B. Wheelahan (MC), C. Collins (L), R. Dowling (WH), J. Jose (DR).

As you can see its very similar to IMS's, I think he was very close to the money.
 
bearsboy said:
How do you reckon they'd go against Gissy ?
Click to expand...

i have no idea how theyd go bb.but it is an interesting topic.
as for my view about your club earlier.yes it was 10 years ago and u make a fair point.ill button my lip on that topic now.will catch up for a beer with u and kingy soon v.:thumbsu:
 
matt_nicholls said:
This would be my side.

Not necessarily the best 22 players in the league, but a side put together as if they were to play a game.

B: W. Else (W), W. Kairns (Rom), N. Hole (SK).
HB: B. Johnson (SK), J. Allen (Rid), L. Kemp (K).
C: J. Belleville (Rid), M. McInerney (SK), L. McInerney (SK).
HF: G. Ploog (SK), B. Morgan (Rom), S. Choate (L).
F: D. Salpietro (WH), R. Connellan (Rom), D. Cornish (K).
R: S. James (SK), M. Robertson (K), M. McLellan (Rom).
I: B. Wheelahan (MC), C. Collins (L), R. Dowling (WH), J. Jose (DR).

As you can see its very similar to IMS's, I think he was very close to the money.
Click to expand...

no matter who is picked its going to create debate , im going to be completely biased here and say that Damian Janner should be the in a back pocket , not many guys in that backline who could play on a resting rover or a very small forward and also his form/toughness and courage warrants it . Emergencies D. Riely from Diggers Rest and although i rate Belleville as a player and have no doubt he should be in the 22 should he be on the wing???. I agree with IMS C.laurie off the bench can be used as a burst player.
 
billylid said:
no matter who is picked its going to create debate , im going to be completely biased here and say that Damian Janner should be the in a back pocket , not many guys in that backline who could play on a resting rover or a very small forward and also his form/toughness and courage warrants it . Emergencies D. Riely from Diggers Rest and although i rate Belleville as a player and have no doubt he should be in the 22 should he be on the wing???. I agree with IMS C.laurie off the bench can be used as a burst player.
Click to expand...

Good point Billy.. Janner very stiff...
 
matt_nicholls said:
This would be my side.

Not necessarily the best 22 players in the league, but a side put together as if they were to play a game.

B: W. Else (W), W. Kairns (Rom), N. Hole (SK).
HB: B. Johnson (SK), J. Allen (Rid), L. Kemp (K).
C: J. Belleville (Rid), M. McInerney (SK), L. McInerney (SK).
HF: G. Ploog (SK), B. Morgan (Rom), S. Choate (L).
F: D. Salpietro (WH), R. Connellan (Rom), D. Cornish (K).
R: S. James (SK), M. Robertson (K), M. McLellan (Rom).
I: B. Wheelahan (MC), C. Collins (L), R. Dowling (WH), J. Jose (DR).

As you can see its very similar to IMS's, I think he was very close to the money.
Click to expand...

Bonnici not good enough mate???
 
Itsmyshow said:
RDFL Interleague side...

B - N.Hole (SK) W.Kairns (Rom) W.Else (WH)
HB - R.Johnson (SK) J.Allen (Rid) L.Kemp (Kil)
C - J.Bellville (Rid) M.Robertson (Kil) L.McInerney (SK)
HF - D.Salpietro (WH) G.Ploog (SK) B.Morgan (Rom)
F - M.Allen (Rid) D.Cornish(Kil) S.Sims (DR)
R - S.James (SK) M.McInerney (SK) D.Bonnici (SK)
I - J.Jose (DR), C.Laurie (DR), B.Wheelahan (MC), S.Choate (L), C.Collins (L), J.Climas (Rid), R.Dowling (WH), L.Coles (Rid), K.Bullen (MC), D.Helmers (SK)

My opinion, may have forgotten someone, These are the guys from the games I have seen (Except Riddell, picked on rep).
Click to expand...
A few Gissy boys in there :D

Gee, its been a big day boys, bit of fun, hopefully i'll see a few of you blokes on Saturday Cheering for the Mighty red, white and blue :thumbsu:

I might even shout IMS a bourbon :rolleyes:
 
bearsboy said:
A few Gissy boys in there :D

Gee, its been a big day boys, bit of fun, hopefully i'll see a few of you blokes on Saturday Cheering for the Mighty red, white and blue :thumbsu:

I might even shout IMS a bourbon :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Hey, no matter what.. It might today mighty interesting :D

Cant make it Saturday unfortunately.. Mrs wants to go away, with the time spent on football during the year its only fair I suppose.. Still, would like to be watching a game with a drink for once... Lol :cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top